All stories

Surgery at 16, still passing as a man at 21

Female · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 3 → Transition 13 → Detransition 18511
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who medically transitioned from ages 14-18 (testosterone for 3.5 years, double mastectomy at 16) and stopped T around age 18 after realizing I actually wanted to live as a gender-nonconforming woman who loves women. I now, at 21, still present male and pass well, which causes me significant distress — I feel like an emotional husk and grieve the lesbian relationships I can't have while being read as a man. My permanently dropped voice is my biggest source of pain and I have decided to pursue vocal feminization surgery. I attribute my transition to childhood trauma, a violently abusive household, internalized misogyny, and easy access to medical transition as a minor in New York, and I advocate for much stricter mental health evaluation for minors while still supporting adult access to transition.

Full story

I was born female and had feelings of being a boy since around age 3. By age 6 I was trying to pee standing up and envying boys' body hair. I prayed to God in 5th grade to make me male. I never liked traditionally feminine clothes and was a tomboy growing up, but my parents wouldn't let me express myself the way I wanted — they tried to mold me into my mom's preppy, ultra-ladylike style. I internalized anything feminine as weakness because of my family's dynamics. I started transitioning socially at 13. At 14 I started testosterone on a low dose (.4 mL) in New York, where it's easy for minors to access T. I was supposed to live as male for a year first; I did, but they had no way of verifying it and just took my word for it. After only 4-6 months I was on T. When I asked why I was on such a low dose, I was told it was 'in case people your age change their mind, they can reverse the changes. I don't think it will happen to you though.' One shot of T is enough to cause bottom growth. I got a double mastectomy a month before turning 17 (at 16), despite never speaking to an actual therapist — I spoke to someone at the clinic for about 10 minutes and got a letter. I was on T from 14 to 18, about 3.5 years. My family life was violent. My dad was violent and especially verbally abusive toward my mom. I saw and heard violence every day for 16 years. My entire family was emotional and manipulative. Growing up I heard 'gays go to hell, they're gross, they should die… they're peds.' My mom and I walked on eggshells around my father and extended family. My mom basically raised me to protect her, and after top surgery she expected me to always be there for her. My family constantly told me my wants weren't valid and that I'd never accomplish anything, and that I was 'weird' for dressing gender-nonconforming. I was a hardcore perfectionist with an all-or-nothing personality from internalizing 'never being enough.' At 13, partly because of a best friend, I realized I was bisexual. On my own I concluded I was a man in the wrong body. Body image issues started then too, and middle school bullies made fun of me on top of family criticism. I felt insecure about my developing feminine traits. I internalized women as weak because of the violence I saw toward the women in my family, and I was afraid of men without realizing it. I think my mind rejected femininity and decided it would be easier to be a straight man, justified by my naturally masculine traits and attraction. Transitioning was freeing at first — I got picked on less and it was easier for everyone to accept me as a man. But I wasn't happy. I realized I traded one set of chains (femininity) for another (masculinity), and that I had changed my body to please other people. Two days before my first post in November 2022, at 18, I realized I wanted to detransition. It hit me while reading fanfic about lesbians — I suddenly understood I'd be completely fine having sex with another woman as a woman, but not as a man. I felt off about sex as a man with a man too. I realized I just wanted to be gender-nonconforming and love women as a woman without judgment. Working with a professional helped me see these were my primary motivations. I'd been a classic case of 'I've felt this way since I was 3' and was adamant I'd never detransition, and yet here I was. I decided to contact a psychologist and consider checking into a mental facility. I'd struggled with suicidal thoughts and depression all my life and hoped to get medication. I was scared to tell my family — my mom and brother. I stopped T about two months before January 2023. After stopping, I realized I had suppressed all my emotions before starting T and continued throughout. I couldn't feel things for more than a few seconds, if at all. Womanhood felt alien; happiness felt foreign. My voice has been the hardest part. I never liked my voice on T and couldn't figure out why — now I know it was because it kept getting lower and I was distressed by that, even though at the time I thought I wanted it to drop more. I cried about it nonstop for weeks. I noticed a slight decrease in my bottom range. I looked into vocal training (Transvoicelessons, local lessons, online feminization coaching) and considered vocal feminization surgery (VFS) if things didn't improve by 25, though I was hesitant because of possible side effects. I held onto hope partly by pointing to Blaire White's voice. I also lost nipple/chest sensation from top surgery, which I dislike. Interestingly, I hated having a chest pre-surgery and now I like it. I'm at peace with the other changes T gave me — I have an androgynous look face- and neck-wise, nothing overly male or female. I still pass as male very well since I started young and got top surgery. About four months into detransitioning I started identifying as non-binary, feeling the label fit me better than woman out of reflex. I acknowledged I was born female and always have. I preferred they/them pronouns but didn't care much since I lived in a conservative area within NYC and would get misgendered regardless. I disliked that I'd changed my name and wanted something neutral or feminine. I hadn't been able to express much of my 'girly' side yet, but I wanted to try being girly for a change and believed I'd love it once I got there. By 2023 I no longer envied men. After watching women in shows and on YouTube, I realized women could be inspiring and successful — my entire family had torn women down, along with gay people. I was alright with being a pan/bi woman. I appreciated men for who they were but didn't envy them or trans men's transitions. I felt transitioning is glamorized. Now, at 21 (three years after stopping T), I feel dead inside having to portray myself as a man and not wanting to engage with the social rules dictated for men. I feel pain every time I remember I can't have a lesbian relationship this way. I let myself have a crush for the first time in years only to remember I can't do anything about it. My emotions are virtually nonexistent and I feel like a husk most days. The only thing keeping me sane is the thought of getting VFS to be seen as female again — after three years I've made up my mind. I stopped T before developing overly masculine characteristics, so my voice is really my only problem. I just want to be a lesbian. I do believe trans people exist, but this wasn't the case for my life. I think trauma related to gender and sexuality, on top of being a child, motivated me to transition. I feel angry and hopeless. I don't think transition should be banned and believe adults should have access to it, but I think kids should be scrutinized much more thoroughly by mental health professionals — it was an absolute joke how easy it was for me to get on T in NYC. I believe people have to make their own mistakes and that banning things outright just drives them underground.