These stories have been summarised using AI.
On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.
Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.
Summary
I am a detransitioned male (MtFtM) who stopped HRT abruptly around autumn 2022 and was in the early, awkward stages of detransitioning, still presenting somewhat femininely and worried about being read as a baby trans girl or crossdresser. I detransitioned because the cons outweighed the pros: I'm mostly attracted to men and lost faith that any man could truly be with a trans woman, and I've grown more comfortable being GNC. I now view my transition as an attempt to fit a role and maximize my physical potential rather than something rooted in gender ideology, and I hold critical, structural views about why people transition. I'm cautiously exploring dating as a gay man and remain concerned about passing, safety, and breast tissue from HRT.
Full story
I detransitioned (MtFtM) and by autumn 2022 I was in the messy middle of it. My first post, in October 2022, was about not passing anymore: I wrote that the most annoying part of detransitioning for me would be the initial stage where people assume I'm a baby trans girl, or 'a really clocky trans girl who isn't even trying.' I'd always been told that I pass, so passing was something I wanted to hold onto — 'it's one of the things i did right' — and now I had to let it go if I wanted to move on. I joked that I needed a way to automatically let people know I am not new to this.
I hadn't started using men's bathrooms yet, but I said that was 'definitely something im not looking forward to.' I also worried about being misidentified as a baby trans person, an egg, or 'worse a crossdresser.' I compared the experience to being at a senior level in a career but being treated as an incompetent associate, and noted it can make other trans women less trusting of me and can be dangerous safety-wise, though I concluded that for the sake of my mental health it's best not to think too much about people's perception of me.
On why I detransitioned, I said it wasn't personal and that it was too complex to name any one reason, but 'the cons just started outweighing the pros.' I explained that I'm mostly attracted to men and I stopped having faith that any man could ever truly be with a trans woman. I'm around gay men a lot and they seem much happier — it feels more communal — whereas dating trans-attracting men felt like asking for trouble or stepping outside of my social network. I also said that as I get older I'm more comfortable with the idea of being GNC, which I acknowledged contradicted my original post.
I stopped HRT abruptly rather than tapering: 'i didn't taper off HRT - i just stopped it one day.' I was still holding onto presenting feminine and hadn't cut my hair yet. I was curious about options for breast tissue from HRT before considering surgery, asking another person whether they'd try tamoxifene or raloxifene, noting they say it doesn't work on HRT-induced breast tissue but that I wanted to exhaust my options first. I've been off HRT for a while but said I still pass to others.
I reflected that I always secretly knew I was transitioning to fit a role better, to maximize what I thought was my physical potential — 'i mean thats what transitioning is lol' — and that I never truly bought into gender ideology; I just did and continue to do what I think is best for me. I told a younger person to take time to sit with themselves, journal a lot (especially after socializing), and think about what kind of life would make them happy, considering where and with whom they're most comfortable, what they like to do, how they'll sustain themselves, and whether they can withstand a transition long-term; I said to listen to myself and consider the opinions of those who truly care about me, and that it could be a phase or the next step in a lifelong transition.
On dating after detransition, I said one of my fears is dating as a gay man — I know it won't be any easier, but I hoped it would be at least better than my experiences with cishet men, and that maybe somewhere in between is best for me. I also noted that when I was/am GNC before and after transition, I get much more animosity from men than I did when I just looked like a 'normal' girl.
I engaged critically with detransition discourse. I questioned a post about leaders of the trans movement targeting women, asking what the incentive to 'create' more FTMs would be, and argued that a society that devalues women would produce lots of FTMs — 'who would want to be a woman, esp an ugly woman, in a patriarchal society?' — with the trans movement providing an 'easy' way out, though I doubted most trans men actually gain respect. I agreed that transsexualism as it exists today is a result of 'white supremacist capitalist patriarchy,' and argued that how different races are racialized (e.g., Black people viewed as hypermasculine) can affect gender identity the way misogyny or materialism can. I also cautioned that detransitioners' emotional reactions to the trans movement may be clouded by unhappiness with our own decisions, and that what works for others may not work for us; I distinguished between cases where someone could hold a doctor or professional responsible versus cases where someone made a personal mistake about themselves. I was skeptical of a post I thought might be fabricated to push an agenda, and questioned a lawsuit post with 'how is that MTFTM lol.'
I have not described any surgeries, diagnoses, therapy, trauma, family dynamics, or mental health conditions in this transcript. I did not describe suicidal ideation, self-harm, or attempts. I haven't described advocacy beyond participating in online discussion.