All stories

Thirteen years as a man, then a butch lesbian again

Female · Detransitioned2.1K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a man for about 13 years, was on testosterone for 7 years and had top surgery before realising my male identity was a coping mechanism rooted in trauma, internalised misogyny and homophobia. I stopped T about three years before deciding to detransition, have refeminised enough to pass as female again apart from facial hair and voice, and I now identify as a masculine gay woman (butch lesbian). I don't regret transitioning overall - it helped me survive - though I wish I'd taken T for a shorter time due to health complications including PCOS, and I'd have chosen a reduction rather than full male chest reconstruction. Detransition has been a profoundly positive experience bringing me peace and enormous personal growth. I remain supportive of trans people while advocating for much greater caution and psychological investigation before transition.

Full story

I had dysphoria throughout my teens without knowing there was a word for it. My life was fine until puberty, and then I could not come to terms with my curvy female body and experienced it as horrific. I grew up in a conservative environment where non-gender-conforming women were treated as ugly and aberrant, and I was bullied for being different. I had a controlling, overprotective single father who wouldn't allow me male friends, so I was trapped in all-female environments that were hostile toward me, and I wasn't permitted any masculine self-expression. I also had a hormonal disorder that messed with puberty with no adult female in my life to help me understand my body, and I was undiagnosed with a physical illness that made life far more traumatic and difficult than it should have been. I developed serious mental health problems including depression and severe social anxiety, and was isolated and unable to take care of myself. I became a video game and fantasy geek, interests considered very masculine at the time, and had an all-male online friend group where I loved feeling like one of the guys. At 18, around the turn of the century, I got internet access and adopted a male identity online because it felt more comfortable. Some time later I found the word transgender and finally understood what I was experiencing. I spent years thoroughly researching transition and talking with trans people before coming out. I was 100% convinced I was trans and remained convinced for a five-year period before transitioning. I transitioned in my mid-twenties, around 2005, before the explosion of interest in transgenderism. I was on testosterone for about 7 years and had top surgery (male chest reconstruction). I had a very disproportionately large chest that caused back pain, physical unwieldiness, and unwanted attention from men on top of the dysphoria. Transition helped me initially - it felt empowering and gave me a boost to begin working my way out of my mental health problems. I was particularly helped by top surgery. However, I also had health complications from T: it induced or exacerbated PCOS, and I had uterine cramps, numbness in arms and legs, fatigue, muscle aches, hot flashes, blood sugar problems, IBS, very high cortisol levels, hair loss, vaginal dryness/atrophy, and increased body odor. T also caused my dysphoria to shift to aspects of my body it hadn't helped, such as wide hips and genitals - I developed genital dysphoria I hadn't previously had and began planning for phallo at one point. I also lost my father, who went no-contact because of my transition. I came off T about 3 years before I decided to detransition, mostly due to health problems and partly due to vanity. I stopped T without telling anyone and let myself refeminise gradually. The realisation that transition was not working for me was complicated: it included profound introspection and personal healing, reading alternative viewpoints about gender, talking with butch women who take a different approach to dysphoria, and understanding that belief in a male identity was working against me. I also became interested in spirituality, meditation and energy work. During meditation I had a vision in which I saw my gender identity represented as a black tornado causing chaos and devastation in my internal landscape, and I consented to working to remove it. I also came to understand I had been dealing with internalised homophobia and misogyny, and revulsion at the sexual attention of men. I realised I was a lesbian - I hadn't figured out my sexuality until after I transitioned, though I suspect I knew subconsciously. Pre-HRT I was somewhere between asexual and male-attracted; T completely reversed that and I became only interested in women; since stopping I'm about 90% female-attracted and describe myself as a gay woman. I also realised my male identity was a form of dissociation and protection - a shield I needed to survive the world. I made a deliberate decision to identify as a masculine woman with dysphoria rather than a man with a female body. I stopped using the word detransition and framed my changes positively to family and friends. I changed my name to a shortened version of my birth middle name and returned to my birth surname, and I intend to change my IDs back to female. I never applied for a gender recognition certificate despite paying £250 for the required letter - I never sent the application. I don't really regret transitioning; it served its purpose at the time. I'm glad I had top surgery as I'm more comfortable with a flat chest, though if I had a do-over I'd have had a radical reduction to an A cup instead of male chest reconstruction. In hindsight I would have taken T for a much shorter time or not at all because it caused health complications. I had a poor surgical result - my nipples did not heal properly and there is visible scarring a decade on. The main things I regret are the health complications from T and the social complicatedness of having lived as trans. I have refeminised pretty completely over the years off T: fat redistribution returned my face and body to female, body hair reduced significantly, and all the hair I lost to male pattern baldness grew back (though not quite as thick as pre-T). The permanent effects are my voice, facial hair, and enlarged clitoris. I pass as female again as long as I don't have visible facial hair, and I'm planning laser hair removal. I'm doing voice training. I like my deep voice. I had remaining breast tissue that swelled with estrogen, giving me approximately an A-cup appearance. I was almost diagnosed with Asperger's at one point but chose not to have the assessment until I dealt with other health problems, and later wondered whether my symptoms were actually caused by CPTSD. Detransition has been a profoundly positive experience for me - I feel a huge weight has dropped off my shoulders, and I've grown enormously. I consider myself a masculine gay woman, a butch lesbian, though I've become uninterested in labels generally. I still sometimes feel envy when I see the kind of man I wanted to be, but it's nothing like before. I'm in the UK. I've become active in detrans communities, regularly posting advice and support, and I was involved in connecting UK detransitioners with a BBC documentary director researching detransition perspectives.