All stories

Three months on estrogen, and the dysphoria was the misdiagnosis

Male · DetransitionedTransition 19 → Detransition 19-1.1K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned gay man (MtFtM) who was born male, went on estrogen for about three months in early 2023, and detransitioned the same year. I now identify as a gender-nonconforming, autistic, gay man and consider myself cisgender in my own framework, saying my so-called dysphoria only began on HRT and was really a misdiagnosis of my GNC, autistic, and gay traits. Therapy, losing weight, building confidence, and befriending trans people IRL helped me move from a period of depression and hateful commenting to becoming a vocal trans ally. I am a data science student and activist who strongly opposes conservative and right-wing groups using detrans people, and I argue transition has a very low regret rate and should remain accessible to adults. I have no suicidal ideation or self-harm reported.

Full story

I was born male and grew up in Saudi Arabia; my family still lives there apart from my brother. We moved when I was 2 and I immigrated at 12, before my parents moved back. I'm a gay, autistic, gender-nonconforming man of colour who now lives in Canada (Kelowna, BC area), and I'm in my twenties. Growing up I was GNC, overweight, and autistic, and I struggled with shame about being gay, GNC, and autistic. In a college town I thought transitioning would make life easier as a GNC guy. I went on estrogen in late February 2023 and came off it about 2-3 months later, so roughly three months of HRT total. I only ever passed as androgynous. Before starting E I didn't experience what I'd now call gender dysphoria — I say my dysphoria only began once I was on estrogen: 'HRT began inducing gender dysphoria,' and 'it became harder & harder to look at myself or enjoy my body the longer I stayed on E.' I describe my GNC behaviour and weight issues as having been 'falsely diagnosed as MtF dysphoria.' I worked with a therapist and 'finished doing what I could to fix the 3 months of HRT I had then moved on with my life.' I label myself MtFtM and say I now experience 'MtM dysphoria' — distress at not being perceived as male — and that after detransitioning I settled as a 'GNC dude.' I describe myself as cisgender and agender-adjacent in my own idiosyncratic framework, and I say 'I'm a gay man' and 'I date trans & cis guys, & masc NB people.' I have a boyfriend who went on testosterone and had wide hips before T. I wear a he/him pronoun pin, long hair, and eyeliner. I went through a period after detransition of depression in which I made hateful comments about trans people on their posts. Therapy helped me realise that attacking trans people was self-destructive. I also went to therapy about a month before April 2024 for 'hating people (specifically a few other gay men & 1 trans femme NB)' for how they dressed or acted; my counsellor had me list what annoyed me and I found 9/10 of the things were irrational. I say my main mental health improvements came after I lost weight, built confidence, and dealt with what I'd misdiagnosed as dysphoria — trauma, shame over being gay/GNC, shame over autism — rather than from detransition itself, though I note 'slight improvement after detransition (mainly because E & my brain didn't play that well together).' I also mention a 'messed up home life' alongside my detrans experience as a source of trauma. I'm a data science/CS undergraduate with a day job in data science, and I've been involved in local politics and activism — roughly a third of my activism is about trans and detrans rights together. I've been treated badly by both progressives (who assumed I was a transmedicalist or trans in denial) and conservatives (who dislike GNC people and know me from my activism). I strongly oppose detrans people allying with conservative or right-wing outlets: I call Prager U and Young America's Foundation propaganda outfits that 'weaponize my trauma,' and I repeatedly call detrans law firms 'ambulance chasers' who also take anti-vax and anti-mask cases. I urge detrans people to only use apolitical lawyers. My central position throughout is that trans people exist, that sex and gender are different (I cite Campbell's Biology p.298 obsessively), that gender dysphoria is a real biological phenomenon, and that transition has an approximately 0.5-3% regret rate with ~80% quality-of-life improvement (Murad et al. 2010, Davies et al. 2019, Danker et al. 2018, Olson et al. 2022). I argue puberty blockers are safe and reversible, citing around 20 sources. I'm critical of AGP and HSTS as Blanchardian constructs, and I defend WPATH. I believe detransition was mostly a misdiagnosis of my GNC/autistic/gay traits rather than genuine transness, and that better diagnostic criteria — not banning transition — is the answer. I'm a trans ally and say befriending trans people IRL, getting into trans allyship, and getting involved in local politics after detransition is what helped me heal. I say I'm 'secure enough in my gender to be a trans activist.'