All stories

Nullified between 2023 and 2024 — and still seen as a man

Male · Detransitioned179
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I was born male, grew up gay in a conservative Arab society, hated my male body since childhood, and after two years of research had gender nullification surgery (removing all visible genitalia) between 2023 and 2024 while continuing to present as a man. I am happy with the physical distinction from other males, but the surgery did not resolve my dysphoria because society still sees me as a man and I date gay men. I do not want to transition to live as a woman and identify as roughly 55% female, 45% male. I treat regret as a state of mind rather than a prediction, and I remain uncertain about how I'll feel in coming decades. I actively participate in detrans communities, debating gender, masculinity, and transition.

Full story

I was born male and grew up in a very conservative Arab society. Looking back, I can say I hated being a male during my childhood and teenage years, and I never could see myself as a man in that environment. Around my first teenage years I noticed my attraction to males, and I grew up to identify as a gay man. As an adult I did the opposite of what many people expect: I owned my masculine appearance. I went to the gym, dressed accordingly, and enjoyed the privileges that gave me in gay sex life. Over time I resolved many of the distressing issues I had felt toward other gay men and toward myself, but I still hated being seen and treated as a masculine man. I described creating "a character that I never seen as myself, but like a depiction of someone else, or a concept." Physically I describe myself as a 6-foot-tall muscular man with a wide chest, and elsewhere as a 5'11" tall person with broad shoulders and a slim build. I never liked my male parts, physically and in terms of identity. I hated having erections, hated when my penis touched surfaces or a partner's body, and found that it distracted from the psychological, emotional level on which I enjoy sex or brought orgasm too soon. I also said I feel disgusted when people look at or relate to my penis seductively, and that I see testicles as some of the ugliest body parts, though I don't mind ugliness on other men. For about two years before March 2023 I became highly interested in bottom gender nullification surgery — removal of all visible genitalia while continuing to present as a man. The moment I discovered a flat crotch was an option, it became an obsession, because I felt it would make me complete in my body and more comfortable in sex. I insisted it was not a fetish, since I am not sexually turned on by the idea or the process. I read a lot, consulted therapists, transgender people and nullos, joined detrans communities, and spoke with an endocrinologist. I also tried tucking and chastity cages, but the pressure made me more aware of my genitals and the dysmorphia felt worse. I told people I had no plan B if I gave up the surgery and that I would find other ways to "damage the things down there." When someone pushed back hard, I replied, "Thank you for this slap." I acknowledged I could not fully predict how I would feel at 40, 50 or 60, and that "there's no 100% sure." By April 2024 I stated plainly: "Today I'm a nullo, I'm happy about the distinction I made between me and other males." So the nullification surgery did happen between March 2023 and April 2024. However, it did not resolve my dysphoria: I wrote that "My nullification didn't really 'solve' it, because I'm still seen as a man and need to date gay men." I still present as male to society and am uncertain what to do next without compromising my attractiveness. I explicitly do not consider transitioning to live as a woman, saying I would rather aspire to be "a sexy guy/boy/twink" than "an ugly trans woman," and that turning into a woman would mean becoming "a 5'11 tall woman with broad shoulders and a slim build" who would be seen as "an anomaly stuck in between." I have thought a lot about regret, describing it as "a state of mind" and "barely connected to how satisfied one is with the results." I said I know the warnings, that it scares me, and that I may still see it as worth the risk. I have learned to love the scar and imperfections of a nullo crotch and said that even if the result is less aesthetic than I expect, I'd still want it. I also said I don't see the lack of a penis as self-harm, because I don't regard it as harmful or negative — instead I see males with genitals as fragile and imperfect. On sexuality and identity, I theorized that everyone has some level of dysphoria, especially same-sex attracted people whose own body parts feel "a bit alien" yet attractive on others — "a dance between dysphoria and autophilia." I said I feel disgusted by autophilia. I also reject separating the self from societal images and porn, arguing they shape and help define sexuality, and I'd rather embrace that exploration. When asked to quantify myself I said "I'd say 55% female, 45% male." I hold developed views on gender: I argue woman/man are social concepts grounded in male/female biology, that "to be a woman is a social experience," and that a trans woman who fills that social role is "a type of woman" but not a "real" woman — not as an insult, but acknowledging a genuinely different experience. I also argued the opposite of feminist framing: "Who wants to be a man in this world?" — saying men must earn love and respect, masculinity is treated as toxic, and that feminism has "demonized masculinity to an unprecedented point in history." I believe the detrans community is wrong to insist it's better to be a man, and I advocate restoring "gender balance" where the two sexes cooperate rather than fight. I was raised in a conservative Arab society and identify as androphile (attracted to males), and I speculate that while social explanations (being skinny, foreign, bullied, not fitting in with other boys) could explain my sexuality, the initial cause may simply have been genetic. I am active in detrans forums partly because "I see myself in you, because I did the same thing before I went for my nullification surgery." I defend dialogue across echo chambers, saying detrans forums are "a lot more intelligent than the trans subreddits." I have not described any specific therapy, diagnoses, medications, or mental health conditions beyond the dysphoria and dysmorphia discussed above. I have not described family reactions, career impact, or regret that is worsening — my stated position is that I'm happy with the distinction nullification gave me, even though it didn't solve the underlying dysphoria.