All stories

Feminist philosophy, France, and a lifelong misgendering

Female · Desisted99
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I never transitioned or detransitioned; I'm an older woman who frequently gets misgendered and who holds firm gender-critical feminist views. I believe there's a social-contagion epidemic of body dysphoria among young women, tied to media sexualization, and I argue humans cannot change sex even though body dysphoria is real. I support women-only spaces, sports, and restrooms while not begrudging personal fashion choices, and I financially support groups helping young people question transition. I read feminist philosophy (Beauvoir, Wittig) and have lived in France. I have no personal transition or detransition timeline.

Full story

I never transitioned or detransitioned — I'm an older woman who has simply spent her life observing these questions from the outside, and who has ended up with firm views about sex, women's rights, and what I see as an epidemic of body dysphoria among young people. I have never identified as trans, and I have never detransitioned. I've said plainly that I'm "just an old lady who frequently gets misgendered." In casual situations — a grocery clerk, for instance — I sometimes correct them, and sometimes I misgender them back "for fun," though it embarrasses me if I'm with friends. There's really nothing that can be done about it; some of us just look different. On the broader question, I believe body dysphoria among adolescents and young women is quite high, and understandably so given the sexualization of women in the media. I cross-reference this with anorexia and bulimia. I've cited the figure of something like a 500% increase in girls and young women presenting as gender dysphoric compared to ten years ago, and while I don't think it's universal, I describe it as "an epidemic of a sort (social contagion)." I hold a philosophical position that stating a man is — or can transition into — a woman is absurd. I've welcomed trans-identified men who speak reasonably for women's rights around safe spaces and female sports, and I've noted how hard it is to voice such opinions without being called "Nazi," "Killer," or "Far right." I'm waiting for the day when more cross-dressing trans-aligned men will just admit they're men. I don't begrudge people who enjoy dresses, long hair, makeup, or drag shows — plenty of women enjoy those things too, though not me; I was never interested in drag shows or beauty pageants. But I draw the line at restrooms, locker rooms, and women's sports: those should be segregated, "let women shine." I'm a reader and something of a feminist. Favorite books include Nancy Bauer's "Simone de Beauvoir, Philosophy, and Feminism" and Beauvoir's "The Second Sex" in the newer translation. I admire Monique Wittig, the last-generation French feminist who was rather butch — all the more remarkable given how much more femme French women tend to be than Americans or Brits, speaking from experience having lived in France for a while. I also admire Joan of Arc, whom I pity for being killed for cross-dressing among other transgressions. I support organizations trying to help young people question medical transition — I have a paid subscription to one group's Substack simply to support their efforts, saying "if it helps some it's worth it," even though it wouldn't be for everyone. When asked whether gender dysphoria is "real," I answer that it's not real in the sense that humans can't or don't ever change sex — simply — while acknowledging that body dysphoria itself is certainly real. I've also offered gentle counsel to others grieving their former selves, noting that grief is most often defined as sorrow for the loss of another person, not one's former self, so it's hard to fathom, but that it will happen eventually if you live long enough. I've found internet comments sometimes rather nasty, ageist among them, and prefer respect for the real people around you.