All stories

The surgeon refused — and she survived

Female · DetransitionedFirst dysphoria 12 → Transition 18460
These stories have been summarised using AI.

On Reddit, people often share their experiences across multiple comments or posts. To make this information more accessible, detrans.ai gathers all of those scattered pieces into a single, easy-to-read summary and timeline. All system prompts are noted on the prompts page.

Sometimes AI can hallucinate or state things that are not true. But generally, the summarised stories are accurate reflections of the original comments by users.

Summary

I am a detransitioned woman who lived as a trans man, was on high-dose testosterone for about 4-5 years, and stopped on my own around 2023 after developing serious cardiac issues. I narrowly avoided top surgery when the surgeon refused, and I now say I wouldn't have survived had I gone through with the surgeries I wanted. I kept my chosen name Isaiah, still have a male sex marker on my ID, and live as a woman while dealing with permanent changes from T (prominent Adam's apple, facial hair, altered chest, enlarged clitoris, fertility loss — I never had children). I attribute my transition to childhood abuse, trauma from being SA-ed, Tumblr gender discourse at age 12, and inability to accept the difficulties of being female, and I am now strongly critical of transition and gender ideology for others. My mental health and physical health have improved substantially since detransitioning, and I've reconciled with my parents and friends.

Full story

I was born female, and I grew up in church and Christian private schools, which I described as horrible in itself. I was abused at home and then abused at school for lashing out. When I was 12 I was online too often and got sucked into reading Tumblr discourse and gender politics, which seemed to offer a way out of hating myself so much — a cure for me. I was a tomboy, traumatized by puberty, and then told there was a cure for all my problems. I came out as trans much younger, and at 18 I was kicked out to a homeless shelter for making the appointment to start testosterone. I identified as ftm and socially and medically transitioned. I was on a high dose of testosterone via once-a-week IM shots for about 4 to 5 years (I gave both figures at different times). Transition felt great to me at first — I didn't pass very well, but just trying felt right at the time. I was in a seriously dark place mentally even if it didn't seem like it; I was confused and hated myself SO MUCH I didn't want to exist in my own body. I seriously thought I could understand what it is to "be a man," only because I couldn't accept the difficulties that come with being woman. I went as far as a consultation for top surgery. The surgeon actually saw my fear and stepped in and said "No, this is a terrible idea for you." I said if she hadn't done that I probably wouldn't have survived to detransition. I first saw a Kiwi Farms thread just after I had my consultation for top surgery while researching. I said I wouldn't be alive today if I had gone through with everything I wanted back then, and that I have horrible hospital PTSD as it is. I also came close to pursuing phalloplasty. My mom was all for the surgery until she started reading about it in depth. Around 4 years on T I needed therapeutic blood draws to keep my red blood cells in a healthy range, and it was causing a lot of problems with my heart, but my doctors were dead set on keeping me on it. I stopped on my own. I tapered a little by spacing out my shots further and further, and after a month or so stopped entirely. I had serious cardiac issues from being on T too long and didn't know it was even possible until it was too late. Detransition started gradually: it began with not feeling like correcting or explaining pronouns, then curiosity about growing my hair longer. I never straight up told anyone I was detransitioning because I didn't feel like I had to come out as anything this time. I blocked the majority of trans pages when I started thinking about detransitioning, even before I stopped HRT. It took me almost 2 years of trying things out to find what fits. I bought feminine clothes for the first time ever and things fit right and my body shape wasn't scary anymore. I got my first bra a month before that comment and didn't like it, so no bras for me. I kept my chosen name, Isaiah (nickname Isa), because it's 100% legally mine and a pain to change back; I play it off like my parents chose it. I never changed my sex marker back to female on my ID, so it still reads male. I have an obvious Adam's apple from T and I'm quite tall. I still shave my face every now and then. My figure came back, my period took almost 2 years to come back and then about another 6 months to become regular (I gave both "almost 2 years" and "about a year" plus 6 months at different times). The T permanently altered my body and I'll deal with it for the rest of my life, but at least I'm still able to pee normally. My breasts are completely flat on the top half and my ribs are even curved inward underneath them, attributed to binding; I can't get any bras to fit right. I never had children. What moved me toward detransition: getting away from my abusive parents and getting older and more settled in life, I realized I just didn't need it anymore. Once I was away from my family and free to exist however I wanted, I grew out of the need to be someone else. I realized it wasn't fixing my problem, so I tried accepting what I was. I had to be SO gentle with my thinking to not fall into feeling like I deserved misogyny and violence but still accept that reality. I let go of hating being looked at finally and feel free to be pretty. A big factor in snapping out of it was the men I was with while identifying as a trans man: 99% were pretty much only interested in the novelty of a boyish girl (or the T clit), and the other 1% didn't even want me once they met me because my body was a little too female. They were just humoring me and I was lying to myself. The guy I was with at the time I detransitioned couldn't stay with me because of it — he wanted a man, or trans man — but it turned out for the better and we're still pretty close. I said the not-so-normal things I did as a kid turned out to be symptoms from being SA-ed. As a teenager I would have flipped out at the idea of accepting being female and would have self-harmed over never being a real man. Now I'll always be female, even with my Adam's apple and hairy legs and never having children. I'm neutral about religion now and would even call myself religious in a way; I've been comforted recently by the thought of a god. I have serious cardiac issues from T, hospital PTSD, an enlarged clitoris from T, a prominent Adam's apple, altered chest/rib shape from binding, facial hair requiring occasional shaving, and I still don't have fully regular periods. I said I still struggle with dysphoria. I said I'm still insecure about a lot of things and still don't like my breasts. My mom and I had a really tense relationship; after going no contact for years we now can talk and go out to lunch like mostly healthy adults. My parents fought me for years and then realized it was pushing me away so they started being supportive, but I said it was all just me emotionally blackmailing them into it. My friends were relieved when I told them I was detransitioning; the same friend who drove me to my first HRT appointment was happy for me once I stopped identifying as trans. I don't describe an explicit regret list, but I said "I can't believe I wanted it [top surgery] so badly" and that I'm thankful years later I barely avoided it, and that I was "going against every instinct in my body" hoping "trans joy" would come after surgery. I said the T permanently altered my body and I'll deal with it for the rest of my life. I never mentioned suicidal ideation or attempts after detransitioning, only that I wouldn't have survived if I'd had the surgeries. As an adult I've had sexual relationships with both men and women; I said I've hooked up with straight men and that as an adult I've never had a woman be put off by my enlarged clitoris, with much more positive reactions than negative. I said the men I was with while identifying as trans were pretty much bisexual. I'm critical of transition for others: I said "Transitioning is obsessive and unhealthy by default imo," that trans healthcare is a disgrace, that they get paid to mutilate us, that autogynephilia/autoandrophilia is very real and a common motive for transitioning, and that "Trans ideology was literally founded on fetishes." I advise people against surgery and hormones, telling someone considering FFS "absolutely do NOT DO IT" and that "You can be a femboy without hormones OR surgery." I told a parent that a child "needs therapy and to live his life outside his room, not to cut up his body." I've done informal advocacy by commenting extensively in detrans spaces.