All stories

Tumblr, a spiritual experience, and a tomboyhood that stopped fitting

Female · Detransitioned94
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who identified as nonbinary for a time after a spiritual experience and Tumblr/queer-community involvement, rooted in a lifelong tomboyhood that became less acceptable as I aged. I desisted after becoming disillusioned with queer-community infighting and bullying, and after realizing other genderfluid people's experiences didn't match mine. I have not described any surgeries, hormones, or suicidal ideation in this transcript. I remain critical of rushed medical transition and of LGBTQ+ community culture, while still enjoying 'costume' feelings from dressing up.

Full story

I was a tomboy from early childhood — I refused dresses but wore girly shirts and played with dinosaurs, and I was in a boys' clique at school while also playing with kids of both sexes in the neighborhood. My mom initially accepted that I didn't want earrings, but as I got older she became increasingly frustrated with me: she got mad that I wouldn't let her pierce my ears, yelled at me for not shaving or wearing makeup, and had me medically tested when I developed a lot of body hair during my tweens. The tests came back normal — XX, no increase in androgens — and my dad is extremely hairy, so it was simply genetic. My mom and I had moved in with a misogynistic 'old friend' of hers, and she started changing around that time. By my tweens I had moved to a new place where the kids seemed not to acknowledge the existence of tomboys, and all the tomboys in media were wearing makeup and skirts. I went through a lot of things I don't want to fully discuss, but they led me to Tumblr, where I was looking for peers who related to me and a strong need to prove myself right in arguments, which I had been raised to do. I had a spiritual experience that gave me strange feelings that I was nonbinary. Combined with being criticized for being a tomboy and being critical of womanhood as tomboys tend to be, this led me into intersectional feminism and the queer community. When I dressed and acted like a man, I expected people to treat me as a man. I had hoped that by looking like a man I would be more likely to get banks to fund my projects. I was scared of looking like a woman. I eventually realized that other genderfluid people's experiences didn't relate to mine, and I became disillusioned — the first two genderfluid people I met said intersex shouldn't be involved in the queer community. As I got older, my tomboyism was less accepted by the world around me, and I wanted to follow my peers while still fighting to be myself. I was incredibly lost and confused, and where I thought I found solace I actually found more fights and self-doubt. A big part of why I desisted was because I had been bullied by the very culture I had admired. I found aggression within LGBTQ+ spaces — if you question another person, it's 'bared teeth' until you prove to everyone that they're dumb. I identified as ex-nonbinary and detransitioned, going back to identifying with my birth sex as a female. I also described myself as someone who stopped taking medication as part of detransitioning. I've reflected a lot on how beauty standards, photoshop, body-positivity campaigns, yaoi/yuri anime, and shifting feminism contributed to a culture that eventually pushed people toward changing gender and toward extreme gender stereotypes. I've advised others against rushing into irreversible procedures like circumcision when the underlying issue is dysphoria, and I've discouraged someone from returning to testosterone, comparing missing the feeling of T to missing hydrocodone or using sugar for a mood boost. I've also commented on how therapists may be under job pressure to approve hormones quickly rather than investigate underlying issues. I've described my own friendship history as: as a kid a tomboy with a male clique, as a teen a few close friends of different sexes, as an adult fewer close friends, and now I'd love to have a female clique. I've talked about how I never learned to 'preen' myself because my mom bought all my outfits as a kid and most of my current clothes are old or donated. I still enjoy the 'costume high' of dressing up — makeup, a suit, a gay outfit, or a plague doctor mask — and I compare it to the feeling crossdressers describe.