These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned gay man who lived as a woman, had vaginoplasty, and stopped cross-sex hormones about seven years in, switching to bio-sex hormones around the eight-year mark. Fear and the pressure of performing womanhood drove my transition, and therapists and doctors actively pushed me toward believing I was trans — I now refuse to see any of them again. My chest growth worsened on testosterone, and I warn that medical detransition has real limits and side effects. I no longer feel like I'm acting when I go out as myself, and I've concluded I'm simply a feminine man. I am critical of transition as it was offered to me and of the depressogenic online forums I used to frequent.
Full story
I was born male and I've been through a full transition and back. I first started seriously questioning whether I should have transitioned somewhere around the five-year mark after starting hormones, began seriously considering detransition around that same five-year point, actually stopped hormones at about seven years in, and switched to bio-sex hormones at about the eight-year mark. I've now been off cross-sex hormones long enough to reflect on the whole arc.
Fear defined my transition. Fear of not being a woman 'right,' fear of my government and other citizens wanting to murder me, fear of traveling to certain areas of my country, fear of the wrong person being elected to office. I got tired of being afraid all the time and tired of feeling like I was required to act a certain way to be myself. That was no different from how I felt pre-transition, except at least back then I didn't feel like I was lying about what I was. All transition did was change whose expectations I was trying to cater to. One day I just decided I'm a feminine man and anybody that had a problem with it could take a long walk off a short pier.
I met trans people about 25 years ago — they were all gay males, and that was part of the draw for me because I didn't know how to meet gay men and here they were. When I went to online sites it was Susan's Place, and by then it seemed to be predominantly heterosexual males. I transitioned after moving to a different region and found that among my trans friends I was the only one that was gay. They talked about how wonderful Reddit was a lot and I'd never even heard of it. As far as female transitioners, I didn't even know they existed until the last decade or so; I always thought it was because society didn't care if women were gender nonconforming.
I had vaginoplasty. During one stretch I felt like I had no choice but to get more surgeries to pass better and just live the rest of my life as a woman, because how do you live as a man after that? Now I can't picture myself living as a woman at all — it doesn't feel like me anymore. I don't feel like I'm acting when I leave the house as me, whereas I always felt required to act when I went out as that 'woman.'
On the medical side, a lot of people can't medically detransition, which is why you end up with this mix of detrans people still on the medicalization path. Reversal surgeries sometimes exist but their results aren't going to reset the clock and could even make things worse. There are side effects from any exogenous hormone therapy, even if it's based on your biological sex — my chest growth actually gotten worse on testosterone than it was on estrogen. If you've had your gonads removed, you need to weigh which is the lesser of two evil.
Therapy hurt me badly. The only way my therapists could have failed me more would have been if they performed the procedures themselves. I never would have believed I was trans if I hadn't gone to them. The doctors weren't any better. I went back to one therapist when I decided to detransition — he transitioned to male while seeing me — and he wanted to help me with my internalized transphobia. None of them will ever touch or see me again.
I used to frequent forums where everybody seemed depressed and it was making me depressed too. I would leave the forums over it, but then get drawn back in again. I journal sometimes — I used to do it daily, but found it was making me more depressed, so now I just do it occasionally. It really helped with getting my memories straight, you know, the ones warped by obsessively thinking about gender for years; it helped me find conflicting memories and figure out which ones were in the wrong context.
I still struggle with categorizing things as male/female that shouldn't be. I also know that when I diet I go overboard and eliminate all unhealthy things, which leads to a cheat day that turns into a cheat month — I think some people do the same thing with gender, eliminating the feminine because they've categorized it as something only women can do, until the craving to express it gets so bad they binge on it, and because they've categorized it as woman they end up transitioning, only to do the same thing with the masculine and detransition later.
I used to post on Reddit because I was in pain and just needed someone to talk to, but then I'd think I was oversharing and get worried about that, so I'd delete it.