All stories

Crushing on girls at 12 and calling it not-like-other-girls

Female · Desisted2.3K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who came to gender confusion through childhood crushes on girls, internalised misogyny, and a strong desire not to be sexualised or associated with pregnancy. I desisted after realising I could love my body and my masculine interests without changing my sex, and I now identify as a bisexual woman. I have been active in detrans communities, offering support while holding a critical but compassionate view of transition, especially for minors. I still experience residual dysphoria around my breasts, pregnancy, and being short, and I manage tokophobia with continuous hormonal birth control. I have no current medical needs related to transition and describe myself as having grown out of my earlier "not like other girls" mindset.

Full story

I was born female, and looking back I can trace my confusion about gender to childhood rather than to any early sense of being trans. I had crushes on girls and couldn't understand why, so I would pretend to be a boy online in order to talk to girls and have online girlfriends. It was only later, once I discovered the terms, that I started thinking this must mean I was always meant to be genderfluid or trans. Alongside that, I was taught to look down on women for being weak and vain, so I developed a lot of internalised misogyny and wanted to be anything but a woman. I also had what I now call "not like other girls" syndrome — I directly and indirectly looked down on femininity because I didn't like pink, dresses, makeup or dolls, and I was awkward and unfeminine, so I concluded I wasn't really a girl. I grew out of that insecure and sexist mindset. My dysphoria was tied up with sexuality and with not wanting to be sexualised. I was uncomfortable with my breasts — not because I disliked having them exactly, but because I didn't want people looking at my sexual bits. I have always worn baggy, full-coverage clothes, dark colours and patterns to blend my torso away, and I don't wear bras most of the time so they're flatter. I used to think this was dysphoria, but I've come to think I just don't want people to see them. Part of my dysphoria was also that I didn't want to be a woman because women can get pregnant; I felt disdain for my breasts and my period, and jealousy towards men, which I still feel to some degree. I never ever wanted to give birth, and since so many women look forward to pregnancy, I sometimes felt I wasn't really a woman. I also recall that while I was always depressed, the popularity of self-harm awareness — even people talking about their struggles or trying to stay clean — influenced me into self-harm; I probably never would have cut if I had never learned about it. I eventually realised I wasn't trans. My biggest desist victory was realising I could love the body I was in and also love everything else about myself — my tits had nothing to do with my fashion or my hobbies, and my masculine interests never got in the way of finding a mate. I now identify as a woman, and I'm bisexual. I've said that while I'm bisexual I still feel bitter and want to "prove" my bisexuality to my mom, even though I shouldn't have to. I've also noted that gender critical spaces feel like a minefield — if someone learns I'm gender critical they usually think I'm transphobic, but I have compassion for trans people, not disgust or disdain. I'm 5'1 (I've also said 5'2) with large hips and breasts, and being short has made me feel patronised and resentful, especially when taller, stronger men seem to command more respect by default. I've said I've always hated it when men rub their physical strength in my face, and that it made me feel inferior and unsafe — "I don't know why I thought transitioning would give me a leg up." I have tokophobia (a phobia of pregnancy) and therefore pretty much have to use some form of hormonal birth control; I take it continuously, with no pill breaks, to prevent my period, and I refuse a copper IUD because of the tokophobia. I don't trust condoms because I have no control over them. On transition and medicine more broadly, I'm sceptical. I've said minors cannot consent and that complete transition is still possible past 18, and I've repeatedly advised people not to get surgery as soon as they turn 18 — "Do not do it. You can always do it later if you're 1000% sure, but you can never undo it." I've expressed concern about children under 11 identifying as non-binary, arguing it's rooted in not conforming to stereotypical standards, and I've said I'm confused about what people expect opposite-sex hormones to do, warning about patchy beards, balding, voice changes, fat redistribution, and on oestrogen, poorly structured breasts and easier fat gain. I've also said I'd be more comfortable if doctors were sued for transitional regret, though elsewhere I've argued adults paying for a cosmetic procedure shouldn't be able to sue for getting what they asked for, and that grown adults can make their own choices about their bodies. I've suggested medical tourism as an option for people who can't access procedures in the U.S., and I've called the healthcare system "broken and corrupt" and its double standards around hysterectomy "absolutely misogyny." I've been active in detrans spaces, describing the sub as a place for detransitioners to talk about their experiences and support one another, with a wide range of ideologies — some anti-trans, some still pro-trans but realising they themselves aren't trans. I've said detrans trauma isn't a pro-trans or transphobic talking point, and that detransition should be treated gently rather than as an anti-trans talking point. I've predicted that in 20-30 years many transitioned people will detransition as the pendulum swings back to the middle. I've also said I constantly get TikToks of people bashing detransitioners. I've given a lot of advice to others: encouraging people to explore identity without rushing, to detach from restrictive labels, to identify with their name rather than their gender, and to seek out gender exploration therapy. I've advised parents to take a neutral stance — "I'm not telling you who you are... let's sit down and talk this through" — while holding that children shouldn't physically transition until 18, though social transition can be acceptable as healthy gender exploration. I've also been supportive of people staying on hormones or having surgery if it genuinely helps them, and of people identifying as non-binary if it helps them detransition comfortably. On sexuality and womanhood, I've said I think girls don't tend to transition for sexual reasons — for me it was the complete opposite: as a woman I wanted to be desexualised. I've also said I've always been jealous of the male ability to have sex and easily orgasm, and that I find my sexual experience dull by comparison because of how difficult it is to feel pleasure and the lack of a physical release. I've expressed resentment about pregnancy feeling like "a punishment for being female" and dehumanising, and pushed back when others told me I was being unfair. I've argued that gender is entirely sociological and "made up," that there's no right way to be a man or woman, and that freedom from gender ideology is learning that your personal traits are separate from your sex. I've been critical of rigid gender roles from both conservative and progressive directions, saying that "dresses are for girls and suits for boys" thinking is what led to the gender crisis in the first place, and that it's not ok to be different anymore — there's just a new box you get shoved into. I've also been supportive of butch women and of women getting breast reductions, and I've given a lot of practical femininity and makeup advice to detransitioning women.