All stories

From transmasc to butch — back to the community she'd left

Female · Detransitioned242
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who now identifies comfortably as a butch lesbian. I transitioned through nonbinary and transmasc identities to the point of passing as male, but felt increasingly isolated from the lesbian community I belonged to. Discovering detransitioners online led me to research for months before detransitioning, which I'm deeply glad I did. I've reconciled with my female sex and no longer feel pressure to perform femininity, and my mood and happiness have greatly improved. I believe detransition should be more normalised so people don't feel trapped in transition.

Full story

I had been gender non-conforming as a young girl, and being called a lesbian felt like the worst insult anyone could call me at the time — I used to feel such shame and aversion around those words. Over the years I identified as a lot of different things and made many changes to my clothes, appearance, and pronouns, leaning at various points into being nonbinary and transmasc, and eventually presenting and passing as male. At one point I was passing as a straight man even though I knew I was a lesbian, and that period was very lonely. I didn't feel safe with men or straight women, so queer women were all I really had, and once I started passing as male I felt a huge divide open up between me and the women I had always felt closest to. Even when I was accepted in groups of men I felt out of place, because it was obvious to me that we did not have the same life experiences, and I couldn't relate to them on a level even close to the deep connections I'd had with other lesbians. I also came to understand that I don't love women the way straight men do — I love them in a way that only another woman can. The turning point was coming across a detrans woman online. I spent months researching and obsessively going back and forth about what to do; the thought of detransitioning terrified me, but I did it and I'm so glad. For years it hadn't even occurred to me that detransition was something people did — once I learned it was, it didn't take long until I was convinced it was what I needed. I detransitioned, and I think I would have done it much sooner if detransition had been more normalised; I also think I might have come out earlier if being trans hadn't felt like a mandatory lifelong commitment. Coming out as a woman felt harder than coming out as trans because of the baggage and stigma around detransition. Since then I've reconciled being female and come to understand that my sex is what makes me a woman — not my personality, interests, or appearance. I stopped putting pressure on myself to look more feminine, to walk or speak a certain way, or to worry about passing as female, because I realised there was nothing I needed to do: being a woman isn't something you do, it's just something you are, and that was very freeing. I unpacked the thinking that because I wanted to keep my hair short and didn't like wearing dresses, I must not be a woman anymore — which seems silly to me now. Once I understood a woman can look or act like anything, I stopped caring what people think. I still don't feel a connection to the word "woman" as an identity, but I feel strongly connected to butch, dyke, and lesbian, and I can now say "I am butch, I am a dyke, I am a lesbian" and feel happy about it. My mood improved enormously once I let go of the burden of trying to control how people see me; I love seeing how I look genuinely happy in photos and I'm finally starting to look like my old self again. I feel joy and gratitude for the body and life I've been given. I hope anyone questioning takes the time and space to figure out what they need, and remembers not to stay somewhere that's making them unhappy just because they don't know what will happen when they leave.