These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned woman who started testosterone as a teen, lived as male for about 17 years, had multiple surgeries including a vaginectomy, and in 2020 stopped identifying as a man, now calling myself "inbetween" or nonbinary. I regret the permanent changes — chiefly facial hair I must shave for life — and I cried feeling I ruined my life and lost 17 years, though I'm taking it a day at a time at nearly 34. I realized transition was driven by misogyny, wanting safety from men, and disliking being a masculine lesbian, and that living as a man made me feel fake and worse. My family has been fully supportive throughout, but support didn't fix my depression. I now support other masculine girls staying off testosterone and run a community space for people like me.
Full story
I have always been what the Black community calls a "stud" — a masculine girl — since I was young, and I've come to accept that. I use the term "inbetween" for myself now, and I use "nonbinary" mainly to connect with other like-minded people who feel inbetween or genderless; nonbinary gatekeepers and their rules have irked me. I started testosterone as a teen and lived as a male for about 17 years. I switched to T gel earlier in 2020 because after years of poking myself with injections I was over it; my levels dropped significantly, and I hadn't had them checked in about six months at that point. I haven't talked to my endocrinologist about estrogen, though I've researched a few topicals and I'm unsure whether I want them. My doctors have been great about supporting my decisions whenever I bring something to them.
I've had multiple surgeries, including a vaginectomy — asking for it was a no-brainer for me because I never wanted to be penetrated by anyone, my orgasms have always come from the clitoris, and I've always felt disgusted having to clean that area, even though I love vaginas. My surgeries did help me. But the permanent changes are what I struggle with: I'll always have facial hair unless I get electrolysis, which I don't want to do, so I shave with clippers and was about to try a razor for the first time, hoping for the smooth face I miss, while dreading that the hair grows so fast I'll have to shave every other day. I wish there were a "reverse medicine." My curves never actually left and I still have thick thighs — body fat redistribution is one of the big misconceptions about T.
This is my first year of feeling free of identifying as a man, and it has felt so good to stop. But juggling my masculinity and femininity hasn't been easy, and some days looking in the mirror and not knowing who's staring back feels worse than pre-T. I plan to change my gender marker next year from M to X, only because it looks "pretty bad ass and rebelish." I feel embarrassed, ashamed, and alienated trying to embrace womanhood after living as a male since I was a teen — like I'm invading space. I've had full support from my family through everything: they wouldn't care if I identified as a zebra cheetah, they use my chosen pronouns and name, they were there for surgeries, and when I told them I identify as nonbinary and explained it means I feel inbetween, they said "okay, whatever makes you happy baby." Even so, their support didn't help my depression; if anything it enabled my identity crisis. They only wanted me happy and didn't know I felt like I was dying on the inside.
I recently started bawling my eyes out because I feel like I ruined my life, wasted so much time, and missed out on opportunities, and because I have to live the rest of my life as a bearded woman. On days I want to feel pretty and more feminine-looking, I feel ugly. I've been researching biological women with beards — there are more than I thought, most just shave from embarrassment, but it seems to be a growing community that's embracing it. My mom tells me not to focus on things I can't change because I can't get those 17 years back. I'll be 34 next year; I may have lost my youth, but I plan to take advantage of the last of my mature years, taking it a day at a time.
What moved me toward stopping was realizing I felt worse and fake living as a man, like I was living a lie. Being in male spaces all those years showed me how much more gross men are — the misogyny and talk that goes on when women aren't around is bad — and it made me glad I'm not attracted to men. I started questioning why I ever wanted to be male and realized my masculinity was different from theirs; masculinity is not a man thing, men just make it toxic. I realized another reason I wanted to be a man was misogyny — women are oppressed under men, women are targets, and other than my body issues, I felt like being a man kept me safe from men. It did keep me safer, but it didn't help my depression.
I also didn't like being a masculine girl or being lesbian, or how society made me feel about it, how girls are treated differently from boys, and how men treat women. I hated having a vagina and wished I had a penis, but I always thought dudes were gross, which makes me wonder why I ever wanted to be a guy outside of wanting a penis and wanting to be with the same sex without being attacked for it. I worry that having a beard while trying to embrace femininity could put me in harm's way — homophobes or transphobes could mistake me for a gay man or a trans woman in early transition. I've never experienced harm that way, but I've seen terrible stories and videos of Black trans women being murdered or attacked for no reason; I carry protection but it's always in the back of my mind.
I told another young person in a forced-transition situation not to do anything permanent, that they should stand up to their parent, and that going off estrogen would let their testosterone come back — unlike the permanent results of testosterone for someone like me. I run a community space for people like me and tell others they are NOT alone, and I envied other masculine women who had the courage to live life masculine without going on T. I hope more young girls realize it's okay to be masculine and still embrace being born female and don't ruin their lives.