These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned male who now identifies as a feminine gay man, a year off HRT as of June 2024 after previously living as a trans woman. I was bullied for femininity from childhood, beaten up twice for being trans, and mistreated by fetishizing men, which contributed to detransitioning. Physically I feel better off hormones (no longer constantly tired) but I still have residual breast tissue ('moobs') and feel depressed and alienated, belonging to no community. I experience urges to retransition but recognize them as partly delusional, and I remain critical of the current trans community, especially autogynephilic transitioners. I have not described suicidal ideation or self-harm in this transcript.
Full story
I was born male and I've always been feminine — long before I knew the word transgender existed. I liked accessories, makeup, long hair and feminine clothes from a young age, and I was bullied for it my entire life. At some point I transitioned and lived as a trans woman, taking testosterone blockers/hormones as part of that. I don't have exact dates for when I first came out or started hormones in my transcript, but I know I stopped hormones and by September 12, 2023 I was four months off T, posting that I was 'feeling better already.' A year later, around June 2024, I was a full year off HRT.
Living as a trans woman was not safe for me. I was beaten up twice for being trans. Dating was worse — I described always meeting 'the worst type of men' when I was trans, men who fetishized trans women and tossed them away, and straight men who wanted to 'experiment' who turned out to be desperate and violent. I don't think I ever felt safe either way.
Coming off hormones helped physically — I stopped feeling tired all the time — but emotionally it's been harder. By June 2024 I was feeling lonely and anxious constantly, and struggling with the urge to retransition. I tried to frame that urge realistically: it was 'the delusional belief that I would be happier, especially in terms of dating,' but I knew the reality of dating as a trans woman was bad. I wished I'd never discovered transitioning existed at all — that my life would have been easier if I'd stayed oblivious to HRT and the whole concept.
I'm trying to accept myself as a feminine gay man. I don't want to be masculine — masculinity feels foreign to me and I've never been masculine. Giving up my feminine presentation to satisfy society's standards would make me miserable, and I'm already hated for being gay anyway, so it wouldn't help. I compared it to telling a tomboy lesbian to stop sports and cut her hair. Still, I said 'living as a feminine man is hard, but living as a trans woman is harder. there's no winning.'
The hardest part is community. I feel like I don't belong anywhere. My own gay community seems to hate feminine men like me — everyone is looking for a masculine man — and my past as a trans woman makes me undesirable to gay men too. I said I felt like 'a disgusting person with moobs,' which tells me I have some residual breast development from hormones that hasn't gone away. I've felt depressed about not being part of any community that validates me.
I also posted in June 2024 that part of why I detransitioned was not wanting to be associated with the current trans community, which I saw as overrun by 'agp transbians.' I distinguished myself from them: as a feminine gay man (what older typology would call HSTS), I transitioned, I believed, because dating men would be easier as a woman, and I had no interest in women. I was critical of autogynephilic transitioners, especially those who transition later in life after porn addiction, and I felt they posed a threat to lesbian spaces and to HSTS trans women like me. I did not see AAP (autoandrophilia) types as dangerous — 'annoying and cringe at the most' — just having a bad view of the gay community.
Right now I'm a year-plus off hormones, identifying as a feminine gay man, dealing with loneliness, anxiety, and periodic urges to retransition, while feeling rejected by both the gay male community and the trans community.