These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned woman who lived stealth as a man for three years on testosterone after top surgery, and quit T cold turkey around November 2019 while still secretly living male at work. I now want to be a muscular woman, have gone back to my feminine birthname, and am interested in dating and having children. Coming off T brought depression, fatigue, and appetite loss, but the severe sleep paralysis and night terrors I developed on T resolved within a year off it. I regret the permanent changes and years lost to transition, and I am critical of testosterone and top surgery for others, warning people to examine their reasons beyond 'dysphoria.'
Full story
I was born female and struggled with gender dysphoria since my teens. In my mid-20s I hit a wall where I could not imagine any kind of existence for myself unless it was a male one — I felt I had to terminate my existence unless it was a male one, and then I could live. Prior to HRT I felt so suicidal that transition was the best bet I could logically come up with at the time, and I optimistically figured I'd have a couple of good years before I hated myself or that it would work better than expected. I started testosterone in my mid-20s and was on it for three years. I never officially came out anywhere, not even to my family — I just wrote them a letter about four months on T, and they've been accepting and loving. I passed completely and lived stealth the entire time at work in an industrial setting, used the men's restroom, and had top surgery (peri/periareolar — I was an A-cup before). I was ordered off T for a total of two months before top surgery. I was a late, skeleton-fused transitioner and passed in about six months. Girls at work had crushes on me or hit on me; my online friends (all guys) believed 100% I was cis, and I'd even voice chatted with them.
I was addicted to lifting — that was the only real boon T brought me. I was strength training/bodybuilding on a perpetual leanbulk, able to rip 225lbs for 10 deadlifts. I'd been a virgin pre-T; I couldn't bear the thought of someone interacting with my body that way, it was sickening. I had a copper IUD. I was underweight before T with no sex drive, small A cup, and a period only every 6 months — I was 24 and my cycle may as well have made me a child, springing on me 2-3x a year; I think severe eating disorders can really put you 'behind' in that sense. I'd had an eating disorder, and my breasts were the 'fat' I wanted gone; I even considered awful things like 'if they got cancer they could be removed.' I worked labor for 2 years to pay for surgery.
Around November 2019 something happened that finally got me to quit ignoring all the doubts I'd been pushing aside, and I decided not to do my last scheduled shot and go cold turkey off T. I was stealth-detransitioning in secret — 'mere survival, too exhausted to deal with expressing it when I know I'm read as male.' I had a lot of anxiety about feminizing at work, fearing people would think I was going MTF, fearing hostility for having 'tricked' them, and dreading dealing with a period in the men's restroom. I planned to just be read as female again by the time I left that job without saying anything, and to go back to my super feminine birthname to tie everything up. I never got into the why with coworkers — just 'had a stint as a dude for 3 years' if asked. I couldn't bring myself to tell my boss.
I had no therapist at first; when I sought one for a surgery letter it was an LGBT-focused place 2 hours away, and I didn't think I should go back there. Coming off T, test cyp cleared my system and I got more depressed and fatigued even at a low weekly dose, spending a lot of time exhausted in bed outside of work. About six months into HRT I began having aggressive sleep paralysis and night terrors for the first time in my life — waking up screaming, feeling something in my mattress, slaps through the covers, a 'finger' tracing down my spine, a shadowy person stalking my bedroom — about monthly, increasing with stress (weekly after a breakup). Over one year off T, all the sleep paralysis and night terrors vanished; I can only think they were caused by testosterone. Before the sleep paralysis I'd had nightmares about T turning me into a body horror abomination.
The better I passed, the more dysphoric I got that I wasn't 'real', plus feelings of fraudulence — 'biological reality screaming obviously amidst secondary sex characteristics that wouldn't naturally occur.' I found stealth isolating: I became afraid to get too close to people, felt like an intruder in the restroom, and had turmoil when male friends shared private experiences with me knowing they never would have if they knew the truth. There were instances of women sexually harassing guys at a job and it caused me turmoil that one was going to 'brush by' me and find out my secret. I also noticed an MTF coworker was treated normally until occasional comments about her being 'a man' came out, which showed me people's views were only 'tolerant.'
I had painful cystic acne about a year and a half in, plus hair loss and a Norwood pattern. I never worked up to a full beard, just heavy on the jawline and neck with thick dark hairs leaving a shadow I'd have to get lasered. About six months off test I couldn't pick up 225lbs anymore — I attribute that more to appetite suppression and forcing down a meal a day during a hard time than to low T. I lost almost 20 lbs after switching to calisthenics at home during COVID, but kept broad shoulders and looked more muscular than on T. Creatively I was 'numb as fuck' on HRT — couldn't daydream as deeply, stopped enjoying music as much, a 'robot feel.'
About a year into transition, when I passed enough to start obliging male social expectations, I began questioning the validity of 'gender' from a trans perspective — a lot stayed in the female gender role with male pronouns attached. Binding had made my dysphoria worse: my breasts were on my mind constantly from discomfort and self-consciousness about posture and lighting, and top surgery became life or death. I'd never had much bottom dysphoria, but after my mastectomy I started developing it because it was the only thing in the mirror that didn't match. I was ordered off T two months before top surgery.
Quitting felt like waking up from a dream or discovering the god of a religion I believed in was dead — a blank slate, freeing but terrifying, because I'd built my whole life around transition working. I described transition as having put life further on hold: documentation, penny-pinching for surgery, body dysmorphic symptoms, loneliness, struggling with dating. I said transition 'just feels the opposite no matter how well I fit in' and that 'this was the form of suicide I chose at the time.' I was 'stuck' living as male because I'd rather not engage in performative behavior to pass as my sex again and still look like a twink in a dress. Rediscovering passions has been slow. My biggest bullies as a masculine girl were other women all the way into my early 20s, including my own mother. As I became healthier and older it wasn't my breasts I hated so much as having to bind them. I got 'em peri'd so I can't compare before/after boobs. I'm now finally interested in dating and making babies. I look younger than I did when underweight because I'm in better health now. I want to be a muscular chick. I browse the detrans subreddit maybe once a month. I was on tumblr before; it was YouTube binging and a Twitter full of friends who romanticized transition while being NEET that got me into it.
I advise people considering top surgery to examine why they hate their chest — 'Don't just say dysphoria and call it a day' — and I said I was lying in pain post-op thinking I'd never recommend it to anybody, so I won't recommend it. I tell people questioning that their doubts are a red flag, especially if the surgery is about escaping binding pain. I'm generally critical of testosterone for everyone except those whose bodies cannot produce any, and I advise people to 'pretend transitioning is not an available option' and ride it out. I predicted a decade where more people detransition and it hits mainstream knowledge. I think lifting/fitness is not part of any 'trans contagion' but that the contagion is more about internalizing sexist comments when doing things outside your gender narrative. I believe feeling 'not one nor the other' fuels dysphoria and the desire for surgery.