All stories

Never transitioned — but has thoughts on who belongs in lesbian spaces

Female · Desisted91
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned-free, never-transitioned woman who identifies as a lesbian and was born female. I have not undergone any transition or detransition myself; my comments concern trans women in lesbian spaces, which I view critically as products of male socialization, while still supporting trans legal rights and healthcare. I engage with others' questions about body dysmorphia and chest discomfort, suggesting reduction as an option some cis women choose. I have not described any mental health conditions, medical interventions, regret, or suicidal ideation in this transcript.

Full story

I am a woman who identifies as a lesbian, and I write from the perspective of someone who has lived in society as a woman her whole life. I have never transitioned; my account here is about how I see myself and other women in relation to trans women who identify as lesbians. In March 2024, I posted several comments in the detrans community and related discussions. In one, I described a lot of the behavior I see in lesbian spaces as "extremely garish and attention-seeking and self-centering." I said lesbian spaces are "literally drowning in trans women looking for constant validation and to put their 2 cents in on what it means to be a lesbian and a woman," and I contrasted this with gay men's spaces, which I said are not like this with trans men. I called this "100% a product of being socialized as a man, and usually a heterosexual man," arguing that people who lived with that privilege for most of their lives get used to having attention and taking up space, and that doesn't change for a lot of them. I was careful to say that I believe trans people should have legal rights and access to healthcare, but I called it "an absurd delusion that only exists inside of Redditland" when someone who lived as a man, especially a straight man, for 20-30 years and only recently started HRT insists their experience of womanhood and lesbianism is as valid as mine. In another comment, I responded to someone struggling with their chest, asking whether what they felt stemmed more from body dysmorphia, from societal perceptions of men and women, or both, and suggested they consider a reduction, noting that a lot of cis women decide a chest of a certain size doesn't feel good for them both physically and mentally. I also commented, "Leave it to men to mansplain girlhood to you," and in a longer comment I described how most cis lesbians I know are respectful about being overtly sexual. I explained that the "useless lesbian" stereotype exists not because we're actually useless or don't have high libidos, but because we've been on the receiving end of things that feel "icky and predatory" often enough that we don't want to do that to other women. I said that subtle nuance with which we move around each other is something "that only other people who have lived in society as women their whole lives understand." Finally, when asked directly, I answered simply: "Female." I was born female and have lived as a woman without transition.