All stories

A detransitioned man skeptical of his own tribe's research

Male · Detransitioned180
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, lived for a time as a trans woman, and have since detransitioned; I now describe myself as a detransitioned man who has sex with trans women. I do not give specific ages or dates for my dysphoria, coming out, hormones, or any surgeries, so those timeline points are unknown. I do not express strong regret about my own transition in these posts, but I am deeply skeptical of other trans people's self-reports and of detransition research. I think people's lives are generally better off if they are not trans, while also believing the subreddit should not blanket-oppose transition. I have not described mental health diagnoses, trauma, family reactions, or current quality of life in the supplied material.

Full story

I was born male and identified as a trans woman at some point before detransitioning; I have not given a specific age or year for when I first felt dysphoria, came out, started hormones, or had any surgery, so those dates are unknown. What I do know is that I went through a period of living as a trans woman and then detransitioned, and I describe the change plainly: 'now that I have Detransed, I have sex with mtfs and they think I am a “straight” man as well.' Before detransition I was involved with men I perceived as 'straight' — 'Yes Iv been with “straight” men' — and I now frame that as evidence that such men are not actually straight if they want to be with someone like me. I also say my experience 'isn't too different than how I feel' when responding to another detransitioner, but note 'you won't be able to relate to me because we are opposite sex,' which tells me I read myself as male and the person I was addressing as female. On the medical side, I have discussed HRT effects in detail, particularly penile atrophy, and I state from my own experience that 'Mine did not shrink' while on hormones, and that shrinkage can be avoided 'as long as you are masturbating and it is getting to full erecting length routinely.' I have not mentioned any surgeries, fertility concerns, or ongoing medical needs in these posts. I have not described any complications or irreversible changes I experienced myself. I do not describe a specific mental health diagnosis, but I am highly skeptical of other trans people's self-reports, saying 'You can never trust trans people to be reliable narrators' and that they 'retcon their histories all the time,' based on 'interacting with trans people for years and seeing how much they lie to themselves. Especially the older generation.' I am also skeptical of studies on detransition for the same reason, worrying that people who 'tried to transition at 18 and had to repress' and are 'now at 48... ready to be true selves' would distort the data, and suggesting an age cutoff 'at say 35' to 'weed a lot of those hon types out of the data.' I have not described trauma, abuse, assault, bullying, or family dysfunction in these posts, and I have not described my family's reaction to my transition or detransition. On sexuality, I appear to be male-attracted or at least open to sex with male partners post-detransition, since I say I now 'have sex with mtfs.' I also comment on pornography and sexual fetishes as a possible driver of gender confusion in others, asking a therapist whether they discuss with male patients 'how their porn consumption could influence their sexual and gender confusion' and noting that 'Male masochistic emasculation fetishes are becoming more and more common.' I do not express much overt regret about my own transition in these posts; instead I am argumentative and somewhat dismissive of other people's transition-related anxieties, telling one person they are 'a victim of obsession over penis' and 'catastrophizing,' and telling another 'I think you have a flawed understanding of yourself. Good luck.' I do not describe my current quality of life, career, family situation, or support network. I have not described any advocacy or activism, though I am clearly an active participant in detransition-related online discussion. My overall attitude toward transition for others is mixed: I say 'This sub should not be telling people not transition as a rule, it's simple for sharing experiences,' but I also think 'your life will be better off if you ARENT trans,' and I encourage one poster to explore 'the risks and potential downsides of living as a “trans woman”' rather than only the negatives of male presentation. I am critical of trans communities, particularly what I see as autogynephilic ('agp') trans women who 'hypersexualize the existence of young women,' and I am comfortable using community slang like 'hon' and 'trade/downlow dick.'