These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I considered transitioning for a couple of years but never started hormones or surgery, and I now understand that my body image issues stemmed from my disability and from not fitting society's expectations of femininity rather than from being a woman. I'm a disabled, bisexual woman who would ideally want to be a gay man, but I recognize transition could never give me that, and I'm currently happy on my own. I believe transitioning doesn't solve body image problems and often creates new ones, and I've shared this view to support others questioning transition. I have never taken estrogen and have had no medical interventions. I remain someone who doesn't feel like a man but doesn't fully identify with conventional womanhood either.
Full story
I'm someone who knows they're not a guy but doesn't feel like a girl either. When I was little I always wanted to be a boy, and for a couple of years I even considered transitioning, but I never actually started hormones or surgery. Ultimately I realized that the sort of man I thought I could be happy being was a kind of man I could never become.
A lot of what drove my body image issues came from elsewhere. I'm disabled, which is a big part of it — I always have to wear athletic shoes, which has actually been a bigger detriment to self-expression than you might expect, because I can't wear the cute outfits that would need cute shoes or boots with. I also don't fit into many of the boxes society allows for women. I'm not feminine at all: I don't have the patience for makeup, and I shave my legs maybe twice a year at most. I don't identify with the constant barrage of media telling us what women are like and how they behave and feel and think. When I was younger I thought my inability to identify with any of that meant I couldn't be a woman. Over time I realized it wasn't being a woman I had an issue with, but the way society treats women. Judith Butler's *Gender Trouble* helped me realize a lot about why I felt the way I did about being a woman.
I started having doubts about transitioning when I looked into the realities of what it would be like. I didn't want to deal with acne, facial hair, even more body hair, and balding. Also, no matter how much surgery I could afford, I would never have a completely functioning penis the way a cis man would, I would never be tall or muscular, and I would still have my disability. In short, I would never be the sort of man I would want to be if I could wave a magic wand and become an ideal man. I'm glad I spent a long time researching and reflecting before beginning any kind of transitioning — internal reflection is key to knowing what you want, especially for something as drastic as hormonal or surgical transition. I have an FTM friend who lives in a country with good health services and he still almost died from surgery going wrong; even when everything goes right, your body still doesn't really function properly. I wish more people would realize that transitioning will not magically solve the problems they have with their body, and will likely bring a bunch of new ones.
On sexuality: I'm bisexual. I think I would be happiest being a gay man in a gay relationship, and I've said before that if I could press a button and magically become a man I would still do it. I think the best option for me as I am would be to date a bisexual man, though for now I'm actually pretty happy on my own.
I've never taken estrogen — other people have told me I don't look even a bit androgynous and that they wouldn't guess I'd ever been on E. I've offered support to others in similar positions, telling them that liking 'feminine' things doesn't make them less of their gender, and that not fitting the popular image of a gender doesn't mean you're not that gender. I've also pointed out to parents that their child's trans identification may be tied up with body image issues beyond just coping with being gay, especially if the child doesn't 'perform femininity' in a way society accepts. Overall I'd describe my position as someone who considered transition, researched it seriously, and decided against it because I understood it wouldn't give me the body or life I actually wanted.