All stories

The button she won't press, and the body she still wants

Female · Desisted112
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a gender-critical, gender non-conforming woman who has never transitioned and does not identify as trans. I experience dysphoria about my female sex characteristics (hips, menstruation, breasts, height) and would want a male body if a button could give it to me, but I know medical transition won't deliver what I want, so I've chosen not to pursue it. I'm critical of self-diagnosed autism, of 'cis' as a concept, and of transition being offered to people whose distress stems from something other than true sex dysphoria. I've been direct with others about taking hormones responsibly, insisting 'hormones aren't tic-tacs.' I remain in a difficult place — neither transitioning nor fully at ease staying as I am.

Full story

I am female, and I have never identified as anything other than a woman — I am gender non-conforming, but I have never wanted to transition. I've said plainly that I'm 'GC' (gender-critical) and that I don't think transition is the right choice for me. I've described being in a difficult place with my own body: I don't *want* to transition because I know it won't give me what I actually want — 'slimmer hips, bigger shoulders, no female reproduction system' — but staying as I am also feels bad. If there were a button to instantly give me the male body I'd want, I'd press it, but no such button exists, only 'a bunch of medical shit that will or will not work out, and still won't deal with it fully for anyone who is dysphoric about their sex.' My dysphoria, as I've described it, is specifically about sex characteristics rather than stereotypes: wide hips instead of slim ones, a menstrual cycle, breasts that ache when running, being shorter than male counterparts, less strength. I've said transition could work for someone who only wants, say, a beard and deeper voice but is fine with a female reproductive system and wide hips — that isn't me. I've also noted that transition can make things worse because it makes you 'hyperaware of everything you detest about yourself,' and that unavoidable reminders like getting your period or feeling your breasts are part of why staying put is hard. I've been critical of self-diagnosed autism on Tumblr, saying 'a lot of those people aren't remotely autistic though; they're just self-diagnosers,' while also arguing that autism can make people 'confused about illogical concepts like gender' and that autistic women often show masculine behavior because femininity is performative — noting sensory issues as one reason women might reject makeup. I've pushed back against the idea that all dysphoria comes from trauma, and I've argued that 'actual GD' means sex dysphoria, not other conditions or internalized misogyny in disguise. I've also said being dysphoric is itself a mental illness, while someone who detransitioned because they turned out to be cis or just GNC is not. I've been blunt with others: I questioned why someone with no dysphoria who wanted none of the physical changes would take testosterone, telling them 'hormones aren't tic-tacs' and to get hormone levels and bloodwork checked. I've defended a person who talked about having actual dysphoria and told a disruptive commenter to 'go back to GC if you can't behave.' I've also rejected the 'cis' label, saying 'we're just women because we're female not because we have a gender identity.' I've been critical of trans women who claim female brains while not taking on typical female social roles, and I've noted I don't do housework, cooking, or child-raising either despite being female. I've advocated screenshotting predatory messages, blurring kids' faces, and sharing them publicly or contacting the person's workplace. Overall I'm supportive of people who genuinely have sex dysphoria getting proper medical care, but skeptical of transition as a solution for people whose distress comes from other places.