All stories

A married ally with three sisters in the debate

Female · Desisted138
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a woman who has never transitioned or detransitioned; I post here as an ally concerned about the medical and social treatment of gender-questioning youth. I am married to a husband and have a sister with Asperger's who at one point questioned being nonbinary and now runs trans groups, plus a nonbinary sister-in-law married to a trans woman. I have a mother with apparent Munchausen by proxy and my own mild tactile sensitivity issues with clothing. I want a middle ground that respects certain trans adults while acknowledging the real risks of hormones and puberty blockers to young people. I remain critical of how the topic is taught and discussed, and I am not detransitioned.

Full story

I have never identified as trans or detransitioned; I have posted in this community as an ally and observer. I am a woman, married to a husband, with at least one sister and a sister-in-law (my husband's sister or my sibling's spouse, referred to as my SIL) who identifies as nonbinary and is married to a trans woman. I have a milder tactile sensitivity to over- and understimulation: when I wore leggings I wanted to claw my skin off, and I would say to my husband, 'Why do I have to have legs??' I started stealing my husband's sports shorts and was much happier; some women's running shorts are also comfortably loose for me. My sister questioned for a while whether she was nonbinary, dresses pretty masculine, has much stronger tactile sensitivity than me, and is diagnosed with Asperger's. She has many online friends who have Asperger's and came to identify as trans a couple of years later, which struck me as a strong pattern. That same sister works to 'educate' people and runs trans groups, and insisted to me that there were no negative side effects or complications of puberty blockers, that it was just 'putting puberty on pause,' and that the only reason anyone would oppose them is that they hate trans kids. I found that denial of risks troubling. I also have a mother who appears to have Munchausen by proxy (MBP), and I described 'breaking out of the unreality' as not easy, especially when psychological health is involved. My SIL (nonbinary) and her wife (a trans woman) have a weirdly insular, mostly online community; I unintentionally heard the wife tell my SIL about my SIL's family that they're 'all right for cis people,' which I described as 'a bit culty.' My views: I think telling a gender-nonconforming child they are trans instead of simply a tomboy is wrong, since being a tomboy requires no medical treatment and most kids who feel that way are not trans. I find it demeaning to reduce someone's suffering to a fashion choice or political statement, and I criticize 'non-dysphoric trans people' on those grounds. I want a middle ground where trans people are not denied hormones they are sure about, but where the serious lifelong repercussions of hormones and puberty blockers are acknowledged openly, and where questions, disagreement, and discussion are permitted rather than suppressed. I have not described any medical transition of my own, any regret about transition, or any advocacy work beyond these comments.