All stories

Planned to transition at 22 — then chose the healthy body

Female · Desisted1.2K
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who never medically transitioned but identified as a boy in childhood and planned to transition, deciding around age 22 that I would rather live in my healthy female body than be permanently dependent on medication as a 'trans man.' I am bisexual, in a long-term relationship with a man, and describe my story as boring and trauma-free. A key driver of my detransition was recognizing the current trans craze as exactly parallel to the anorexia craze of my youth. I do not believe in gender identity ideology, though I support adults' bodily autonomy to transition if they choose. I still sometimes instinctively count myself among men and find men's self-help resources more useful to me.

Full story

I was born female and grew up in a country where, at the time, you had to be 25 to be considered for sex reassignment surgery. From my earliest childhood I was, in my own words, 'just a boy.' I was an early and avid reader and always identified with the boys in the books I read, chose books with boy characters, and did the same with movies and cartoons. My friends were always boys, I played 'boys' games' and with 'boys' toys,' and I watched the same TV shows as the other little boys. I thought my penis would grow out someday. I never saw myself as 'not like the other girls' - I was never negative towards girls and wanted to be friends with them, I just always found myself with the boys. Puberty came late; I didn't need a bra until about 16, and my first period was mostly annoying because it meant I couldn't go swimming those days. I had P.E. with the boys but changed with the girls. In middle school the girls wouldn't shower with me because 'you're a boy!' In high school it stopped being an issue. I remember one girl asking if I was using men's deodorant, which I hadn't thought about - I'd just picked out the deodorant I liked. I started community theatre at 16 and almost always got cast in male roles; people who didn't know me thought I was male. I played the lead in a theatre production (a female role) as recently as a year before April 2024. Liking girls came naturally - my friends were talking about girls they liked and I did too. Liking boys was more challenging because it made me far more 'gay' in the eyes of me and my friends, whereas liking girls was expected. I am bisexual. I have been in a relationship with a man for four years as of January 2024, with no wish to change it, and people are - 'every. single. time' - surprised to learn my partner is a man; everyone assumes I'm a lesbian. I originally decided to transition because, as I put it, I was a boy: my friends were boys, and whenever I heard 'man this, woman that' stereotypes, I felt more like whatever the 'man' thing was. I never had a trans community. Somewhere around 22 I realized that nothing kept me from just living my life with the body I have, and that it would be far easier for me not to transition. I detransitioned because I would never be a man and never have the experience of growing up as a boy - I would only ever be a trans man, and that was not enough. I chose not to transition medically. My reasoning for detransition was that no matter what, I would never get a healthy male body; I would never get to be born and live my childhood as a healthy male. The very best I could hope for was something resembling a male body through surgery and medical treatment, and I would never not need the medical treatment. In short, I would never be male. I also became convinced through learning about how brains work that there is no way my mind is male, because there is no way for a mind/brain to be male - everyone's mind is different and it all comes down to what we're exposed to and interested in. I'd rather have a healthy body than what I described as a 'mutilated one which will always need hormones/medication.' A part of me still believes that if it truly is possible to be 'born in the wrong body,' then I am - but there's nothing wrong with my body; it's healthy and I'm happy with the life I've made for myself. I believe my life would be little different if I'd been born a boy. TL;DR, as I wrote it: 'I am a woman, because that is what my body is.' I still sometimes forget that I'm a woman. When I don't think about it, I count myself as a man; when talking about my childhood/teen years I say 'me and the other boys did this, and the girls did that.' When seeking psychological help it helps me more to read advice for men. To this day I find it more helpful to look at men's resources in psychology and self-help than the women's section. I've never instinctively felt like I'm one of them when I see other women; when people split into men and women, it takes conscious effort for me to group myself with the women. I don't 'feel like' my sex because my sex is not a feeling but a biological reality - sometimes that biological reality hurts, and that's life. I described my story as 'a very boring and trauma-free story.' I don't report mental health diagnoses. I do suffer from Horton's Headache (cluster headaches), which certain sounds can trigger. I was bullied at school for being masculine. I was embarrassed not to be able to eat an entire pizza when my two best friends (both men) could. A major factor in my detransition was recognizing social contagion: as a young teen in the 90s/early 00s we were warned extensively about anorexia - TV episodes, books, and warnings about online communities that encouraged each other. 'And then came the trans craze, and this was actually a very big part of what made me detransition - it wasn't just eerily similar; it was EXACTLY similar to the anorexia craze of my youth.' I don't use the label 'cis,' I don't use 'preferred pronouns,' don't participate in pronoun rounds, and don't believe in gender identity ideology. I believe there are two biological sexes and that anything else is either biological anomalies or sexist stereotyping. I believe some people's lives improve with transition or cosmetic surgery and I firmly believe in bodily autonomy for adults, but I think transition should be an adult choice because you need to be able to explore other causes for discomfort and comprehend the consequences. I don't feel hated and don't feel I need a trans community. I have criticized the show featuring Jazz Jennings, noting she had bottom surgery at 17 (not 10) after long-term puberty blockers and hormones that made surgery difficult, and that her mother told her not to discuss surgical complications. I have also criticized what I see as sexist grooming of children through gendered toys and clothes from before birth. I have not described any advocacy or activism beyond posting these views online. English is not my first language.