All stories

Five years as a trans man, no transition required

Female · Desisted147
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born female and never physically transitioned, though I thought I was a trans man for roughly half a decade. I now identify as a masculine straight woman who wants to be the 'man' in straight relationships, experiencing what I call cis GNC dysphoria rather than trans dysphoria. I attribute my past trans identification partly to lack of representation of GNC straight people and a fetish-like attraction to masculinity. I struggle with hard-to-control perfectionism that stalls my creative productivity. I currently identify as a detransitioned/desisted GNC woman who embraces female masculinity and small breasts.

Full story

I was born female and have never physically transitioned. For roughly half a decade I thought I was a trans man, but I never pursued hormones or surgery. Calling myself a woman has always felt wrong to me, not because I feel like a man, but because most women are not as masculine as I want to be. Calling myself a 'female animal' feels right, and I even think I'm kind of attractive when I look in the mirror, although I'm only really attracted to males and masculinity, so it would have been better if I were a hot guy. I acknowledge that part of it is just a fetish thing that would likely have led to disappointment if I had actually tried to transition. I think I already am psychologically masculine in a way, because my attitude towards men resembles that of a dominant gay top. I want to look like a Victorian gentle(wo)man but can't really afford to. I get dysphoric-ish from the ubiquity of makeup on women and struggle to find photo collections of women wearing no makeup, especially masculine or androgynous ones. I identify with a certain type of 'plain' natural face while the default woman look involves at least some makeup, which makes a lot of women come across as uncanny-valley to me, and then you add my masculinity on top and average women start to feel like a different sex or even species. I felt trans partially because there's barely any representation of full-on GNC straight people and their relationships. I'm mostly masc4masc and can't even think of any straight couples like that, at most it's just femdom with a strapon. Seeing enthusiastic straight appreciation of masc women on r/RoleReversal was quite encouraging, now I know there are some men out there who would likely love the shit out of what I want to look and act like even in bed. I still wonder how masc of an outfit and haircut I can get before people start pestering me about it. I have some really hard-to-control perfectionism so I'm stuck spending my days not really getting anywhere when it comes to writing, painting, finding new clothes, productivity in general. I hope that once I recover from my deficiencies my brain will get easier to manage. I'm masc because being grouped with gender-conforming women apparently gives me some kind of cis GNC dysphoria, and this dysphoria is enough that deliberately trying to find their facial features on me (as an attempt at cis gender affirmation) made my brain freak out and go 'that's not my face' for a week or so. I'm masc not because I want to escape a tradwife fate, but because I want to be the 'man' in straight sex and relationships -- not in a straight femdom with a strapon way, but more like in a stone butch top way. Basically I want to enjoy men the way typical men enjoy women and would likely feel terrible (possibly even dysphoric) with men who expect the opposite. I measure masculinity in degrees and based more on clothes than body. If a man dresses in something more typical for women (like short shorts and a crop top) then to me he's fem, if he dresses in something more typical for men then he's masc. If he looks feminine in those guy clothes then he's soft masc, same with butch lesbians and women in general. I have small breasts and I like their size, although admittedly I'm a proud 'not like the other girls' and enjoy female masculinity. People can be pretty bad at telling the sex of masc women correctly -- they don't notice the more subtle differences and rely on stereotypes like 'boobs makeup hair skirt'.