All stories

An autistic commenter, not a detransitioner

Female · Desisted26
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am not trans and have not transitioned or detransitioned; I am an autistic (diagnosed) person who engages in the detrans community as a commenter. I advocate for caution around age and life-long medical decisions, noting the brain isn't fully developed until 23-25 and that major psychiatric conditions often aren't diagnosed until the 20s. I emphasize the roles of trauma, neurology, and possible congenital/epigenetic factors in gender-related distress, drawing on research about body integrity dysphoria and brain structure. I try to be supportive of people in distress while being skeptical about whether all medical outcomes are disclosed to patients. My current identity is a non-trans autistic woman offering perspective rather than sharing a personal detransition account.

Full story

I posted a link to the Cattle Decapitation song 'Forced Gender Reassignment' in May 2023, and after that I spent time in the detrans community responding to other people's situations. I'm not trans myself, but I try to be thoughtful about what people going through this are dealing with. In one thread I suggested to the OP that their distress might come from feeling objectified by their parents' comments — things like 'cause you're such a pretty girl' — and that it was understandable to be hurt if they felt their parents wouldn't love them if they transitioned. I told them plainly that I'm not trans, but I'd be hurt too in that position. In another conversation I weighed in on age and decision-making: '18 is young for these kinds of decisions that are life long. The brain isn't done developing until 23-25ish.' I noted that major psychiatric disorders like bipolar and schizophrenia generally aren't diagnosed until the 20s, because you can't undiagnose a major disorder unless it was misdiagnosed in the first place. I also just checked in with someone, saying 'What's going on OP? You aren't alone I'm positive.' I'm autistic — diagnosed — and I'm quite blunt, which doesn't always go over well with people. I acknowledged that 'none of any of this is easy.' My view is that people who transition as adults and do it thoughtfully do put a lot of consideration into outcomes, though I'm skeptical about whether they're told all the outcomes. What I try to focus on is the reasons and feelings behind transition, as well as suppressed feelings around transition. I believe trauma can sit suppressed in the background for many years, and that neurology plays a role. I've read about research on body integrity dysphoria (BID) finding parietal lobe differences in some participants — that lobe being responsible for perception of the world and self. I connected this to a close friend who had childhood cancer and a parietal lobe lesion; she describes her leg as feeling like it 'isn't connected to my body,' has drawn her leg strangely since childhood, and trips frequently. I think epigenetic factors are likely at play, with congenital biological cases as well as cases where trauma shapes brain development — noting research that physically abused and chronically sexually abused children show larger ventricles and differences in affected brain areas. I don't share a personal transition or detransition story; my engagement is as an autistic, non-trans person trying to think carefully about the medical, psychological, and trauma-related dimensions of these decisions.