All stories

Stuck between two roads, and neither one home

Male · Detransitioned126
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned or detransitioning man who identified as trans after an identity disconnect that began in my early-to-mid teens. I went through with transition but now feel it was the wrong direction, describing myself as unable to have a normal relationship, an embarrassment to my family, and the end of a bloodline. I face a choice between decades of prejudice while living as trans or detransitioning, which I fear would leave me worse off. I still experience dysphoria and don't feel connected to masculinity, but I believe I am a man and don't want to be trans. I hold a measured view of both trans and detrans communities, valuing the insights I gained while recognising resentment and lack of empathy on both sides.

Full story

I've been trying to make sense of a path I ended up on, and I still don't have clean answers. My sense of self collapsed about a year and a bit before I first wrote about it, and since then I've been stuck between not liking or feeling connected to a lot of masculinity, still having dysphoria about a lot of things, and yet concluding that I probably am a man even if I'm not happy about it. I just don't want to be trans. Looking back, the identity disconnect had been developing since my early-to-mid teens, and I don't see how I could have avoided it. When I found the trans community it felt like a port in a storm — a light that answered questions about myself that didn't fit what people say identity is supposed to feel like, showing me how other people steered, with new headings to mark on my map from a shared community who understood many of the same identity issues and were in search of similar destinations. Now the port's closed to me, or at least I'm not in search of the same destination as the other sailors there. I did it. I went through with transition, and now I can't have a normal relationship ever, I'm an embarrassment to my family and myself, the end of a bloodline, and facing either a few decades more of prejudice and insecurity, or detransitioning and being in someone else's position but worse. That comment came from a place of real anguish — it's the most upvoted thing I've written, and it captures how trapped I feel. It's strange to look back at the path walked and recognise that it was the wrong direction, and yet still value its insights so much. I notice in queer spaces there's an assumption that your identity is your own business and you can present how you choose, which challenges expectations in a lot of normal society. I've also seen, from the outside, how quickly people in these spaces can pathologise each other — one exchange I read dismissed someone's account as 'fetishistic' simply because it was focused on sex, which struck me as reductive. I try to hold a balanced view. I see a lot of spite and resentment in detrans spaces, people lashing out at a life choice which didn't work out for them, and I think what the community lacks is empathy and the ability to separate their personal pain from a philosophical stance. When I've engaged with the trans community, they've been among the most feminist, egalitarian and empathetic people I've met. That said, I'm still figuring out where I stand — I don't have a neat resolution, and I'm not sure I ever will.