All stories

A near-perfect transition, then emptiness

Male · Detransitioned53
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, identified as trans (MTF) for several years, and began detransitioning in 2021 after reaching a near-perfect transition result and feeling empty. I regret transitioning, mourn the lost time and experiences, and wish I had worked through my trauma, abuse, and mental health issues before being pushed toward hormones by therapists. I now reconcile that I am a man but mostly just see myself as me, and I am still early in detransition, feeling scared and sad but certain it is right. I remain concerned about irreversible changes, fertility, lifelong hormones, and the impossibility of becoming biologically female. I am a detransitioned woman... correction: I am a detransitioned person who was born male and now identifies as male/detransitioned, and I actively argue online that neither sex has it inherently easier and that misandry can fuel self-hatred.

Full story

I was born male and identified as trans (MTF) for a handful of years before beginning to detransition in 2021. Looking back, I fit every stereotype from childhood up to the point I decided to transition, so transition seemed like the obvious and perfect answer — I was, in my words, "the perfect case." My dysphoria was very painful and I didn't see any other option, and no one cared to give me any other option either, so I wasn't able to truly explore my feelings and reasoning at the time. When I started transitioning I was excited. I felt awkward initially because I still looked in-between, and I needed to learn to fit in like any other woman. I kept going forward without hesitation and finally arrived at what I wanted: I passed, was attractive, had friends, and made a life for myself. I got exactly what I wanted and arrived at a near perfect result — and when I realized I had arrived there, I felt empty. You keep expecting it to get better, but you eventually hit a wall. Starting hormones and living as "myself" had been the most exciting feeling I could imagine; the rush faded once there was nowhere left to go. Once I reached that point, I realized what I actually wanted: to be a mother and carry my own child; real sex like other women, since no surgery will give me a true vagina; the experiences of growing up that others had, which are impossible to recover; not having to take hormones for the rest of my life to be "me"; and to be able to date without saying I am transgender. I also came to see that surgical results were not good enough, with many complications delivering less than perfect outcomes, and that hormones for life carry health concerns. No children as a trans woman. Dating is extremely hard — I have standards, and being trans shrinks the pool enormously, plus there is always the fear of someone digging into my past or just being able to tell. Trans subreddits want to make it seem you are authentic no matter what, but to me it isn't. I just wanted to be a woman, not a woman who is trans. Nothing can change your sex. At the end I realized it would never be enough, and I wasn't able to truly live my life being trans. Time doesn't stop, so staying in that place was no longer acceptable. Through everything I was able to reconcile with myself that I am a man, and also to stop seeing myself as a "man" in the abstract and just see myself as me. I have been able to admit and work through a lot of experiences, like trauma and abuse, that I wish I had dealt with long before. I had an extreme amount of mental health issues, and I am annoyed that you are sort of just pushed through towards transition to "fix" your problems — if you say the magic words, all the therapists and people around you push you towards taking hormones to become your authentic self. Contributing factors for me included what men represented to me. I had a lot of bad experiences with men and boys and a lot of issues with my father, and I had no male role models (though I did and do have women as role models). It turned me off and made me feel uncomfortable with myself; I saw myself as inferior and broken based on it. When I was little and growing up I had horrible and negative experiences with men — I hated them and thought of them as inferior, and I wanted to be the farthest thing from them because I never had the experience of being proven wrong. It was a definite contributor to my issues and eventually transitioning. Trauma and other issues strongly contributed as well. At the time it seemed simple, but now I see and feel how messy it really was. I am still early in my detransition. I am scared and sad as well, but I know detransitioning is for me, and I regret transitioning originally. I mourn the time I lost and the person I was. I am extremely saddened about the things I did and the people and experiences I lost, and I still haven't fully moved past that. I wish I had tried to work through my issues before, to allow myself to live a fulfilling life, but I was in a horrible place without anyone to question me. On practical matters I have discussed with others: actual breast growth from hormones stays, though fat redistribution makes the overall result smaller; and fertility is not guaranteed but many people seem to return to normal after hormones balance out, though the longer one is on them the more uncertain it becomes. I was hoping to get some related procedure covered by insurance. I also commented that I prefer my current look overall, though I understand missing one's old face. In terms of attitudes, I have argued at length that neither sex has it inherently easier. I disagree that men are inherently advantaged in authority or financial success, and I do not see society-enforced misogyny on a grand scale in the USA. I believe saying one sex suffers more is wrong, and that constantly promoting women as victims can lead to learned helplessness in young girls. I have pushed back against negative generalizations about men, arguing that misandry can cause someone to hate themselves and want to be the sex that isn't as "broken" — possibly including detransitioned people. I also noted that women receive more general attention and care, while men are seen as more disposable, and that the extra visibility placed on women can make young women feel under the microscope. I value this subreddit for having voices that help us understand each other and ourselves.