All stories

Five years moderating r/detrans after losing two friends

Female · Detransitioned176
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned member and moderator of online communities who has been active in r/detrans since October 2019. I have written that I was 'pretty deep in some echo chambers' myself and that I lost two friends for not supporting them through their trans surgery ideas. I strongly advise against transition, urge people to get offline, and am critical of how trans ideology is reaching young people, saying I hope we 'stop ruining our kids.' I have not posted a full account of my own transition or detransition timeline. My current identity is a detransitioned person who is critical of transition, especially for youth.

Full story

I have been an active participant in the r/detrans community since at least October 2019, and I have also served as a moderator of a large subreddit (an alt account), which has given me experience managing difficult conversations online. I have reflected a lot on how people end up identifying as trans and how to reach those who are heading toward transition. I have noted that I have been 'pretty deep in some echo chambers' myself in the past and probably would not have received help well at the time, which shapes how I think about intervening. I have asked others in the community what the best method is for offering help to trans youth pre-transition as they are steeped in 'TRA culture online,' and who would be the best person to approach them — a professional, parent, trusted friend, or school personnel. I have also commented on how privileged an issue gender concern is, observing that you are unlikely to worry about your gender when you are struggling to eat alongside the rest of your community. I have given direct advice to people considering transition: 'I'd say don't transition no matter what people tell you. I'd also say get offline and stay offline. For like 6 months.' I have also suggested that people asking for first-person accounts tag their posts 'detrans only replies.' When someone described knowing a person in real life who was considering transition, I asked whether they knew statistics about HRT and how it changes you in ways you may not be signing up for. On the question of supporting friends through trans surgery ideas, I wrote: 'You can't reason someone out of a position they didn't reason themselves into. Desiring both genetilia is neither normal nor reasonable, and personally I have lost two friends for not supporting them through their trans surgery ideas.' I advised the person to consider whether the friendship was truly worth their emotional energy, to take care of themselves first, and that they are not responsible for anyone else's mental health. This is the clearest reference in my own writing to friendships lost over disagreement about transition — I have not posted a full account of my own experience. I have expressed strong views about the current approach to trans-identified youth: after watching a video, I wrote 'Powerful stuff. Sad stuff. I hope we fix this soon and stop ruining our kids.' I have also commented that kids are resourceful and the internet is big, in the context of restricting access. On the relationship between gender identity and sexual orientation, I have said that gender identity is 'piggybacking on the sexual orientation train' but is not a sexual orientation and therefore has little to do with issues discussed in LGB-focused spaces. I have emphasized the importance of maintaining connections with LGB people, who 'still deserve love and support,' and I have praised the sub for being civil and well moderated 'for such a scary topic internet-wise.' I have also offered practical safety advice to someone considering making videos online, recommending they hire a third party with removal powers over the videos to manage the account and filter messages before the person sees them, noting that celebrities do this to prevent gross misbehavior. In July 2020 I responded to someone in acute pain, writing 'I can feel the pain in your writing. I'm so sorry I have no suggestions. But I wanted to let you know that someone read it, and I wish you the best. This sub is here for you.' I have not publicly detailed my own transition timeline, medical interventions, surgeries, mental health diagnoses, or the specifics of my detransition in the material available. What is visible is my sustained critical stance toward transition, particularly for young people, my sense of having been inside echo chambers myself, and my grief over friendships lost for not supporting friends' trans surgery plans.