These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a 30-year-old prospective step-parent who posted in January 2020 worried that my fiancee's 15-year-old daughter — who came out as trans about a month earlier and immediately asked for testosterone — would regret transitioning. I noted she only presents as male at school and therapy while living as a girl at home, and I worried the identity felt trendy or attention-seeking rather than sincere. I am not against transgender people, but I hoped she would wait and try living as "he" everywhere before considering T, and I was grateful to discover the detransition community. I have no personal transition history; my current identity is a non-transitioned concerned family member. No suicidal ideation, self-harm, or mental health conditions are described in my account.
Full story
I am 30 years old and I posted on r/detrans in January 2020 because I was worried about my stepchild's potential for regret. My fiancee has a daughter who is 15 and just started high school. About a month before I posted, she came out to us as transgender. We are all very supportive — her mom, her dad, and I — of whatever makes her comfortable, and we use female pronouns at home because when we asked about pronouns she said she was "not ready" to go by he full time.
What confused me was the split between settings. At school she goes by "he," and in therapy — a therapist the school suggested for LGBTQ+ kids — she is "he." But at home she is still who she's always been: she wears dresses, makeup, fake nails, and watches movies I would consider girly. Nobody makes her do any of this; she chooses everything herself when clothes shopping. She hasn't really tried to appear male beyond a shorter haircut and what she calls "not so girly clothes" — still female clothes, like a flannel shirt and tight ripped jeans, and female shoes.
Her history of coming out was rapid: last year she came out to us as pan, then this past summer she cut her hair short and said she was non-binary but still used "she," and then the trans "come out" was about a month ago, at which point she immediately mentioned testosterone. On day one of being called "he" at therapy she said she wanted T. Her mother pointed out the contradiction — "you want T but don't want me to call you he" — and she had no real answer.
In therapy she has sessions where she can be alone with the therapist or have her mom there. Every time she wants her mom in the room she flips out about HRT and basically looks to the therapist to try to push mom. Her mother keeps telling her "you'll be 18 in less than 3 years" because she's so worried her daughter will regret this. Mom doesn't say the doubt to her daughter directly, but she talks to me about her worry about insincerity. Mom's stated position to her daughter is: "while you're still a teen and growing and developing I don't feel comfortable letting you do this" — regardless of whether she's appearing as a boy, girl, or anything in between — and that she can decide for herself at 18.
When mom asked what she thinks she'll get from HRT, her only answer was that she wants her voice lower. When mom asked if she's prepared for everything else — body hair, mood changes — she doesn't respond. I suggested to mom that she should perhaps try being "he" everywhere for a while before even thinking about T — "don't you want to try those shoes on before you run the marathon?"
I was genuinely trying to understand rather than attack. I said explicitly that none of us are against transgender people, but it "just feels trendy," and I worried she was pushing hard for T while appearing to want attention. I compared it to my own adolescence — I have tattoos I got as a teen that I regret — and I noted that every trans story I'd heard involved relief at finally being open and cringe at being called their birth gender or name, whereas this felt like two different people depending on the setting, which felt inauthentic to me. I had the strongest feeling that if she stuck this out she would regret it. I was also worried she might be second-guessing and wanting to make a quick decision to "get it over with," or that she was afraid of upsetting her parents even though they're supportive.
I came to r/detrans because I had never heard of detransitioning until I found the sub, and I was grateful to find a community that would be accepting if she went from she to he and then back to she, just in case. I learned a lot from the responses — I said "I had no idea theres this huge grey area like this" and thanked people repeatedly for info I'd never heard of. I wasn't sure whether I could talk to her directly or whether she'd shut me out, but I wanted her to be comfortable no matter what and I wanted to help.
I don't have any personal experience of transition or detransition myself; my concern was entirely about my stepchild and my own memories of impulsive decisions as a teenager.