All stories

A year on estrogen, then stopping for reasons no one expected

Male · Detransitioned85
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a nonbinary person born male who stopped MtF hormone therapy (estrogen, spiro, progesterone) in March 2022 after about a year on E, reaching a B cup. I stopped because my sex drive dropped and I never saw myself presenting as a woman; I still identify as nonbinary, wear makeup occasionally, bind for androgyny, and am considering top surgery while keeping my male name. I've experienced hostility in trans communities for being he/they and not fitting binary expectations, and I now believe people shouldn't transition for social reasons but only for genuine physical discontent. I have a master's degree, a six-figure job, and I'm in my 30s nearing 40.

Full story

I was born male and have always identified as nonbinary rather than strictly trans. I started estrogen and spironolactone along with progesterone at some point, and by March 2022 I had been on E for about a year, reaching roughly a B cup. Around that time I decided to stop HRT altogether, initially quitting spiro first while continuing E until I could talk to my doctor on a Wednesday. My reasons for stopping were mixed. I noticed some good effects from estrogen — my hair growing forward again and looking younger — but my sex drive dropped and I realized I didn't actually see myself presenting as a woman. I never felt binary; I wished I did, but I just don't. I described feeling comfortable enough at a certain point on E that I even stopped lasering my beard hair, and I was looking into lowering my hormone levels to allow more of my natural testosterone back. I've done a lot of work on my presentation in both directions. I've been lifting weights to keep up muscle tone, doing voice therapy to bring my voice into a neutral range so it's hard to determine my gender from voice alone — my voice coach even records audiobooks for both female and male characters, which inspired me. I've lasered most of my facial hair except for a mustache and chin area I sometimes let grow. I bind when I want to be more androgynous, and I've been considering top surgery to remove my breasts while using breast forms on my more feminine days, though I'm torn because surgery scares me. I go by a more feminine name that's close to my original male name, and I have no plans for a legal name change; gender marker changes in many US states are easy and I've considered that. On stopping estrogen, I asked whether I could quit cold turkey or needed to taper, and how much breast growth I'd lose. I was told that after a year on E, breasts shrink a little and become less soft but still look like breasts — enough that binding was still needed even on full testosterone. I noted that for MtF transition, E effects are mostly reversible when stopped, outside of breast growth removable by surgery, whereas testosterone has harder-to-reverse effects like hair growth and voice change. I've experienced a lot of friction in trans communities. I get hate on Reddit for being nonbinary, using he/they pronouns, and taking MtF HRT — to the point where I considered that sharing myself on here was bringing more negativity into my life than it should. I feel often non-accepted within some trans communities and I'm not a stickler for pronouns, so I stick to real-life people who can see the real me. I have a master's degree and work a six-figure job; I spent a good chunk of my 20s traveling after my bachelor's degree, and I'm in my 30s, nearing 40. I have friends across the spectrum — an ftm friend who is happy being binary despite struggles dating, and another ftm friend considering reversing everything because being trans has made dating extremely hard. I've met people through Bumble BFF and value friendships based on relating rather than gender. I don't look at gender anymore when making friends, just whether we relate. My current thinking is that gender is largely a social construct — from clothes to behavior. I act more feminine than some women yet society deemed me a man and them a woman. I support people for whom transition works, but I believe nobody should transition because they think they'll be better off in society; rather, they should have a strong discontent with their physical traits, not just feel put down as a woman or by male society. I've shared my experience openly to help others think it through, explicitly saying I'm not trying to scare anyone. I'm proud of being born male and happy to leave my name and marker alone, and I like that I was born with a penis. I'm still nonbinary, still wear makeup from time to time, and I'm navigating an androgynous middle ground rather than a full binary detransition.