All stories

Envy of what straight women wanted — five years as a man

Female · DetransitionedTransition 14 → Detransition 17983
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman — a butch lesbian — who lived as a transman for about five years and was on testosterone injections for 11 months before stopping at the start of 2020. I now believe I transitioned out of envy of male characteristics that heterosexual women were attracted to, because I am homosexual, and because lesbianism was far less visible than the trans movement when I was growing up. Detransitioning cost me most of my friends and left me isolated, and I briefly considered suicide in late December 2019 before finding clarity. I still experience dysphoria and dislike my body, and I am pursuing a legal name change and a breast reduction rather than a mastectomy. I now publicly advocate against transition, having posted a video titled 'Gaining Confidence as a Butch Lesbian After Detransitioning.'

Full story

I grew up in California and first thought I was trans around 2013-2014, when I was about 14-15 years old; I later described that period as having transitioned "in 2013" though I also said I couldn't remember the exact year because it had been a blur. I came out and lived as a transman for roughly five years. Around my 17th birthday in 2019 I started hormone replacement therapy — testosterone injections — which I obtained with startling ease: I walked into a gender clinic in California and got a coupon for testosterone for the Wal-Mart pharmacy in under 30 minutes, and I doubted the clinic even had licensed doctors since it handed out needles to people sleeping in the parking lot. I was on testosterone for about 11 months, skipping doses occasionally, and I never had any surgeries. I also bound my chest for 3-4 years, 8-12 hours a day, all week, which left my DD breasts saggy and hanging far lower than they should, causing posture problems and strained breathing. Several things pushed me toward transition in the first place. I was never typically feminine, and I resented the language applied to women — she/her, woman, pretty, ma'am, and in Italian, donna/ragazza/lei — which I experienced as "social dysphoria." I envied male peers going through male puberty, and I later realized this envy was not because I was a boy in a female body but because subconsciously I recognized those masculine features were attractive to girls, and I wanted to be the one who wooed them. I wanted to be seen as a person rather than an object of desire, and becoming a man seemed like the only way to accept myself. I also described having an awful life, a constant thought that I would end up homeless and die before age 25, and that transitioning was the only goal I had — I was willing to live a short miserable life so long as everyone thought I was male. I forced myself to find men attractive while identifying as a transman, though I was only attracted to hyper-feminine men who looked like women, and I wrote off any doubt as internalized transphobia, a framing the mainstream trans movement of 2013-15 hammered into my head. I also mentioned being influenced by the incel/MRA community into giving up poetry, and I gave up drawing because it fit the "Weird Quiet Artsy Girl" stereotype. In summer 2018 I had a breakdown because I thought I might be a lesbian rather than a transman; I was furious and slightly revolted by the possibility, but it turned out to be true. In December 2019 I began seriously researching the ingredients in my HRT injections and the negatives drastically outweighed the positives. Over about two days at the end of December 2019 I was in a terrible mood from thinking, and I even considered suicide as the greatest option, but after forcing myself to face the truth I realized the facade I had maintained for almost five years began to crack. Around New Year's 2020 I skipped an injection and decided the previous week was my last dose of HRT. I could not afford a good therapist in California and had no doctor monitoring my hormone levels, so I considered gradually lowering my dosage rather than stopping abruptly, fearing testosterone withdrawal. I told the people I interacted with daily that I no longer wanted to transition, and all but one ignored me; the one who acknowledged it called it "sad." I had literally nobody outside of the internet to talk to except a family member generations older than me who did not live in my town. I had dropped out of school, had no friends or siblings, and was deeply isolated. I lost about half of my so-called friends when I detransitioned. I also participated in online debate, arguing aggressively against the concept of transgenderism, calling it a delusion and a cult-like ideology, and I frequented communities like /LGBdroptheT and r/flexinlesbians, the latter of which helped me come to terms with my body by showing me other masculine women. I detransitioned at the start of 2020, around age 17-18. I still experience dysphoria and I still despise my body, wishing I could be taller, more muscular, and have a deeper voice and a beard, but I accept that my physical state of being cannot change. I am allowing myself to walk and sit more comfortably, and I no longer force myself to avoid anything perceived as feminine — I had previously gone so far as not being able to push my hair out of my face. I am still legally changing my name and plan to get a breast reduction instead of a double mastectomy, and I have considered liposuction around my thighs and hips. My breasts are saggy from years of binding, and I was seeking bras that would lift them without straining my ribcage. I am a proud taxidermist and lover of biology and nature. I came to understand that I transitioned because I am homosexual: I am a butch lesbian, and my attraction to men in any expression has completely vanished since detransitioning — I now only admire the male physique aesthetically, like art or a beautiful insect, while women captivate me. I want to be with a woman the same way I would if I were a man. In April 2020 I posted my first video, "Gaining Confidence as a Butch Lesbian After Detransitioning," which was a confidence booster for me. I now believe transitioning is a delusion, an unhealthy coping mechanism, and an escape from reality, and I am critical of transition being offered as the only solution to gender dysphoria, though I acknowledge gender dysphoria itself is real.