All stories

Passing as a woman, still identifying as male

Male · Detransitioned66
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, transitioned (including years of cyproterone), and now pass as a woman, but I recognize myself as male and live as a woman because conforming to masculinity as a gender non-conforming man felt unlivable and dangerous. I have not detransitioned medically and don't feel I've lost anything from transitioning, though I warn other males that transition can ruin lives catastrophically and have lost friends to suicide after transition consequences. I've experienced groping and sexual assault after transitioning, endured homophobic violence as a teen, and find detrans spaces alienating as a detrans male minority. I've advised others against surgery and toward careful self-reflection. I currently identify as male while living and presenting as a woman.

Full story

I was born male. I grew up spending the majority of my teens getting the shit beat out of me by homophobes on the daily, which shaped how I compared later experiences to that baseline. I transitioned medically and socially, took cyproterone for years, and now pass as a woman. I never wear makeup; most of the time I wear jeans, though sometimes when I feel like it I'll wear a skirt or shorts. For a while now I've come to the conclusion that I recognize myself as male, but I simply cannot live a life gender conforming as one — for me personally it is just unlivable, and living as a gender non-conforming man is dangerous and stressful as hell, so I live and present myself as a woman instead. I don't think I've lost anything; from the very beginning I was always myself, so I don't relate to the leaving the male self behind thing, and I also don't relate to the changes feeling like they're too much. I've described myself as MTFTM at points, and I've also said that my experience was that if you pass as a female everyone treats you nicely and shows kindness toward you, whereas as a man — especially if you're fat, ugly or bald — that is pretty much unthinkable, and people will just be disgusted at you rather than pity you. After transitioning I was groped and sexually assaulted, but at least for me life has been way easier after transitioning, though that might also have been because of the constant homophobic violence I endured as a teen. Anecdotally, in my community almost every MtF I've seen detransition either didn't pass or was attracted to women primarily — those are the two red flags for me. I've been on hormones for years (cyproterone specifically) and haven't had long lasting effects other than breast budding. I've told others to avoid surgery: "PLEASE don't get the surgery. You will have something taken away from you that you won't ever get back." I've struggled with how I'm received in detrans spaces. I often give up on posting because after observing the subreddit for a while it is pretty intimidating to post from the perspective of a detrans male when the subreddit is a vast majority female, and there's a strain of sentiment that men deserve no sympathy or compassion whatsoever. I kinda wish there was a place where detrans males could talk between ourselves about our own experiences openly without having to explain ourselves or feel judged, but I know even if I make a subreddit there aren't enough of us to keep it going, so the whole thing is very depressing for me. Reading a post from another detrans male, I said it resonated so much with my own experiences and the journey I've been through that at points it almost felt like they were writing about my own experiences — "almost disturbing in a good sort of way." I said I feel as though I can finally accept myself as a male, after feeling so much hatred and despair about myself and my gender and going through so much. In a way it almost feels like it was thanks to all that I've been through that I'm finally able to just accept myself fully in every way — like I am finally free. I don't think I will feel otherwise but I hope it stays that way. On transition risk for males, I've said I think you should only even think about transitioning if it is clear in your head that you simply can't keep on living otherwise, because as AMAB transitioning will often ruin your life in catastrophic (and often violent) ways that many times you'll be unable to fix back. I've literally had friends commit suicide after the consequences of attempting to transition really hit. I've also advised others to take care of themselves, self-reflect, go back to the core of their feelings, focus on what they want and what kind of future would make them happy, and if the ideal isn't achievable, to shave off layers until they find a realistic future they can stomach. I currently live and present as a woman while recognizing myself as male; I have not detransitioned medically.