All stories

Therapist said HRT at 12 — nightly panic attacks followed

Female · Detransitioned114
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman, over five years detransitioned and close to four years reidentified as of May 2020. I transitioned after being a trans kid whose therapist confirmed I needed HRT and surgery, and I used testosterone and a chest binder before detransitioning. Over the last decade my dysphoria-driven nightly panic attacks and sleeplessness resolved substantially through aging, deconstructing my feelings about gender, and being around gender-nonconforming women, though some dysphoria remains. I have endometriosis and PCOS, and a bad reaction to Depo-Provera caused eight months of continuous bleeding after discontinuing it. I am critical of transition being presented as an easy fix, of therapy that only affirms or only converts, and of language describing detransitioned bodies as 'ruined,' while opposing mean-spirited attacks on trans-identified kids.

Full story

I grew up feeling ugly, and right before I started transitioning I didn't really feel ugly — I just felt mismatched and wrong and so, so tired. I fantasized about zipping and clawing off the parts of my body that felt like they shouldn't be there, while still frequently feeling I looked good, though too soft and feminine, in the mirror. There were days I wished I could just be happy as a girl, and more days when I wished I could have just been born a boy. I don't think there were any days where I really thought 'this is good' until I actually started transitioning, and then for a while I was much happier being trans-identified. I was a trans kid. My parents tried the route of getting me to a therapist rather than transitioning, but to their surprise my therapist only confirmed that I was trans and needed HRT and surgery. I went on testosterone at some point — I've noted that it took a long time, probably more than a year, for my body to become curvier again after stopping, and I'm actually curvier now than I was before I started T. I also bound my chest: before binding my relationship with my chest wasn't good but I could tolerate baggy clothes and jackets, and after I started binding I got so used to a flat chest that going out without one became unthinkable. I'd regularly wear one for 12+ hours a day and felt worse than ever when I had to take it off, until the other negative effects of binding got so bad that I had to break the cycle, which was hard as hell. I used an androgynous nickname based on my given name for a little while during transition, and now I go mostly by my full given name. I think I would have just stayed with the transition name if it had been even a little bit neutral sounding. I'm now over five years detransitioned and close to four years reidentified — I'm a detransitioned woman. I'm over five years detrans and close to four years reidentified as of May 2020. On medical issues: I have both endometriosis and PCOS. I took Depo-Provera and it made me feel awful, feminized me in ways I didn't want, and when I discontinued it my hormones were thrown so out of whack that I bled continuously for eight months. I'm critical of birth control and note it doesn't leave me pain- and side effect-free, and I'm skeptical that women critical of birth control wouldn't also be critical of psych meds. On mental health: in the last decade I've gone from barely sleeping because I had nightly dysphoria-induced panic attacks to not feeling dysphoric at all most days. Some of that improvement was aging, some was deconstructing my feelings about gender, some was letting go of my dysphoria as a source of validation and giving myself permission to stop focusing on it, and some was being around other gender-nonconforming women. It's not totally cured. I also commented that if someone's been breaking down all the time, something intended to kickstart them out of that would probably do more harm than good, but if they're making good progress in recovery and ready to process difficult things it can work wonders. On social experience: I'm a detransitioned woman but a lot of the time I get called 'he' — I think it's often because people assume I'm trans and are trying to be considerate rather than because they actually think I'm male. I get mistaken for a guy on a regular basis, but that doesn't mean I am one or have to identify as one. I'm doing better with it now and don't have the kinds of reactions I used to, though public bathrooms will probably always be somewhat anxiety-inducing because that just comes with being gender-nonconforming. Accepting myself as female doesn't mean looking feminine or removing all my body hair — a lot of the detransitioned and reidentified women I know don't shave and still wear masculine clothing. On sexuality and community: I've engaged with other detrans people on other social media and in real life prior to r/detrans, and I've been baffled and saddened by some of what I've seen described as detrans behavior in the reddit detrans community. I've discussed reclaiming a slur for lesbian, directed disproportionately but not exclusively at masculine lesbians, and told someone I wouldn't for a second read them as anything other than a lesbian. On attitudes toward transition: I don't think wanting to go shirtless or wanting attention are good reasons to make the decision to transition, and I recommend really thinking about what will be healthy long-term. I'm critical of the idea that therapy alone fixes dysphoria — by and large therapists either affirm trans identity or practice conversion therapy, and the kind of therapy people imagine doesn't exist. I find it insulting when people refer to our bodies and minds as 'ruined' as if we're disgusting and beyond repair. I was a trans kid and won't approve of something obviously mean-spirited that would have hurt me and not helped me reidentify, but I also don't believe there's anything wrong with these kids that needs fixing by dissociation from their sex and medical intervention. I think one of the most damaging things about my transition was that it prevented me from unpacking internalized misogyny — it's not possible to undergo female socialization and not absorb any of it, and whether that's causing part or all of gender dysphoria is worth unpacking either way. I suggested someone do a SurveyMonkey survey of detransitioned people, noting a study that concluded there are barely any of us by asking current gender clinic patients if they'd detransitioned.