All stories

A supportive big brother who chose to stay himself

Male · Desisted139
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned person who came to see transition as running away from your real self rather than solving problems, and who now advocates for working through dysphoria to love yourself as you are. I have a younger sister who worked through her dysphoria in time, and I frame myself as a supportive big brother to girls struggling with body image and gender expectations. I believe deeply in rejecting communities that demand you adopt their stances, and I value therapy as the real path forward. I hold a critical but nuanced view of gender roles, sexualization of women, and the escape that identifying as male can represent from female sexualization. I have not described any surgeries, hormones, medical interventions, or my own transition/detransition timeline in this material.

Full story

I came to the realization that transitioning doesn't solve your problems — it only sweeps them under the rug, and what you really do is run away from your real self. I remember telling someone that the way they said people would be confused or even mad was a giveaway that they didn't want it, and that you're never obligated to go through with it; I compared it to buying a magazine you only picked up because you thought it was free, or getting a tattoo on a whim — you don't do it unless you're 100% sure, or you'll regret it forever, and unlike a tattoo, this can't just be removed with money. I insisted they needed psychotherapy with a therapist who would actually try to solve their problems, asap, even though it might be a long and hard ride. I've thought a lot about how misogyny toward men works — I called out the male equivalent of 'men are sooo stupid lol' and objectifying discussions about treating men like toys. I discussed a friend struggling with dysphoria who didn't want boobs because she didn't want to be noticed, and I framed being a guy as sexually more 'low-profile' — no prominent sexual characteristics like boobs or hips, no worrying about clothing drawing attention, upskirts, wardrobe malfunctions — just throw on whatever and go, comparatively not objects of attraction 24/7, so being a guy can be perceived as more chill or an escape from sexuality. I clarified that when I talked about sexuality I meant sexuality as a whole, not sexual orientation specifically, and that girls and women often want to escape not just objectification but sexualization or sexual context in general. I've made jokes about sex not being a spectrum but an orb, and quipped 'Went from Leafy to Linda.' I've commented on voices — noting that in Germany ladies often have deep voices which I think sounds nice, and finding it weird how people elsewhere are self-conscious about not sounding like a dog toy. I described the culture I'm around as genuinely equal — people are shocked when everyone pays their own share at a restaurant, we don't treat women differently than men, we socialize and drink together without awkwardness, and we don't sexualize each other, partly because of an open approach to sexuality (nude beaches, topless sunbathing in gardens, no one cares). I said deep voices on women are 'hella nice' and that a lot of people find them warm, welcoming, or hot, and I joked about high-pitched voices being 'tinnitus on legs.' I've commented that moobs come and go with weight. I posted a big supportive message shouting out broad-shouldered girls, tall girls, flat girls, girls who work out, do martial arts, skate, weight lift, who prefer hanging with guys or shopping in the men's section — telling them they're all valid, that there are no criteria to being valid as a girl, and framing it as coming from 'a big brother who is very happy that his little sis could work through her dysphoria in time and love herself the way she is.' I've joked about whether they give you something 'for the case you change your mind,' praised 'Female Roxas FTW,' complimented an outfit, and criticized something as 'old fashioned sexism and gender roles but promoted more cleverly.' I came to believe that rejecting communities can be one of the healthiest things for your mental well-being — that by joining a community you adopt its responsibilities, opinions, stances and image, and 'when you join a community, you are the community. You sail under their flag. You don't represent them, they represent you.' I ended with 'Reject community, return to monke.'