These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I previously identified as non-binary and came out to my spouse around 2021, but desisted after she said she could no longer live with my gender identity. Since then my dysphoria has returned intensely, at times with secret thoughts of male-to-female transition, but I have resolved to desist for myself and am trying to make peace with who I am rather than medically transition. I have not had any medical interventions, and I found therapy unhelpful because I felt therapists only wanted to affirm rather than help me manage the dysphoria. Reading detransition material has helped me feel less alone, though I expect dysphoric thoughts may stay with me for life. I currently identify as a desisted, previously non-binary male.
Full story
I came out to my spouse as non-binary around 2021, and for a while I felt confident and authentic, like this was really me. The dark side was an almost constant need to appear more feminine through clothing, posture, makeup, and how I carried myself — a constant uphill battle. Physically I was thin and couldn't grow a beard or much body hair, but at 6'1 with a male build I was never as androgynous as I wanted. HRT crossed my mind, but I knew explaining breast growth would be difficult and the prospect of becoming infertile made it seem selfish. I tried natural supplements for a while, but they were a waste of money.
About a year after coming out, my spouse broke down and told me she could no longer live with my gender identity. I was devastated. Part of me knew she was onto something, but I didn't want to acknowledge it. I desisted pretty much overnight, though not completely of my own volition. It's been two years now, and the dysphoria came and went — but when it returned it came with a vengeance. Instead of non-binary, I was secretly considering male-to-female transition. I'd try on women's clothing to see what was most flattering, experiment with heavier makeup and gender-swapping Snapchat filters, and think things like whether I could microdose estrogen gradually enough that nobody would notice.
It was all pie in the sky, and I knew it. The depression was terrible, compounded by the fact that no matter what I did I would never escape who I was: raised male, socialized male, predominantly male interests, male build, male genes. Sure I could fool the camera with the right lighting and makeup, but turn my head slightly and it was obvious I was male. Filters made me feel worse because I knew they were fake — they're designed to give you dopamine and nothing else, a harmful exercise in delusion and futility. Would hormones and surgery help? Perhaps, but I'd still be 6'1 with very masculine proportions.
I finally resolved to desist for myself and not just for my spouse, but the dysphoria was still there. I figured I'd have to make peace with it and needed help. None of my friends would understand, and seeking therapy was worthless — all these therapists wanted to do was affirm people. I don't want to be affirmed, I want to be rid of this, or at least able to manage it. I began reading detrans material, and it helped a lot. I can't relate to any of the medical things because I haven't had any of that, but the thoughts and feelings people described I could relate to. I described having two souls: one screaming to embrace my authentic self, the other replying that my authentic self is a sham I'll never be happy with. My heart wants the former, but my head knows the latter is correct.
I've resigned myself to the fact that dysphoric thoughts will probably be with me for life, and having mental health challenges of my own doesn't help. I also don't have a strong sense of self, which is part of my struggle. I've been slowly learning that I'll be better off making peace with what I am instead of embarking on a journey that holds no guarantee of true happiness. I've advised others in similar situations to do whatever they need to do to make peace with who they are and develop their identity outside of gender, warning that fixating on reconciling who you see yourself as with who you see in the mirror only compounds the problems — as it did for me.
I've become critical of certain aspects of transition culture: I've questioned why some behavior isn't considered a red flag for mental illness, saying letting people continue on like that is unkind to everyone. I've expressed frustration that masculine women and feminine men are still treated as others — just once I'd like to do something feminine and not be instantly labeled gay, non-binary, or an 'egg.' I've said it makes my blood boil how entrenched these flawed concepts have become in medical literature, while conceding that some people probably genuinely believe they were born in the wrong body — but that's not everyone; some of us are or were lost. I've also commented that gender-swapping filters adjust your facial features to match the proportions of the sex you're trying to replicate, but seeing the whole person in real life tells a different story, and that the whole thing is fake — it does nothing besides give people the wrong idea of what being trans really looks like.
Currently I identify as desisted, having previously identified as non-binary, and I wonder to what extent non-binary identity is just a stop on the road to transition — it certainly felt like that for me, though some simply seem to grow out of it. I have not undergone any medical transition.