All stories

Butch lesbian, shut out of LGBT spaces for common sense

Female · Desisted196
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a desisted woman who is still deciding between she/her and she/they pronouns, and I identify as a butch- or androgynous-presenting lesbian who is part of the gay community but not trans. I feel shut down by mainstream LGBT spaces for what I see as common-sense views, and I'm active in detrans communities supporting others while pushing back on off-topic religion and on figures I view critically. This account doesn't cover my original transition timeline, medical history, or mental health in detail.

Full story

I detransitioned or desisted and I'm a woman who is still figuring out exactly how I identify. I posted in the detrans community asking what pronouns other people use after detransitioning or desisting, because I had been sure She/Her was fine but was questioning whether She/They fit me better. I described myself as a desisted woman who uses she/they pronouns. I'm gay or lesbian — I've said that a good number of us turned out to be gay, lesbian, or bi, so we're still part of the LGBT community, just not trans, and that's okay. I'm drawn to butch and androgynous presentation: I've said I wish I looked more butch and that I wish I looked androgynous, complaining that I look 'so girly.' I've complimented other detransitioned women on looking like butch lesbians or androgynous women, and told one person they look like a girl. I've also said I'd think someone was a woman and called them pretty. I feel alienated from mainstream LGBT spaces. I wrote that I'm 'sick of our common sense being seen as transphobic and being shut down from the LGBT community.' I'm active in the detrans subreddit and care about it staying focused: I pushed back hard when someone kept bringing up religion, telling them 'Boy, just stop. If someone doesn't believe in your religion, don't force it on them,' and explaining that the sub is 'a non-political religious subreddit where we're supposed to be helping people who are detransitioning or desisted' — actually a non-political, non-religious subreddit — and that forcing religion on people makes them feel unsafe. I also engaged with debates about labels, noting there are 'Trixic and Sapphic' labels and not understanding why non-binary people use 'Lesbian' when those exist. I've been supportive of others in the community, telling people 'life has been tough on you recently, but we're all here for you' and reassuring someone that 'we all make mistakes sometimes' and that they're 'perfect just the way you are.' I've also been sharply critical of one figure, saying they don't look like a certain person because 'they're an AGP with masculine features and a groomer,' contrasting them with someone I called 'very pretty and feminine.' I don't have detail in this transcript about my original transition timeline, medical steps, mental health diagnoses, trauma, or family situation. What I have shared is ongoing uncertainty about my pronouns and identity, a strong identification with being female and with butch/androgynous presentation, continued identification with the lesbian/gay community, and a critical stance toward both mainstream LGBT orthodoxy and trans-identified male figures I see as inappropriate.