All stories

Cross-dressing instead of transitioning — and advising others the same

Male · Desisted43
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a male who has never medically transitioned but has lived with autogynephilia and gender dysphoria, and I manage it through a harm-reduction routine of limited cross-dressing rather than transition. I see my condition as partly a 'gift' — a vacation from reality — and I accept that at 6' tall and heavily masculine I would never pass if I transitioned. I have not found a therapist who understands AGP or gender dysphoria and mostly act as an informal advisor to others considering HRT. I remain male-identified, critical of uncritical transition, and hold that sex is strictly chromosomal while gender is separate.

Full story

I have never medically transitioned, and I want to be clear about that up front — what I'm describing is a lifelong pattern I've learned to manage rather than a detransition story. I was born male, I am male, and I've lived my whole life as a man, but I've dealt with what I've come to call autogynephilia (AGP) and gender dysphoria for as long as I can remember. Physically I'm very masculine — I'm 6' tall with huge shoulders and hands — and I've long accepted that if I ever did transition I would never become the woman I fantasize about. That realization is one of the main reasons I never went down that road; I didn't want to 'settle for less.' I've also told people considering hormones that if taking them doesn't accelerate the desire to become a woman, that's a tell that you probably aren't trans, because hormones usually 'seal the deal' for those who are chemically oriented that way. I've warned others that HRT brings irreversible changes and that the decision shouldn't be made without a lot of thought. My own coping method is what I call harm reduction — a concept borrowed from addiction therapy. I limit the behavior to a set time and place so it can't damage the rest of my life. In practice that means I get up in the morning, dress up a little, masturbate, and then I'm good for the day. I used to spend an hour doing a full dress-up with makeup, masturbate immediately, and take everything off; now I dress up less so the transition back isn't as much work. I've described this cycle openly: 'One hour dressing/making up, jerk off, remove everything.' I've found that a limited cross-dress once a day plus a release satisfies the compulsion to transition, and I've compared the principle to low-dose estrogen therapy. I've considered the three options I think exist for dealing with AGP: transition, harm reduction, or abstinence. Abstinence strikes me as the hardest, and it helps to have someone you care about supporting you — I've noted that many men find they value their marriages and existing lives more and are happier than they'd be giving it all up. I've strongly recommended seeing a therapist for that route, while also saying I've yet to find one who has a clue about AGP or gender dysphoria, so I tell people not to expect more than a sounding board. More broadly I recommend finding a good neutral therapist — someone who doesn't generally treat trans people, since I think most of them are biased — mature but not so old that generational bias gets in the way. I also suggest journaling and making a pros-and-cons list of living as female versus male, and not assuming you have to be either. Over time my view of my cross-dressing and AGP has softened. I now see it as 'somewhat of a gift' — I get to take a vacation from reality whenever I want. I've also said the best thing is to be yourself, whatever that is, and not to let other people define you. I've described myself as a combination of a hyper-masculine self and someone who desires to be feminine in mind and body, which I consider a good thing because I like being strong and confident. I could never pass as a female, but I've gone out many, many times dressed and been struck by how no one seems to notice or pay attention. On hormones specifically, I've shared that they do crazy things to one's libido — for me it made me constantly horny, while for others libido subsides — and I've told people that the longer you're on hormones the less likely you are to regain your old physique, though there's no certainty it couldn't happen as T levels return. I've also observed that when a transition is right it looks natural and smooth, and when it isn't it looks anything but right. On gender more broadly, I think the push to escape gender stereotypes — how one is supposed to dress, makeup, jewelry, or women presenting very masculine with short hair and no makeup — is more about avoiding stereotypes than about one's actual gender. I hold that gender is not sex, and that sex is determined strictly by one's chromosomes. I've also told people they can use whatever name they're comfortable with without legally changing it. I don't describe any activism beyond offering this advice and perspective to others online.