All stories

Pressured by both sides, then cold-shouldered by both

Female · DetransitionedTransition 16 → Detransition 19531
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a man and was on testosterone for a period before stopping because of the health effects and because I realised I never actually wanted to be a man — I just hated existing in public as a woman in a misogynistic society. I never experienced dysphoria, and I was pressured into identifying as trans by both the conservatives of my childhood and the progressives who called me an 'egg'. Since detransitioning I've become more physically sensitive, still cry when I think about what I look like, and have been cold-shouldered by queer circles in my city after Instagram stories about me circulated. I don't identify with womanhood as an identity — it's just a descriptor — and I'm active in detrans communities, angry about misinformation and censorship of detransitioners. I'm currently living in an in-between state, still often read as male, and I haven't detransitioned in earnest.

Full story

I was born female and grew up in India — I've mentioned being from south India and living in Chennai, one of India's most traditional major cities. I was tomboyish as a kid and studied at a conservative high school where I was repeatedly told I was 'not a real woman' because I wasn't feminine. I didn't care much at the time because I assumed I'd eventually move somewhere liberal and be accepted for my tastes. When I did get to a more liberal environment, the opposite happened: the people there told me I was 'a caterpillar about to break out' (their version of 'egg') and non-binary. That really messed with me. The people I thought would accept me for who I was also told me I wasn't a real woman because I didn't perform womanhood correctly. I described it as the conservatives of my childhood and the progressives working in tandem. This led to around two years of constant self-questioning, trying to pass, and trying to figure out what gender I *felt like*. I also noted that people would tell me they thought I was a man — cis or trans — which was part of the reason I transitioned, even though I said I personally didn't want to at that point. I moved away from home at 16. I never came out to my family as trans; they are very conservative (homosexuality is wrong, you will marry a man and be a good wife). I transitioned socially and medically — I was on testosterone ('T', which I've referred to as steroids) for a period. Around six months into transition, it hit me that I was 'messing with my body, desperately policing my behaviour, ruining my mental health; all for something I didn't really want.' I never experienced dysphoria, whether I was read as male or female. The first few months after I began passing were nice — I said men really do have it better, and I liked being left alone rather than being seen as a man per se — but then my mind 'got weird about gender' and I began questioning the logic behind trans theory, and it fell apart for me. I stopped taking testosterone because of the long-term health effects and because I realised I wasn't really a man and never could be, and that I didn't even want to be one — I just hated existing in public as a woman. I described feeling like I could 'opt out of living in a misogynistic society' and said transitioning felt like an individual fix to a societal problem. I also said that if it weren't for the health risks of T I would probably still be on it, and that I might retransition if I'm old and it becomes medically safer. I told everyone I'm not trans anymore and stopped socially identifying as trans. I still get clocked as male because of thick facial hair and other effects, but I'm too exhausted to put effort into passing as female, so I just roll with whatever people use for me. I said I haven't bothered with detransitioning in earnest, so I 'just look inbetween now.' On the medical side, since coming off T I've become a lot more sensitive to everything: I almost always have a rash or hives somewhere, most things make me sneeze and my eyes water, and I tolerate a smaller range of foods. I noted it had only been a few months since I finally quit, so I couldn't say how it would work out long-term, and I worried my hormones might be 'permanently out of whack till I see a doctor and have them fix me.' I also mentioned developing a strong jawline ('Chad like on my bad days; Tilda Swinton like on good ones') alongside baby-ish round cheeks, and hoping it evens out. I miss how strong T made me. Mentally, I said I still cry when I think about what I look like, but that I felt similarish while on steroids, so it might just be me. I recommended CBT methods for dysmorphia as having been rather helpful. I picked up gardening and playing the keyboard, and for a few months, every time I thought about gender, I'd aggressively think about my garden instead. Of late I don't think about gender at all and am much happier with myself. Detransitioning included working on my self-esteem: I hated how being perceived as a woman came with expectations, but so did being perceived as a man, and I was 'too much like the other gender in both cases.' I still hate being perceived and interpreted by other people, but accepting that I can't control others has made me much happier, and I no longer blame myself when they misinterpret me. On causes, I said I wasn't really bullied into identifying as trans because I never cared either way, but I did feel pressured — a combination of the conservative messaging of my childhood and the progressive 'egg' messaging, plus a healthy degree of people telling me I'm an egg. I also said that what led me to transition was what another person described, plus that pressure. I don't identify with woman or womanhood — it's just what I am, in the same way I don't identify as being tall; they're all just descriptors. I think we should meddle with the body as little as possible and only seek to change it when what's natural is messing with our health. Socially, I've had a complicated time since detransitioning. I was excommunicated from the queer circles in my city and, by extension, the middle-class liberal circles. Things got bad about 14 months before August 2021 when a group of MOGAI-style people (and their straight allies) shared Instagram stories listing my 'crimes against queer people.' It isn't life-ruining, but the low-level cold-shouldering is annoying: whenever I meet a new group, it's fine until someone recognises me from the Instagram stories and they all pull away a bit. In two cases people have privately told me they don't think what I did was bad, but no one wants to be seen as bad by association. My friends have stood by me and no one above 30 cares. I was well known in my city partly because I had an orange mohawk in Chennai and had 'street cred' since I'm poor-ish and used to volunteer with Thirunangais (what the West calls Hijras), though I wasn't popular in the 'having clout' sense. I often get called a Hijra, a catch-all for gay men, non-passing trans women and GNC male-bodied people in general — and I used to be terrified of being clocked as female. I'm not close with my family. As of August 2021 I was 20, having just turned 20 that month, and was considering going home to visit them for the first time in three years, undecided about whether to tell them about 'the whole mess' or claim it was a late puberty. I have a job prepared for when I leave college. I never intended to go back home since they're conservative. I've been active in detrans communities online. I was angry about r/detrans being banned and about attempts to take it over, saying 'I actually hate every single one of those fuckers trying to get us banned.' I blocked around 90 people who rubbished r/detrans. I was also angry about misinformation surrounding the Keira Bell case, making a post about it. I worry that trans people paint detrans people as transphobic/terfy bogeymen or misguided self-hating trans people, while conservatives like Abigail Shrier paint us as mutilated victims — 'our actual stories seem to be erased in favour of whatever best suits whoever wants to weaponise our lives.' I said I don't have anywhere to actually talk about my issues with the trans way of looking at gender because I'm worried it'll be called transphobic and get the sub banned again. I hate spaces like egg_irl and gender critical, both of which seem dogmatic. I believe people should be free to do what they want as long as they aren't hurting anyone else, but it can be hard to tell if you actually want something or if external factors and social conditioning are making you desire it. I've given advice to others questioning transition: wait until 25, try not to think about gender for a while, pick up hobbies, think of your body as your true self rather than something to change, and consider whether you want a male body or just a flat chest. I told one person they sounded genuinely trans and that HRT might be best for them, and told another that detransitioning due to external pressure is the same as transitioning due to external pressure. I also said gait and a more monotone voice helped me more than HRT at passing.