All stories

Four years on estrogen, then facing what can't be undone

Male · Detransitioned108
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned man who lived as a trans woman for about four years on hormones before detransitioning, and I now identify as a straight man. I came to understand my transition through autogynephilia (AGP), which I initially denied but now accept, and I detransitioned because I was depressed, listless, and miserable at being a not-quite-woman. Since detransitioning I am physically healthier and happier, though I still feel shame and anxiety and have little optimism about my sex life. I have irreversible changes from estrogen (a chest, no testicles) and I strongly advise others against bottom surgery. I remain isolated, afraid to be open about my history, and I actively discuss AGP and caution others about transition in detrans spaces.

Full story

I was born male, and I identified as a trans woman for several years before detransitioning back to living as a man. I first came to understand myself through the lens of autogynephilia (AGP): I am AGP, and I transitioned and then detransitioned. At the time I transitioned I was convinced I wasn't AGP and thought it was pseudoscience, but with testosterone running through my system again I can say I was in denial, and AGP scenarios are once again erotically appealing to me. I spent four years on hormones before detransitioning. I detransitioned because I was miserable at being a not-quite-woman and had become depressed and listless after those four years on hormones. When I was trans I was, in my own words, "hollow." It wasn't until after I had been on testosterone for a long time that I realised I did have AGP and that it was real. I also came to believe that the reason I hated those other trans women was because deep down I was the same as them — familiarity breeds contempt; I was ashamed of myself and projected it onto others. I think a lot of the reason AGPs go through with transition is the shame of being a man turned on by feminisation. Adjacent concepts in erotic material are often femdom, cucking, etc., which are embarrassing and difficult to explain erotic proclivities. It's much easier to just "become the girl" and finally your sexuality makes sense with your gender. Transition also became socially acceptable, even encouraged — you'd be lauded for your bravery on Twitter, have hordes of other trans women saying how stunning you are, support networks, community, finally a place to belong — compared to living as a humiliated, ashamed AGP man whose romantic and sexual prospects seem diminished. In a way, transition and detransition is the ultimate binge and purge, like the binge/purge cycle among cross-dressers. I also came to believe I had been less critical because I wanted to believe: "It's a nice fantasy to believe that all the problems about hating yourself and your body are caused by a medically legitimate condition that is having a booming social movement right now. I wanted to believe too. It's easy to delude yourself when you desperately want a way out of self hatred." While trans, I started believing more and more "terf" rhetoric and feeling ashamed of trans women I saw as egregious examples of things I disliked. The online trans community is very strong and eager to excommunicate those who have the "wrong views," and once that sense of community goes it's alienating as you question the nature of transness. Sexuality has been complicated for me. I went from ostensibly straight men to straight trans women — I slept with men while presenting as a woman. I contend that my androphilia is not innate but a pseudobisexuality caused by AGP: I liked men because they made me feel like a woman; they were part of the fantasy, not a genuine object of attraction in themselves. Having detransitioned, this and my own "homophobia" were confirmed: once I became a man again, I didn't want to hook up with men. It's only appealing to me in a masculine/feminine pattern, not masc/masc. I can get off to gay porn but in a fetishistic, masochistic way, and I have to fight an initial feeling of repulsion when I see two men having sex. I also slept with men and note that bisexuals and asexuals are categorised as AGP in the typology. After detransitioning I describe myself as a "straight" guy now, so I don't fit into LGBT groups, which I imagine would be hostile to detrans anyway. I get along fine with other cis men but can't talk openly with them because I don't want to reveal myself and I feel ashamed and like I'm a freak. I was lonely and looking for detrans community in my city, but I was scared to join Facebook groups in case trans or especially woke friends saw it, and I didn't want to out myself to people who didn't know I transitioned. I sometimes miss the unconditional validity of belonging to the transgender populace. Medically, I have ongoing physical consequences: I describe myself as "a guy with no balls and some small tits and a weird history now," and I mention having "e chest" (an estrogen-induced chest) that makes me worry about clothing and my body a bit. I strongly urge others not to have SRS or any kind of surgery, warning that if they decide they have to detransition it would be tragic, and that many surgical results I've seen have been less than desirable; I repeat that advice more than once. As for how I'm doing now: I can say I have been happier and physically healthier having detransitioned. There is some hope and ambition in my life where previously it was a dead-end. Now, as a man, I may be ashamed and anxious, but I am a whole, real person once more. I have no desire to transition again but I also have little optimism for my sex life. Some level of acceptance seems to be the best thing — incorporating little things into an otherwise vanilla sex life — though I see that as a slippery slope. I don't know if I'd advise someone in my situation that it's a step toward transition or a compromise; it depends on awareness. I have no desire to transition again.