All stories

A woman who never transitioned, in detrans spaces anyway

Female · Desisted120
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted-adjacent... no — I am a female who has never transitioned or detransitioned, but who participates in detrans and gender-critical communities. I view transition as rooted in internalized misogyny and restrictive gender socialization, and I advocate self-acceptance of the female body and female role models over medical transition. I hold strongly gender-critical views and am critical of trans activism. I have not described any personal transition, medical, or mental-health history.

Full story

I have never identified as trans or detransitioned; I am a female commenter who has spent time in gender-critical and detrans-adjacent spaces online, mostly in 2019 and 2020. I have consistently argued that sex is real and binary, and that sexuality is tied to sex. In September 2019 I pushed back hard against the idea of a 'girldick,' writing that 'a penis is a male sex organ' and that a penis rendered non-functional by hormones is not a clit. I also objected to intersex conditions being brought into debates about trans-identified males, describing intersex as 'a developmental, anatomical condition' with 'reliable measures,' while calling transgenderism 'a mental illness at best, a fetish at worst.' My core analysis of why people transition centers on internalized misogyny and restrictive gendered socialization. In a long February 2020 comment addressed to someone struggling with being female, I wrote that 'these feelings stem from internalized misogyny, which is encouraged by the way society portrays femininity,' and that I don't know 'any female who has not experienced at least some internalized misogyny.' I argued that sexist stereotypes and norms hurt everyone, that 'an adult female who enjoys more stereotypically masculine endeavors is still a woman,' and that thinking 'the grass is greener' for all males 'is rooted in sexism.' I recommended 'finding some female role models' and 'radical acceptance of the female body without sexist judgement,' and I acknowledged that overcoming internalized misogyny is difficult because these biases 'formed subliminally over your lifetime.' In May 2020 I commented on a thread about discomfort with female puberty, saying 'Not trans or detrans, but as a bio woman yes to all,' and describing these as 'common sentiments for many developing females.' I noted that 'often the discomfort and self-hatred go away once we get older, get used to our developed bodies, reflect on internalized misogyny, and realize we don't need to bow to society's stereotypes and expectations.' I have also argued that passing for many trans people is overstated outside of carefully angled photos, and I have been combative toward trans activists online, telling one commenter to 'take your delusion back to your echo-cult' and accusing the TRA community of 'rampant and aggressive silencing of dissenting points of view.' I have acknowledged that 'restrictive and sexist socialization is one of the deepest roots of the problem leading people to transition.'