All stories

A year of they/them, then choosing she/her

Female · Desisted192
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned/desisted woman: born female, I socially transitioned partially for about a year (they/them pronouns, binding, androgynous presentation) while seriously considering testosterone, then committed in early 2021 to not transitioning and went back to she/her. I never took hormones or had surgery. Transition desires were driven by longings to be a gay man, a sense of being illegible, body self-disgust, masculine childhood traits I felt shame about, and possibly an 'erotic target location error' around attraction to men. Weightlifting, actually dating men, and reframing myself as 'a woman with transgender feelings' rather than someone with an innate gender identity have been the biggest helps. I have no current advocacy role but I'm active in this community as someone who decided against transition, and I advise others to exhaust non-medical options before starting HRT.

Full story

I was born female and have never taken testosterone or had any surgeries, so my story is one of questioning, partial social transition, and then deciding against medical transition. Growing up I was always the most physically aggressive girl on every sports team, and in math class I was the only girl who acted like the guys — asking questions, shouting answers, showing off, clowning around. I felt a ton of shame about it, and I'm sure it contributed to my not being popular or dateable, but I could never stop myself. I had disordered eating and body image issues growing up, at their most intense around age 10-11, which was definitely not about wanting to be sexy — more about control, purity, escaping embodiment. I also struggled with gender and sexuality a lot as a kid and a teenager. As a young adult I tried very hard to be queer, which mostly meant having mostly queer friends, dressing masc (ties, Doc Martens, flannel), and not dating anyone, since I wasn't attracted to women and felt alienated by heterosexuality. I had an intense platonic relationship with a gay male friend as a teen, several celibate years, then a relationship with an AMAB genderqueer person — I didn't have sex until that relationship, at age 24 — and then celibacy again. After a decade of angsting and questioning sexuality, the bottom line is that I'm only attracted to male bodies; having had PIV sex made me very clear that that's my thing. I went through a long phase of dressing specifically to try to get people to read me as a lesbian because I wanted to be one so badly — I think because I felt I had this masculinity that wanted to come out and lesbianism was the image of female masculinity I knew. Then came my 'egg cracking' moment of realizing I had all these longings to be a gay man. The things that pulled me toward transition: a sense that the cruel inner critic when I looked at myself wasn't a straight man telling me I wasn't hot enough but a gay man saying 'ew, take all that off'; glimpses of my body as profoundly alien to how I saw myself; horror and panic when hearing my voice on a recording; joy and relief seeing myself in a binder; thinking back to the male energy I had in sports and math class; happiness when my mom told stories about my gender nonconformity as a young child and when people said of my coed-but-really-boys-plus-me baseball team 'no one could ever tell who the girl is'; enormous joy joining impromptu wrestling matches with male coworkers at a summer camp; a moment at dinner with straight friends where picturing myself arriving with a boyfriend felt wrong, with a girlfriend felt better but still wrong, and arriving as a guy with a boyfriend felt 'YES, yes, yes, that's it'; quotes from Danny Lavery's memoir; wanting crushes to treat me as their bro and also want to sleep with me; a sense that I was illegible and unplugged from the social fabric and that becoming a gay guy would bring me into focus. I considered transition for about a year. During that period I did a sort of nonbinary transition: dressing androgynously, short hair (which I now think was mostly a public gender signal — I would actually prefer long hair), wearing sports bras or a binder for social occasions, and using they/them in several spheres of my life but not all of them, plus she/they at one point. It all felt kind of pointless — I didn't feel like I was accessing manhood in any meaningful way; people either treated me exactly as they always had or brought out ally scripts that felt weird and distancing. I also felt like an imposter because I thought people were probably reading me as a lesbian, and I'm not. I set myself a deadline about 18 months away, committing not to transition further until then, and then either starting T or giving up transition once and for all. I wanted a long contemplation period before starting T both because I was worried about health side effects and because I worried about getting a 'false positive' — mistaking my love of the strength, energy, and sex drive that comes with T as a sign I was really trans. A couple of weeks after setting that deadline I just woke up and knew: I'm not going to transition, it's not right for me. Making that commitment weirdly turned the dial several notches lower on a lot of my feelings — the shift from 'things I want that I will maybe pursue' to 'things I want that I am grieving and letting go' changed a lot for me. Around March 2021 I committed to accepting being a straight woman rather than trying to transition, and went back to she/her. Telling people was hard. I remember staring at my phone with a desisting text I was trying to send for a full hour, spiraling in shame and panic — thoughts like 'this is such embarrassing TMI, why did I ever insist on those fucking pronouns, why did I give that righteous speech about not seeing me as a woman that one time, they're all adults with their shit together and I'm a humiliating perpetual teenager.' It was to coworkers. People were supportive, and it's over now — it's fantastic to have that over with. The framework I've settled on is to think of myself as a woman — not in an inherent, soul-level 'gender identity' way (that's a concept I've come to not believe in, though I respect others' belief in it akin to how I respect belief in God), but in the sense that I am female and the social gender others give me is 'woman' — but a woman with transgender feelings. That lets the feelings have space to be heard without letting them dictate my whole path. I've also come to feel there probably are sex differences in averages between men and women on some traits (the overlapping double bell curve model), and that I'm on the far end of the bell curve for women for some of those, closer to the male average — that just is what it is, doesn't make me a shameful failure of a woman and doesn't make me special either. If I still believed in the innate gender identity framework I'd probably still think of myself as nonbinary, but I've unsubscribed from that framework. What has helped most: getting really into weightlifting (the #1 thing that has helped me feel better in my body, and it's improved my mood as well as making me more muscular — I've been weightlifting a lot the past year to manage body angst); achieving a 'body detente' via weightlifting and switching to more androgynous/chest-minimizing underwear; actually dating men rather than being celibate, working through difficult feelings with real partners; and learning to notice and accept specific feelings — 'oh, I feel emasculated right now,' 'oh, I'm feeling jealous of that guy's body,' 'seeing that gay couple makes me feel lonely because sometimes I wish I were a gay man' — rather than having amorphous gender angst. Living as a woman post-desistance has been a very different and better experience than living as a woman with gender angst I couldn't conceptualize. Helpful resources I found: Daisy Chadra's YouTube videos about her transition and detransition; Angus Grieve-Smith's 'Four transgender paths' blog (written by a man who considers himself trans and a transvestite but decided against transition); the podcast 'Transitional Wisdom'; a video by Daisy Chadra and her boyfriend about being in a relationship with someone detransitioning. This subreddit was a major influence on the thinking that led me to decide not to transition. On sexuality and dating: I've spent my whole life running away from heterosexuality and trying to carve out a niche in the queer community. My whole self revolts at the concept of dating men or being a man's girlfriend, but I've realized that's not sustainable. I've made some femininity concessions to expand my dating options — I didn't shave my legs or pits for pretty much my whole adult life but picked it up again recently, which feels okay now that there's visible masculinity/androgyny to my body from weightlifting. I also wonder if there's a less overtly sexual version of 'erotic target location error' at play for a lot of gender-questioning straight women — I think that was a big piece of what was going on for me, along with wanting to be attractive to myself and having no guys in my life for a very long time and turning that unfulfilled longing inward. I also used to think of my inner critic as an unkind gay man rather than an unkind straight man and took that as evidence I was meant to be a gay man. I still experience chest and voice dysphoria sometimes — the horror at hearing my voice on recording, and I hugely preferred how my chest looked when binding. I might get a breast reduction and/or do voice training to lower my voice to lessen self-disgust, but I'm making myself wait to see if I really need them. I still might never feel able to marry a man, but I feel much more comfortable with the idea of having relationships with men. I don't think I'll ever have a social media presence, though oddly I could picture having one post-transition. I don't believe people are 'actually trans' or 'actually cis' — I think people should take specific transition steps if, on balance, those actions are most likely to make their lives better. I think it's okay to pursue transition as a means of chasing joy, not just to escape unbearable dysphoria, but if you're going to you have to be as sure as you can that it really will bring you joy and that there isn't a different, safer path that would equally bring you joy. I'd advise anyone pulled in both directions to pause HRT and give living as their birth sex — including expressing femininity if they're male — a serious try first, exploring all options before going down the HRT route, because HRT is a big deal and bad health effects are definitely possible. I'm not anti-transition and don't think I know what's best for anyone other than myself.