All stories

Diagnosed at 51, seven years on herbal estrogen, then a church pew

Male · DetransitionedTransition 51 → Detransition 6050
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, diagnosed with GID at 51 after already marrying, having children, and divorcing, and I lived as a woman for about seven years using herbal estrogen (never had surgery) before returning to living as a man in my 60s after a spiritual awakening following my mother's death. I now present as a man but keep my breasts, long hair, and smooth skin, and I consider my prior life superficial. I attribute my transition partly to body dysmorphia about my flat chest, childhood trauma around my absent father, and rebellion against how women treated me. I am critical of the transition industry and have encouraged others to pursue malpractice lawsuits against therapists. I am a celibate, church-going detransitioned man with no social life outside church.

Full story

I was born male. I was diagnosed with gender identity disorder at 51, by which point I had already been married, had children, gotten divorced, and put my children through college. I started growing breasts with herbal estrogen — the hospital offered me the full program, but I wasn't going to have my penis removed out of respect for my girlfriend. I lived for seven years presenting as a female; I was a social butterfly at the gay bar, had lots of sex with younger men, and attracted much younger men and women who wanted me as a friend because I always smiled. I transitioned in my 50s and detransitioned in my 60s. I never had surgery, so I don't really consider myself a detransitioner in the surgical sense. After my mother died I had a spiritual awakening that caused me to seek communion in an ancient church, and I began living as a man again. I also reconciled with my girlfriend; she got off drugs, but without drugs she was unable to have sex and became socially reclusive. I went from being sexually active to the point of dangerous promiscuity and a party girl to a celibate man with no social life outside church. It's been a difficult road, but it's worth it to me — I feel my former life was superficial with no real purpose. On causes: I definitely had body dysmorphia with regards to my breasts. Even for a man I was flat chested — you could see my ribs under my nipples, and even in the army doing pushups all the time I never developed pectoral muscles. When I started herbal estrogen I reasoned I'd have a long way to go before people would notice, but I soon found even the mild dosage of estrogen I was getting was addictive, and I loved having jiggle on my chest. To me, breasts were a symbol of maternal instinct. I always felt I had more parental love than my children's mother. Our youngest child had a medical condition as a baby and could only sleep when held upright in my arms; I went a month without sleeping at night, holding an infant to my chest, and my long hair surrounded his head like an orgone accumulator. Losing my children to divorce was the worst trauma of my life. Growing breasts was my statement that I am a nurturing caregiver too. Women have treated me like crap from the day I was born. It wasn't my mother's fault — she was abandoned with two babies, one being myself, a newborn, and she was overwhelmed. Not having a role model at home, I made bad choices in love and ended up with damaged women all the time. Living as a woman was my rebellion; I was tired of paying for the sins of other men, until I realized Christ did the same for me. Growing up, the terms "Dad" or "father" were the worst insults my mother could make — "You're just like your father," an alcoholic crazy person who never saw us and never paid a dime in child support. When I had children of my own, they called me "Abu" because it was a word for father that didn't hold negative connotations for me. Even today, though I present as a man, there are some things I won't give up. My breasts are a joy — they never got that big so I can still hide them under loose shirts. I wear my hair long. I had pretty well gotten rid of my bodily hair through epilation and hair inhibitors; my facial hair is too sparse to grow out, but I have to shave it. Even though I live as a man, I keep my body and face smooth through epilation and shaving. On sexuality and identity: I used to joke, but was serious actually, that I would prefer to be called bitch or faggot by a man, because that meant there was a good possibility of some hard core sex. At the same time I had to accept that not every man wanted to fuck me or dominate me. Just before I detransitioned, a cute guy came up to me outside a bar and asked "Do you have a light sir?" I took that as indicating he was hetero and didn't want to relate to me as a potential hookup but was still interested in friendly conversation. Immediately two women started haranguing him on how disrespectful he was, and I had to jump to his defense — I didn't present as a woman to bully people and I don't want others to bully people on my behalf. I've advised others to keep records of their progress and of the doctors and therapists involved, saying two years on hormone blockers shouldn't be irreversible but they may have a case for a future lawsuit. I've told a young person harmed by therapists that they have a case for malpractice, that class action suits are coming, and that they should save documents, write out their story and a victim impact statement: "It's only when the industry gets hit with lawsuits that they will back off. This was child abuse. It has to stop." Before I got diagnosed I read Janice Raymond's "Transsexual Empire" — she'd be called a TERF today, but she had a point; femininity is about more than having an orifice in front. I think it's really important to be clear in your head about your real motivations for wanting to be a woman. I've also recommended an RT documentary about MTFs in the USA who detransitioned or warn others not to get SRS, noting surgeons aren't gods and can't make a real vagina, and some men interviewed had serious problems post surgery. Back in the 80s I was living with my future wife in a northern town on the edge of the wilderness; one Saturday night we noticed we were wearing matching outfits — Greb Kodiak boots, Levis jeans, and flannel bush shirts — and since we were similar in height we switched pants and shirts to see if anybody would notice. Nobody noticed.