All stories

Eighteen months on estrogen, then wanting the beard back

Male · Detransitioned179
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioning person born male who lived as a woman on estrogen for about 1.5 years before deciding to stop. I quit because I never passed well enough to be a woman, I wanted a beard and body hair, I hoped to regain fertility, and I concluded dysphoria doesn't go away no matter how far you transition. I feared losing my current happiness to a second male puberty and worried about looking ugly again without estrogen's effects on my skin. I never described completing the detransition or any surgeries, and my current identity is living as a male while accepting myself. I have become critical of transition, arguing that sex-specific categories should exist for people who clearly look one sex but claim the other.

Full story

I started identifying as trans and went on estrogen, but the transition never gave me what I hoped for. Around four and a half months in, in mid-2021, I wrote that being on estrogen had not solved my problems — I said "transisation is not solution" and that starting it "caused me deep depression," though I also said being trans made me happy even though I "still doesnt look that much feminen." I was clear-eyed even then that "your gender is ABSOLUTELY not the reason of all of your problems" and that changing your gender "may make your life better but it doesnt solve all other problems." By November 2021, after about 11 months on estrogen, I posted that I thought I would quit. I explained that I knew I would never be a cis woman, but "at least i can be cis man," so I decided to stop and try to live as male again, with the option of restarting hormones if I couldn't. I noted that while on HRT I had been publicly male the whole time and that I looked "totally male," so continuing felt like lying to myself. I am sexually and romantically attracted to all genders — I described myself as pan — but said I "seldom deal with genders rather than women." By February 2022, about 1.5 years into estrogen, I was actively trying to detransition but stuck on two fears. First, appearance: I hated how I looked before hormones and worried I would be "ugly like that" again, and I credited estrogen with benefits to my skin. I asked whether I could microdose estrogen to keep some feminine features like skin while becoming more masculine, and worried testosterone would make me ugly and give me acne — "I will be like male puberty again." Second, I feared losing my current mental state: "I am happy now, I am not depressed, I am afraid of losing it, Testosterone can make me a different person." My stated reasons for wanting to quit estrogen were: not wanting feminine facial fat distribution, hoping to regain fertility, wanting a beard and body hair, and planning to start finasteride later to prevent hair loss. I worried about the transition period off hormones, when both estrogen and testosterone could be very low. I pushed back hard against commenters arguing environmental or supply-chain harms of estrogen production, saying where I live you don't even need a prescription and that "No one can convince me with such things" — I wanted a straight list of harms and benefits, not moral pressure. In a February 2022 comment that got strong support, I laid out three conclusions: HRT didn't make my face feminine enough to pass, so with testosterone I could at least reach a good male look and "there is no point to be woman if i only can with lot of surgeries"; dysphoria doesn't go away — even beautiful trans-feminine friends of mine had "depressions, traumas and dysphorias" — so becoming a beautiful woman would take "looot of pain"; and "the easiest way to love myself is accept what i am, accept how i look, accept my gender." I never described completing the detransition in these posts, and I never described surgeries, puberty blockers, or formal diagnoses. I did not mention therapy, family, partners, trauma, or mental-health diagnoses as drivers. The transition itself seems to have been driven mainly by wanting to look a certain way and by unhappiness I later concluded was not actually about gender. My most recent statement, from February 2023, was a critical one: I supported the existence of some kind of sex-specific category "because of people who look completely male or completely female but claim to be of the opposite sex."