These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a desisted, detransitioned-identifying lesbian — I identified as non-binary and then as a man and made HRT and surgery plans, but never medically transitioned, and now describe myself as a gnc gay woman. I still have severe gender dysphoria, which began around puberty at 12, and I attribute it to a mix of internalised homophobia, an eating disorder, internalised misogyny, being the only girl in my family's generation, and possibly PCOS (I was being tested). I was actively encouraged toward transition by my therapist, friends and the trans community, and I resent that my eating disorder and internalised homophobia were never considered. I feel alienated from the LGBT community, being the only lesbian I know among peers who have all transitioned or come out as non-binary, and I have to limit time around trans people or I can spiral. I have not attempted or described suicidal ideation or self-harm in this material.
Full story
I was born female and grew up in a small Australian city, the only girl in my family's generation — a dozen boys and one girl, brothers and endless male cousins. I don't remember having any dysphoria until I hit puberty around 12; after that I loved being mistaken for a guy and hated being perceived as female. Growing up I was mistaken for a boy constantly — I'm tall, with broad shoulders, a defined jawline, thick eyebrows, very hairy legs — and it wasn't until I grew my hair long and gained weight that brought breasts that I started being gendered female.
I was raised on the internet and on Tumblr's "accept everything, no questions" rhetoric. I was into feminism as a little kid, and gender transition caught my interest in my pre-teens. I used to identify as non-binary, then as a man, and I was making HRT and surgery plans when I started developing doubts about the trans community. I went through what I described as a "weird trans-med to gender critical to radfem to something-in-the-middle rabbit hole" and ended up a desister. I now describe myself as a gnc gay woman — a lesbian — though I still have severe gender dysphoria.
Several things fed into my dysphoria and my movement toward transition. I'm gay, and realising that led to internalised homophobia. I have an eating disorder. I've dealt with internalised misogyny. I'm naturally masculine and not feminine in the slightest, and being a woman — "especially an unattractive, masculine, child free, gay woman" — felt like a punishment. I don't want children, and I'm constantly chafing against my wide hips, breasts and uterus. I also noted possible contributors including autism, depression, anxiety, bullying, pressures from parents, living in a misogynistic society, and being the only girl in my generation. I was getting tested for PCOS. I noted that some of these could be effects of gender dysphoria rather than causes.
When I expressed my dysphoria, my therapist told me I was non-binary and encouraged me to go on hormones and get surgery. I heard the same message from friends and other members of the trans community. My eating disorder and internalised homophobia weren't considered at all, and I've become resentful of the community for pushing that narrative. Every medical professional I've raised gender dysphoria with has jumped to recommending medical transition. I don't believe in an "inner soul gender" — that realisation is basically how I ended up identifying as a desister. I think of gender as a social construct similar to nationality: I don't think anyone is inherently a gender, I just think everyone's a sex, though gender expression is a spectrum.
I never medically transitioned, though I do fantasise about it. I've said I'd go on testosterone for the muscle mass alone, and at one point said I was "getting a mastectomy as well, though it'll probably mean flying from my country to the US" — though elsewhere I stated plainly that I obviously haven't medically transitioned. I've done martial arts for a decade and go to the gym trying to build a more masculine figure; I also cut my hair short so I look more masculine when I dress feminine. I'd estimate at least 25% of my dysphoria comes from the fact I'll always be weaker and shorter than men. Guns are not legal in my country and I don't want one — I want to not be the weaker sex.
I decided I could never live the life of a cis man and didn't want the life of a trans man: "I wish I was a man with every fibre of my soul. I just realised I could never live the life of a cis man, and I didn't want the life of a trans man." I also framed it as realising there's nothing fundamentally different about my experience and that of the standard pre-op trans guy — "I wasn't faking."
On causes, I've written a lot about what I think drives female transition. I believe a significant amount of FTM people have eating disorders prior to transition and/or internalised homophobia and misogyny, and that this isn't talked about. I've discussed autogynephilia and autoandrophilia as controversial proposed explanations but said I don't think they're anyone's sole cause — "most transitions are complicated and caused by a lot of things." I've also raised suspicions about the money in the transition surgery industry, citing a $316 million sex reassignment surgery market in 2019 projected to reach $1.5 billion by 2026 and an average transition cost around $150,000, while saying I don't believe there's a huge conspiracy pushing kids to be trans. I've advised a young person with mild dysphoria not to transition, saying the medical toll is underrepresented on trans subreddits and that transition often doesn't even resolve dysphoria.
Mental health-wise, I have an eating disorder, and I've referenced depression and anxiety as possible factors. I don't read feminist discourse or texts like I used to because they're often painful reminders, and I have to spend less time around trans people or I can spiral. Some days there's nothing else I want to talk about, and every day the question crosses my mind for at least a few minutes. I've been told by others that I sound like I'm dealing with internalised misogyny and homophobia, and I acknowledge it myself even while saying I know the arguments against it.
Socially, I feel deeply alienated. I tried to join my university's queer collective but the leader uses bone/it pronouns, and it was mostly trans or nonbinary people and feminine bi girls. I hate the word "queer." The "lesbian = non-man loving non-man" framing makes my soul shrivel. Literally every other gay woman I know — three of them, in my small city — now identifies as non-binary or trans; I'm the only lesbian I know. Some of my closest friends are uncritical of the trans narrative and we've had conversations where I was treated as transphobic; we just don't talk about it now. I don't have a partner but was hopeful. I have to finish my degree and hope to move somewhere bigger. I've said having my views on trans issues makes me "a minority in a minority in a minority."
I don't have a settled position on transition for others — I've said transition is unrealistic for me for medical, financial, social, cosmetic and philosophical reasons, and that living with gender dysphoria sucks with no good therapy for it. I've advocated for better treatments for dysphoria and for waiting longer before medical transition.