All stories

Pants and a hoodie after years of calling femininity a performance

Female · Detransitioned175
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned bisexual woman who now lives as a woman. I view being trans as a choice and lifestyle rather than an innate fact, and I criticise both the 'real vs fake trans' framing and the way transition is pushed as the only option for dysphoric people. After detransitioning I found femininity uncomfortable and impractical at first, and now mostly dress in pants and a hoodie, treating gender expression as a performance I can engage with on my own terms. I have worked through internalised misogyny and now encourage other women to embrace nonconventional or gender-nonconforming ways of being female. I have not described any medical details, mental health history, or suicidal ideation in this material.

Full story

I am a bisexual woman who has detransitioned and now lives as a woman. I came to the view that being trans is not something someone can simply 'know,' because I see it as ultimately a choice and a lifestyle rather than a concrete reality; in my view, anyone who pursued transition was legitimately trans at the time, and I think the 'real trans / fake trans' framing is toxic because it implies detransitioners were not truly trans and that this is why they desisted. I have been critical of how transition is pushed as the only possible response for dysphoric people, and how detransitioners are sometimes told they 'weren't actually trans,' which I feel fails to address their concerns. I have described myself as being called 't*rfy' while also being a bisexual woman attracted to trans women, and I have offered support to trans women navigating dating, telling them to focus on hobbies and what they love rather than their dating life, sex life, or body, and to be gentle on themselves. In 2022 I spent considerable time advising another person who was distressed about gendered thinking and femininity. I told them that women don't think in 'gender neutral' or 'male' or 'female' ways, that no matter how you think you can still be a woman, and that they seemed to be thinking about it too much. I suggested they had internalised misogyny to work through, and that they did not have to be overly feminine — that they could feel 'girlbossy' one hour and 'female James Dean' the next. I noted that it is uncomfortable not having a fixed identity and hard living as a nonconventional or unfeminine woman, but that comfort and freedom can be found by sticking with it. I also pushed back on the idea that women must relate to hypersexual music, calling it the biggest representation of hyperfemininity and far removed from regular womanhood, and I recommended looking to nonconventional women — Courtney Barnett, Sharon van Etten, Lucinda Williams, female UFC fighters, lesbian musicians and artists, female sportswomen — as templates, or carving out a 'third space of radical gender nonconformity.' I spoke about my own experience re-entering femininity: I said I will sometimes act super macho and say crass things as a form of parodying gender norms, and that I am aware gender expression is 'all a performance, but a performance you can potentially find your space/some comfortability in.' I described dipping my toe back into femininity after detransition: 'when I started dipping my toe in femininity again I went quite fem because I was like oh!! I can do this too??? and then I realised how absolutely uncomfortable and impractical it is to wear cute clothes all the time!' I said I now mostly live in pants and a hoodie and will dress up when I actually want to, and that I 'realised how much of a performance feminity is.' I also related to disliking women's deodorant. I advised the person to allow themselves to think gendered thoughts rather than harshly trying to make them stop, saying that black-and-white language like 'need to make that stop' increases cognitive discomfort and that if you stop hyperfocusing on stopping the thoughts, 'counter-intuitively, it will fade.' In 2024 I complimented other community members on their appearance and feminine styling, encouraging them to experiment with accessories and styles — 'some hoops do wonders in my experience!' — and telling one person they looked 'so cool and beautiful' with 'fabulous style.' I have not described my own transition steps, medical interventions, surgeries, mental health diagnoses, trauma, or family situation anywhere in this material.