All stories

Questioned gender at 17 — before social media, before anything happened

Female · Desisted169
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned-in-spirit but never-transitioned woman: I questioned my gender briefly in my late teens, before social media, and never came out, took hormones, or had surgery. I was born female, I'm attracted to men, I don't want children, and I now identify simply as a woman because I'm female, with masculine interests and a body I accept as it is. Working in medical sciences, I'm strongly critical of hormones and blockers for minors and of transition as a first-line treatment, and I counsel others to try therapy and time before any medical steps. I have no medical regrets, only retrospective embarrassment that I entertained the question at all, and that has resolved with maturity.

Full story

I was born female and I never socially transitioned or medically transitioned — my story is one of questioning rather than of hormones or surgery, and I want to be clear about that up front. I had a brief phase where I questioned my gender in my late teens, well before social media existed. It just went away as I matured and realised that life is hard for both sexes, often in similar ways but sometimes in different ways. I never identified any differently publicly — I only thought about things privately — and I never came out, never changed my name or pronouns, and never took hormones or had any surgery. What prompted that questioning, as far as I can tell in hindsight, was meeting an older crossdresser and another person shortly after I went off to college. Meeting them made me question my gender. I had a lot of fun with both of them, but the older one was clearly autogynaephilic — I can tell now, though not really at the time — was married with a few kids, was away over the weekends, and somehow his wife was the one framed as having the mental illness because she wasn't okay with it all. He dropped off the radar after a few years and I lost touch. I also think gender stereotypes played a role: I'm just a woman with some masculine interests and traits, and I don't want to be a pretty, small, subdued, petite person. I'm happy not being very girly. I also had a period of body dissatisfaction that I now read as weight-related rather than gender-related. My unhappiness with my body, regarding the things I can change, stems from my weight/size, and that's a matter of eating less and working out more. I'm still not a fan of my body but I feel the same about it now that I'm bigger compared to when I was 15 kg lighter. I'd like a more androgynous look physically but I'm too lazy to work for it, and I've accepted that and don't see my body as my identity. I'm a woman because I'm female. I have all kinds of interests, hobbies, achievements, and they are what make me me. My chest is definitely there but smaller than average; I'd have a reduction if it were any bigger. I'm not a super fan of my vagina — I find it a strange organ, but peen is kind of strange to me too — I just accept it is what it is. I don't want children, and I do wish I had a male body in the sense of not being so prone to injury, being stronger, and not risking pregnancy during sex. A male body seems more useful in daily life and because I don't want kids it's not worth it for me to have a female body. But that's the hand I'm dealt. I don't feel that being female has held me back in life, and there are social benefits to being a woman. I'm attracted to men and I have a boyfriend. I'm in my early 30s now and I feel I'm probably fixed with regards to personality and core political views. As for mental health, I don't report a diagnosis; general therapy strikes me as a reasonable way to figure out how to deal with things I find hard. I did go out in the goth scene when that was still a thing, and I had a whole bunch of piercings in my mid and late teens, most of which I took out because they were painful or no longer fit how I want to look — luckily they leave only a tiny scar. I also wanted a tattoo as a teenager and I'm happy I didn't get one because I'd hate the design now. That experience is a big part of why I'm sceptical about teens making permanent medical decisions. I work in medical sciences and I'm educated in that field, which shapes how I talk about this. I don't want any children but I feel badly for teenagers who went on blockers and who will really suffer from infertility later on, irrespective of whether they desist or detrans. You can't expect a teenager to know whether they ever want their own kids. I think transition should only ever be an absolute last resort, after other mental health issues are excluded, after therapy and after supporting a young person through puberty have failed, with a real-life test of at least one to two years before hormones and another before surgery. In my view none of the under-18s were capable of consenting to hormonal or surgical transition, and I suspect many adults were not in the right mental state either. I think diagnosis should be improved and that transition as the only treatment option fails many people. I have no regret of my own about medical transition because I never medically transitioned; what I do feel is a kind of retrospective embarrassment that I ever entertained the question, and relief that I didn't act on it. I think it's embarrassing because many who come out seem to have an all-or-nothing attitude, and being told years later 'I've changed my mind again, now change again how you see me' comes across as not knowing who you are. I don't advocate for other people to transition, and I'm critical of strangers encouraging others to transition or of trans women lying to each other about passing. At the same time I say it's okay to be gay and it's okay to be gender non-conforming, and I don't think anyone should initiate transition until they've lived away from family for at least two years. I haven't done any formal advocacy or activism; I've only offered my perspective in online discussions.