All stories

A boy at five, a masculine woman by choice

Female · DesistedFirst dysphoria 5 → Social transition 9 → Desistance 134.7K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman (desisted, never medically transitioned) who identified as a boy from around age five and socially transitioned at school at age nine, but was never supported by my family and was shut down when I raised medical transition at 16/17. I decided against medical transition after researching surgery results and realizing sex change is impossible — transition would only make 'pretending' easier. I have childhood-onset gender dysphoria that I attribute to internalized misogyny, gender nonconformity in a sexist society, and possibly my autism (diagnosed as an adult, along with childhood ADHD diagnosis at age 7). My dysphoria has greatly decreased over time through deconstructing sexist beliefs and accepting myself as a masculine woman, though some residual discomfort with my chest and voice remains. I am heavily radical-feminist leaning, LGB, gnc, and autistic, and I actively advocate against medical transition for minors and against the concept of innate gender identity.

Full story

I have dealt with gender dysphoria for most of my life, and I never medically transitioned — only socially. I was born female and have always been female. I started calling myself a boy around age five, before I even knew what trans or gender dysphoria were. I would constantly pretend I was a boy, make myself a boy in my imagination and all of my games, picture a boy whenever I pictured myself in my head, draw myself as a boy, and wish I had male anatomy. When my chest first started growing I was actually excited because I didn't see them as breasts but as male pecs, but once they got big enough that they were undeniably breasts and impossible to hide, I wanted to cut them off and frequently thought about doing so myself. I refused to wear a bra for a long time because I didn't want to acknowledge that my body was different from a boy's; I eventually caved and started wearing a sports bra around age 12, which actually helped me begin to get used to my body. I officially socially transitioned at school at age nine — I changed my name and pronouns, and the teacher informed the class I preferred male pronouns. Some people still called me 'she' and didn't use my preferred name, and my teacher explained that while she was happy to call me what I wanted, I couldn't force everyone else to — it was a request, not a demand. I was never given access to the boys' restroom and never requested it, because I knew it would be inappropriate. My family never supported my transition: my mom was very resistant and upset about the whole calling-myself-a-boy thing, they never used my new name or pronouns, and they fought with me about my hair and clothes. I tried to get my mom to call me a boy's name and male pronouns as a young kid but she refused. I was basically forcefully detransitioned when the next school year started. When I officially tried to bring up medical transition at 16/17, I was shut down very quickly. I'm thankful for that now, even though I was upset at the time. I first officially learned about trans ideology in high school, where there was what I describe as an 'indoctrination assembly' where they said 'a woman is someone who feels like a woman.' Because I knew I didn't feel like one, I decided I was actually a man after all. I had also seen many FtM YouTubers transition and wanted everything they got — the voice drop, the fat redistribution. I initially planned to do a full transition, including bottom surgery, as soon as I was able. But when I researched bottom surgery, I couldn't find any results that actually looked real, especially not with female hips. This led me to realize how much of my body couldn't be changed — my height, my bone structure, my genetic makeup, the way my body functions. Any medical problems I had would be female medical problems and I would need to be treated as a female patient. I realized I would forever be female but pretending to be male socially. It was all a game — a game I enjoyed playing at times, but a game nonetheless. I didn't want to spend the rest of my life playing a game and demanding everyone else play along. I came to realize that transition wouldn't really change anything; it would just make it easier to pretend. This, along with lack of parental support, fear of medical complications, and not wanting to cut off healthy body parts when it would be impossible to really live as a man anyway, led me to decide not to pursue medical transition. I also spent hours scrolling through surgery result photos trying to find something that looked even remotely realistic, and even the best ones had something that looked off, especially with the contrasting female skeleton that T wouldn't change. I was around 13 when I finally sat down and told myself, 'okay, you're a girl, it's time to get over it.' This was after I realized that my trying to be a boy was causing people to reject me. I felt a deep sadness and sense of loss at first, since I now had to see myself, even in my head, as a girl, but this diminished over time. I coped by viewing myself as a female version of certain male characters I related to and admired. The discomfort and sense of wrongness never fully went away, though. Then in high school, trans ideology came along and I decided I was trans after all. I have been assessed for autism and had a feedback appointment in late 2022; I was diagnosed with autism as an adult (and had previously been diagnosed with ADHD at age 7). I believe my autism — particularly rigid, black-and-white thinking and tendency to categorize things — contributed to my strong association between masculinity and male, and possibly to my dysphoria. I also have a pattern of adopting identities and rebuilding my entire life around trying to become that identity in full, often based on male characters because I didn't like the female roles I saw in media. I have struggled with identity issues my whole life and am currently trying to figure out who I actually am, what my values are, and what I want in life. I'm near the end of my university degree but am taking a break to work on my mental health. I have never had any trauma prior to my dysphoria. My dysphoria started completely as wanting to be a boy and all symptoms were present at once. I believe it was caused by internalized misogyny — seeing males and females a certain way, thinking of certain traits I wanted to embody as male traits and connecting those to a male body. Growing up, boys talked about their genitals but girls never did; vulvas were taboo, which is probably why I wanted a penis as a kid — I got the impression male genitals were normal and female genitals were weird. I also internalized the constant messages about what girls are 'supposed' to do, and my hatred of being a girl got worse every time someone said 'you're a girl, you shouldn't be doing that.' My mom treated me like her 'living barbie doll' and I know many mothers do this to daughters but not sons. My dysphoria has greatly decreased over time through deconstructing my sexist beliefs, not obsessing over gender, and accepting that I'm a masculine woman. Radical feminism has been particularly helpful — it's helped me start being okay with certain parts of my body for what they are (female) rather than trying to make peace by pretending my body is male. I still sometimes feel like there's supposed to be a bulge, and my chest still bothers me sometimes — it's hard to shake the feeling that they don't belong on my chest. My voice sounds a lot deeper in my head than in reality, and I sometimes wish it were deeper. But overall, the distress has gone from severe and consistent to mild and occasional. I haven't actively thought about cutting off my breasts in years. I remind myself of the risks and realities of medical transition to avoid the urge — recently the urge to go on T just until my voice drops has been strong, but I remind myself of the unwanted side effects. I am a very masculine woman — in personality and expression, though not as much in my body, as I'm quite small (5'2), though I have broad shoulders, narrow hips, and my face and voice are relatively androgynous. I dress entirely in men's clothes (well, boy's technically, because I'm small) and have a masculine haircut. I never wear makeup. I get weird looks when I enter women's restrooms sometimes, and I've been mistaken for male more times than I can count — often people think I'm a teenage boy. I'm used to people thinking I'm weird. I am not straight and have had a hard time accepting that; I was in denial for years. Being in LGB-friendly spaces and seeing LGB people I related to helped me start feeling it was okay. I consider myself heavily radfem-leaning, LGB, gnc, and autistic. I have a lot of resentment toward family members who policed my presentation and shamed me for it, though I'm thankful they prevented me from medically transitioning. I don't feel like I wasted any of my life — I was just doing what I needed to do at the time to be happy. What I regret is not the social transition itself but rather my time spent obsessing over gender, trying to fit into the system, and believing I was a 'man in a woman's body.' I have been very active in the r/detrans community, offering support and advice to others. I've had extensive debates about gender, sex, and trans ideology. I advocate strongly against medical transition for minors, believing no child should be put on puberty blockers or cross-sex hormones. I believe gender dysphoria is a real mental illness but not innate, and that it should be treated with therapy rather than surgery. I believe no one is 'truly trans' and that gender identity is a made-up concept. I support the right of informed consenting adults to transition, but believe transition should be viewed like plastic surgery rather than healthcare. I am critical of trans activism but also critical of conservatives, believing trans activists and conservatives are 'two sides of the same coin.' I support radical feminism and believe gender roles should be abolished entirely.