These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned woman who was born female, presented masculine my whole life, and was led to believe that masculinity meant I was trans. I was on testosterone inconsistently for nearly 5 years and have been off it for about a year and a half, left with a lowered voice, facial features, and facial hair I shave daily. I never had chest dysphoria and only bound to try to pass; I stopped binding over a year ago. Now I get he/him'd about weekly at work, and being perceived as male because of HRT changes causes me real dysphoria and hurts more than it did when I was trans. I have mixed feelings — some regret, some gratitude — but I keep my masculine presentation and don't intend to change it for others' comfort.
Full story
I was born female and presented masculine even before I ever transitioned — that masculine expression has always been how I am, not something that started with transition. I was gendered correctly as a woman back then, so my presentation alone was never the problem. I came to be led to believe that my masculinity inherently meant I could be trans, and I was sadly mistaken about that. I started testosterone and was on and off it inconsistently for nearly 5 years. I never actually had dysphoria about my chest; I only bound because I thought I had to in order to pass, and binding hurt. I stopped binding a little over a year ago, and if I had known that even my chest wouldn't affect how people perceive me, I would have stopped binding a long time ago.
I've been off testosterone for about a year and a half now. The changes from HRT are what skew how people read me: my voice is lower than average, and I have facial features and some facial hair growth from testosterone. I shave my face every day — without it there's no noticeable stubble to anyone else, but enough for me to notice. I don't shave my legs. I present masculine, and I've had to come to terms with my masculine expression and the fact that I'm still a woman and was wrong about being a man, just because I'm masculine. I get gendered correctly on the phone, so I know most of the misconception about me comes from my appearance rather than my voice.
Since detransitioning, I get he/him'd at least once a week at work by associates who have otherwise heard me referred to with she/her. That misgendering now hurts more than it did when I was actually trans, because now it's a reminder that my body has been changed in ways I can't fully undo. The dysphoria I experience when I'm perceived as male because of characteristics changed from HRT is detrimental to my mental health. Parts of me regret transitioning, and parts of me are grateful I had the freedom to transition — it helped me find peace in my identity, even though it came at a cost.
I'm not going to sacrifice my masculine expression to appease people's ignorance about what a woman can look like. Cis women have been butch forever, and my problem is not with my butch presentation, because I've presented this way forever, even pre-transition. My view now is that transition isn't the answer just because someone is gender nonconforming, and I wish I'd been told that masculinity alone doesn't make someone a man.