All stories

Three years as a trans woman, still keeping the estrogen

Male · Detransitioned147
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I'm a detransitioned male who lived as a trans woman for about three years, socially detransitioned, but continue taking estrogen and testosterone blockers because they help my anxiety, anger, and dysphoria. I have OCD and BPD, and I trace part of my transition to intense self-hatred about being male when I was young. I still present femininely — long hair, shaved legs, women's shirts, occasional makeup — and don't see detransition as requiring gender conformity. I don't report any surgeries or surgical regrets of my own, and I don't describe suicidal ideation or self-harm. I'm broadly supportive of other people's transition decisions while encouraging slow, grounded self-reflection.

Full story

I'm a male-bodied person who lived as a trans woman for about three years before socially detransitioning, and my situation is unusual in that I chose to stay on hormone therapy after detransitioning because estrogen and blockers genuinely helped my anxiety and anger, and the physical feminization helped my dysphoria. Around August 2021 I was still figuring out my presentation and got a medium-length androgynous haircut as a hedge while I worked out what I wanted. By September 2021 I was spending time in detrans spaces, offering support to others. I told one person considering transition that their impulse looked more like OCD than real dysphoria, drawing on my own diagnoses: I have OCD and BPD, and I described a pattern of getting obsessed with "figuring things out" about myself that felt irrelevant later, or convincing myself to try identities the rest of my brain didn't want. I recommended slowing down and thinking in grounded, concrete terms rather than rushing to an answer. I've tried to hold a non-dogmatic view of detransition. I told someone that detransitioning doesn't have to mean committing to gender conformity — I myself still have long hair, shave my legs, wear women's shirts, and wear makeup sometimes, and I think there are plenty of cis women who are into feminine guys. When someone asked about staying on HRT despite health risks, I was honest that the science isn't really there yet because relatively few studies exist on trans women on HRT long-term, that there's at least somewhat elevated risk of breast cancer and DVT, and I suggested looking at actual studies and minimizing risk factors like smoking and poor diet. I also acknowledged I couldn't advise them on their specific situation. I have a strong streak of self-compassion about how my own transition went, and I try to pass it on. I told a young person who was disgusted with himself for being male — calling himself a man and a rapist — that it's not healthy to approach this from self-hatred, and that when I was his age I felt really similarly, "calling myself a man and a rapist and stuff when I was just a scared kid who needed to love himself more," and that it really screwed up both my gender identity and my mental health. I recommended therapy and making space to understand where the feelings come from, not necessarily to transition. I've also been supportive of people pursuing medical steps when it's right for them — I told someone who'd had orchiectomy that scrotoplasty and testosterone therapy are available and they could restore their genitals to near their previous appearance, framing it as "just an error in medical treatment" that isn't shameful. I've reassured people that genital function generally persists and that testosterone can be replaced exogenously. I don't report any surgeries as my own — the orchiectomy/scrotoplasty discussion was advice to someone else. My own medical picture is that I'm on estrogen and testosterone blockers long-term, which I've continued by choice. I've noted that on E plus blockers I don't produce sperm. I don't discuss fertility goals beyond that. I don't describe any complications from HRT in this record. On mental health, the concrete facts I've given are OCD and BPD diagnoses, plus anxiety and anger that HRT helps manage. I've described myself as having been a "scared kid" with self-hatred around being male that damaged my gender identity and mental health. I don't describe current severity, therapy history, or medication beyond HRT. I don't describe family, romantic relationships, or career in this record. Sexually and socially I present femininely as a detransitioned male and I've said there are women open to feminine men, but I don't state my orientation. I don't describe trauma or abuse beyond the internal self-hatred I mentioned. On regret: I don't express regret about hormones — I actively value them. I frame my medical history neutrally as an "error in medical treatment" when talking to others in similar positions, but I don't state my own regret intensity or trajectory. I don't describe any surgeries I regret. My attitude toward transition for others is broadly supportive and autonomy-focused: I encourage people to take it slow and understand their feelings, but I don't oppose transition, and I explicitly noted that this subreddit's rules discourage recommending that others transition — implying I'm aware of and mindful of that norm rather than trying to subvert it. I haven't described formal advocacy or activism.