All stories

Estrogen for years, then a friend's question about feminine men

Male · Detransitioned966
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned male who lived as a trans woman on estrogen and detransitioned around late 2018 or early 2019 after therapy showed me that transitioning wasn't helping my depression and anxiety. I now identify as a feminine gay man, having realized with a friend's help that internalized hatred of feminine men had fueled my gender crisis. I have worked on presenting more masculine through haircut, hair gel, and planned exercise, and my beard is slowly growing back after estrogen slowed it. I remain in therapy for various issues and have mild, high-functioning autism. I am currently free of gender dysphoria and advise others to stop focusing on gender altogether.

Full story

I was born male. My gender identity crisis ran for a long time, and at some point I transitioned and lived as a trans woman — I took estrogen, which slowed my beard growth, and I described myself as having been "a transwoman at one time." I detransitioned over a year before February 2020, so roughly late 2018 or early 2019. When I decided to transition I was in a lot of mental pain: low self-esteem, severe depression, and anxiety. I had surrounded myself with people who told me that transitioning into a woman would solve all of my problems. Once I got therapy, I began to learn to love myself as a unique individual rather than someone following the crowd. As I began to heal, I noticed that transitioning didn't help me feel better, so I decided to stop it. I also cited the health risks that come from going through transition as a factor in changing my mind. Detransition was not an easy road. I still fought thoughts telling me that it was okay to be trans, and I almost gave in again after a year passed. I didn't go through with it because I knew in my heart I would still be in pain, and because of the health risks. When I did briefly entertain transitioning again, it only made me depressed again, and that was when I realized the harm the dysphoria was doing to me — "the moment I realized this I knew that I was not Trans." In September 2019 I fell back into depression because I was struggling with my identity, and it got so bad I was thinking of transitioning again so I could enjoy my feminine self in peace. I talked it out with friends, and one of my guy friends told me I wasn't trans, but rather just a feminine gay man. It dawned on me that he was right: I was indeed just a feminine gay man, and I had been internally hating myself for it. Society frowns upon feminine men, especially feminine gay men, and I had internalized that hatred and self-loathing. I said my gender identity crisis was finally over and that I was learning to love myself for who I really am. I have autism — mild, high-functioning autism — and I was still trying to understand how it affects my life. I was already receiving help from therapy for a variety of issues. By February 2020 I posted that I was finally free from gender dysphoria. I wrote that I had battled gender dysphoria for so long I became tired of fighting the war, as it was doing a number on my mental health, triggering my depression and anxiety over and over again. After therapy and reading posts in the detransition subreddit, I realized I didn't need to define myself by a gender. I wrote: "I am not a woman, nor shall I ever be. But being a man doesn't mean I should despise myself." I decided to move away from the whole gender debate and work on myself, concluding, "back to being my birth sex (male) for good." It felt like a great weight had been lifted — like I could finally breathe and relax for the first time ever. After detransition I actively worked on presenting as male. I asked for advice on looking more masculine, saying I wanted to "show off that I am indeed a guy." I styled my hair with gel, got a specific haircut recommended by the community "in order to allow me to present myself as my birth sex (male)," and planned to start exercising once the weather warmed up. I noted that my beard was slowly growing in, though taking a while because estrogen had slowed it down. I was pleased that people thought my face still looked fine despite HRT. I posted update photos of my haircut and gel-styled hair, saying I was trying to find a happy medium. In giving advice to others, I said: "Stop focusing on your gender. Gender is a trap to make people feel terrible about themselves. Instead just focus on being YOU!" I also advised focusing on mental health problems like depression and anxiety, pursuing interests regardless of whether they were feminine or masculine, and realizing you are more than your gender. I offered to talk to anyone going through similar struggles.