All stories

The physician who lurked in r/detrans

Female · Desisted78
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a cisgender middle-aged physician in an unrelated specialty who has no personal transition history but has commented supportively in r/detrans throughout 2019. I view the rise in transition, especially among young women, as a social-cultural contagion driven by ideology rather than science, and I believe dysphoria is a timeless distress that latches onto whatever theme is culturally available — gender, weight, or self-harm. I have offered encouragement to detransitioners and criticized online trans communities as "suggestive and cultlike." I currently identify as a cisgender woman and am not detransitioned, desisted, or trans.

Full story

I am a cisgender middle-aged woman and a physician in a field unrelated to gender medicine. I have no personal stake in the transition debate — I never identified as trans and never medically transitioned — but I have followed the field closely and engaged repeatedly in r/detrans discussions over the course of 2019. My involvement began in January 2019, when I corrected a misconception about tamoxifen, noting that it is an estrogen blocker and that when men take large amounts of testosterone some of it can be metabolized into estrogen. Shortly after, I explained who I was to the community: "I have no skin in the game. Cisgender middleaged woman. Am physician in non-related field." I went on to say that I witness "the fast evolution in treatment and how much it is based in ideology and wishful thinking and not science, and I think its horrific," and I told the community, "What you do here in your little corner is important. Thank you." I have been a regular reader and commenter. In April 2019 I mentioned having contacted a company directly with a suggestion about a product they made — "I mailed the company and suggested it. Its high quality" — and I told the community I would post there if the product ever came out. In May 2019 I offered encouragement to someone, saying that "seeing other people in the same situation often makes you stronger" and that I thought the risk they were worried about was low. In June 2019 I laid out my central theory at length. I argued that transgenderism has come in two major waves that differ by sex. For men, I said, the first wave from 1960–1980 was smaller and driven mainly by internalized homophobia among homosexual men, while the second, larger wave from roughly 1990 onward was driven by autogynephilia (AGP) among heterosexual men, with the groups overlapping in time. For women I said it was harder to say because transitioning and SRS were very uncommon among women before the 1990s, and because "gender ideology" makes non-conforming analysis hard to find. My guess was internalized homophobia for the small early group of women who transitioned medically or surgically. For the recent explosion of women transitioning, especially in the last decade and last five years, I said it "has every marking of a social contagion epidemic," noting that women are more sensitive to social contagion and citing the Tanganyika laughter epidemic, 19th-century hysteria, and 1990s repressed-memory claims as historical parallels — all predominantly young women. I summarized the current situation as two groups: "AGPs that are driven by lust, and social contagiants ... that are driven by fear and spur of the momentum." I predicted the lust-driven group would stay in transition because of continuing reinforcing experiences, while the fear-driven group would have less incentive to stay, because "the momentum slows down when you have doing the act of transitioning, and reality kicks in, not passing, male hair loss, male ugliness, hard to find a partner, and so on." In August 2019 I commented on anabolic steroid use, saying bodybuilders "definitly get a high and have troubles getting down from it because of the antidepressive effect," that they use higher doses, and that high doses also trigger aggression. In the same month I offered a one-line explanation for some behavior as being "for woke points." In September 2019 I stated my view bluntly: "It is a social-cultural epidemic and the postmodern ideologicals are keeping the medical establishment hostage for fear of looking like bigots." Later that month I developed a psychological theory of dysphoria: "I think sometimes dysforia is just dysforia, and it finds a theme to latch on to, be it gender or weight/anorexia or selfharm. Right now it seems to be gender for a lot of young women." I expanded on this, saying that "the more I study psychocultural medical phenomena, the more I think that people in all times have had dysforia an and anxiety. It latches on to some theme, be it gender or weight or selfharm." I also criticized online trans communities: "some of the internet world is toxic because of the mass effect of people echoing the same talking points. Its very suggestive and cultlike." Throughout, my stance has been that of an outside professional observer: supportive of the detransition community, critical of current gender-medicine practice, and analytical rather than personally invested.