All stories

Passing as a boy showed her what being a woman costs

Female · Desisted138
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who came to see that my transition was rooted in identifying with sex stereotypes rather than any innate maleness. Passing as a teenage boy without hormones or surgery showed me how much better I was treated as male, which ultimately helped me understand and reject the misogyny I had internalised. I now frame being female as simply a body type, unrelated to femininity, personality, career or dating choices. I advise other butch or passing women to build community with women like them and to keep passing as long as they want to. I remain critical of how Reddit and society silence women's experiences.

Full story

I came to understand that my transition had been about sex stereotypes — that there is no way to feel male apart from being born male, and that everything I thought of as "feeling like a male" was really just identifying with stereotypes. I now see being female as simply describing the type of body you have, with no relationship to being feminine or girly; gender is an oppressive construct forced on girls from birth, and there is no innate femininity in us just because we are born female. When I passed as male — as a teenage boy or youth, without hormones or surgery — I was treated like a human being. I was listened to when I spoke, and it was eye-opening: I learned that how badly I had been treated as a woman wasn't personal to me, it was bias against women in general. I learnt how much the world hates women, and paradoxically that helped me come to terms with being a woman, because I discovered the hate I had internalised didn't belong on me. I still think about the everyday casual basic respect I got passing as male and marvel how rarely it happens now; when it does I treasure it and use it to reassure myself that not everyone hates women. I also got paid more in my job while passing as male, and the difference in how I was treated in that job versus a previous job as a female was astounding. I don't think I could have passed once I got older and less skinny, but it wasn't hard back then. I also loved not being sexually harassed, objectified and belittled when I passed as male. I did something similar when I was younger to survive in a world that targets girls for harassment and has very restrictive ideas about how women and girls are allowed to be. I was brainwashed with very restrictive ideas about how I was allowed to be and hardly knew it. I can confirm that people automatically trust you less around kids when you pass as male. I also noted that more curves tend to gradually kick in during our 20s and can make passing harder. On Reddit, I believe women censor themselves to the extreme and that women's actual experiences of life are not welcome here; men control the narrative here and everywhere else. I think women who desist or detransition naturally become more questioning about social norms regarding girls and women as part of that process. My advice to others in similar positions is to make finding and befriending other butch women the number one priority — you need other women around who help you feel normal, who also get mistaken for male and deal with the same crap from family. I also encourage people to pass for as long as they want to and can, and that being female is "truly female" regardless of what you feel, wear, like or dislike.