These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a male-born person who has detransitioned after years of on-and-off estrogen HRT, which I began partly seeking closer interpersonal connections and an easier social role, especially as a future nurse. I experienced weight gain, male body odor returning, and what I called 'chemically induced menopause' during HRT interruptions. I went through a phase of being gender-critical while still trans, then broke out of that ideology, and now I criticize both gender-critical spaces and what I see as lack of accountability among some detransitioners. I remain supportive of transition access for the right people and strongly oppose legislation restricting trans healthcare and protections. I have not described any suicidal ideation or self-harm.
Full story
I was born male. I've been on estrogen HRT on and off for years — I call it 'stop and go HRT' — and I've had supply chain problems before. Last year when my estrogen supply ran out, within about two months I gained roughly 20 pounds and my body odor switched back to male; I described the experience as 'chemically induced menopause.' In my experience the pendulum starts swinging back toward detransition effects after about a month, with more significant reversal around two months. The big tell for me is when I start smelling like a guy again — about two months in — and it's jarring after you aren't used to it.
I transitioned to female partly because of a genuine desire for stronger interpersonal connections. I said it's 'a huge perk if not the reason for my transition to female' — you can get closer to people easier as a woman. There's a real interpersonal barrier as a man, with women in particular, which makes you automatically more threatening or scary, and I think women have good reason to feel that way. I'm a caregiver and expected to be a nurse within a couple years of 2020. I strongly believed being a woman in that field would be an asset, if only because it plays into societal stereotypes of that role and spares me 'male nurse bullshit.'
I've thought a lot about sexism and misogyny. I listed examples like old men making laws preventing women from having abortions, the wage gap, beauty standards treated as gender roles, and boys being called a faggot for being feminine. I said the thing that would drive me most insane if I ever pass for a human female is being talked over, not heard, and having my ideas or knowledge devalued or ignored — I'd heard professional women complain about this repeatedly and dreaded it. I said bluntly, 'Men disrespect women to put it succinctly. It's normal.'
I also pushed back on some gender-critical arguments. I disagreed with claims that trans women can't speak about women's experiences, saying women don't experience homophobia anywhere close to what men experience and that it's 'fundamentally the same thing, misogyny differently channeled, and just as damaging.' I acknowledged I can't speak for the female side but argued that for men, homophobic harassment is 'a method of behavior control / punishment for deviancy as much as sexism is for women.' I said I was putting a lot of energy into reading women's stories and trying to understand their experiences. At the same time I made some sarcastic comments, including 'I think MTF are legitimately happier with their appropriated bodies with which to better do the bidding of the patriarchy. I know I sure am,' and 'Btw I'm a woman.'
I went through a period of being 'trans person full fledged GC' — gender critical while still trans — and said I 'managed to break out of that ideology, thankfully.' I described myself as able to 'bounce between cults at will now and not be trapped in either.' I think a lot about cognitive dissonance and belief systems. I said it's really hard to entertain ideas that oppose your belief system and that most of what people do is to avoid cognitive dissonance. I argued that belief in a truth doesn't make it true for others, that your truth is often diametrically opposed to the truth of others and both are true, and that the problem arises when you assume your truth is capital-T truth for everyone. I compared strong ideological conviction to religious extremism, saying both sides are 'both right viewed in the right context, although they probably aren't arguing over the same thing.'
I've been critical of gender-critical spaces. I said 'gender critters are just an antagonistic ideology to trans people existing' and argued that trans exclusionary radical feminist spaces conflate criticism of trans people with criticism of trans existence. I said, 'No, it's not any deeper than trans people existing = gender ideology to an unfortunately high number of people.' I also said I see a lot of detransitioners directing anger at their changing world view toward the trans population as a whole, and that while the blame directed at former communities and doctors isn't 'totally unjustified,' I feel 'a troubling amount of it downplays their own accountability in getting the ball rolling on transitioning.' I said I don't think transitioning is an unhealthy way to deal with dysphoria — 'it comes down to if it's the right move for people' — and that unfortunately it wasn't the right move for a lot of people in the detrans community. I said I'm strongly opposed to any ideology aimed at suppressing resources and quality of life for trans people, arguing that framing transition as unhealthy leads to legislation removing healthcare access and social protections like restroom access, which makes life 'a living hell' for trans people.
I also argued with people about hormone levels, saying trans women do experience hormone fluctuation because IM injections and pills have real pharmacokinetics — the half life of pills is short, livers constantly process medication, and steady state is 'obviously the goal' but not always achievable. I said it's 'stupid to deny self-reports of medical side effects' and that people describing cyclical side effects as similar to PMS are describing something physiological even if the comparison to a menstrual cycle is imprecise language.
I've had some antagonistic exchanges online, including being accused of bad faith and of stalking a lolcow figure. I also told someone who was detransitioning, 'You got to see life from two very different perspectives, which is cool af. Good luck with the detransition.'